Claims: Maliki school
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
32 claims · its own: 12 · the religion as a whole: 20
Maliki school · 12
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim8th–10th c.
At Ghadir Khumm the Prophet appointed Ali as his successor.
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim9th–10th c. (the hadith collections and creeds)
The Prophet appointed no successor, and the community unanimously chose Abu Bakr.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted text11th–20th c.
The Shia hold the Quran to be corrupted: passages about Ali and the Prophet's family are supposed to have been removed.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Not supportedCorrupted text10th–19th c.
When the ʿUthmānic codex was made, passages about Ali and the imams were removed from the Quran.
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim10th–11th c.
Temporary marriage (mutʿa) was permitted by the Quran and the Prophet; only Caliph Umar forbade it.
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrinec. 1310–1320
Their faith bids the Shia hide their convictions and speak untruth (taqiyya), so their word cannot be trusted.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedIdentity10th–12th c.
The Ibadis are Kharijites.
Sunni IslamaboutIbadi Islam
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim20th c. (the dispute since early Islam)
The Sunnis' own collections testify that many Companions “turned back on their heels” after the Prophet's death: in the hadith of the Basin…
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine14th–21st c.
The Shia by doctrine revile and curse the Prophet's Companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Aisha (tabarruʾ); this is part of their faith, not the…
Sunni IslamaboutTwelver (Imami) Shia
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text20th c. (the dispute since the Middle Ages)
The Prophet said: “I leave among you two weighty things — the Book of God and my family (ʿitra), the people of my house”; the version…
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1974 (the dispute since 1891)
“Seal of the prophets” (Quran 33:40) means there will be no prophet of any kind after Muhammad; Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, by declaring himself a…
Sunni IslamaboutAhmadiyya
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim2000–2010
No Jewish Temple ever stood on the Haram al-Sharif; the Jews have no historical connection to al-Aqsa, and the Western Wall is only the…
Sunni IslamaboutJudaism
Islam — the religion as a whole · 20
Entries about the religion as a whole: the direction inherits them.
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesProphecyQuran 61:6 (Medina); the Paraclete identification from the mid-8th c.
Jesus foretold Muhammad: “a messenger whose name is Aḥmad” (Quran 61:6) is the Comforter (Paraclete) promised in John 14–16.
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text20th c.
John 14–16 originally read περικλυτός (“praised one” = Aḥmad), and Christians replaced it with παράκλητος (“comforter”).
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Not supportedDoctrinesura 9 (late Medinan)
“The Jews say: ʿUzayr (Ezra) is the son of God” (Quran 9:30).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesIdentity1994
“Allah” is an ancient Arabian moon god (or Baal), not the God of the Bible.
ProtestantismaboutIslam
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted textQuran (7th c.); the doctrine of textual corruption — Ibn Ḥazm (d. 1064)
The Jews corrupted the Torah (taḥrīf).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted textQuran (7th c.); polemic — 10th–11th c.
Christians corrupted the Gospel (Injīl).
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimMedinan period (sura 4)
Jesus was neither killed nor crucified; it was only made to appear so (Quran 4:157).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationProphecy9th–14th c.
“A prophet from among their brothers, like you” (Deut 18:15–18) is Muhammad: Israel's “brothers” are the descendants of Ishmael.
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrineMedinan period (sura 5)
Christians took Jesus and his mother “as two gods besides God” and say “God is the third of three” (Quran 5:116; 5:73; 4:171).
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Partly supportedOrigin8th–10th c.
Paul and the later church turned Jesus' prophetic monotheism into the worship of Christ as God.
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Not supportedProphecymid-8th – 9th c.
The Christian monk Baḥīrā at Bostra recognised the boy Muhammad as a future prophet by signs from his books.
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: A matter of interpretationIdentityMedinan period (sura 3)
Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian but a ḥanīf surrendered to God (Quran 3:65–67).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: SupportedDoctrinec. 1170–1180
Muslims are not idolaters: they confess God's strict unity (Maimonides).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutIslam
Verdict: Partly supportedOriginc. 743
Muhammad composed his teaching after coming across the Old and New Testaments and conversing with an Arian monk (John of Damascus).
The Early ChurchaboutIslam
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted text9th–10th c.
The Quran did not come down in its original form: it was edited under ʿUthmān and other copies were burned (the Apology of al-Kindī).
ChristianityaboutIslam
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine10th–12th c.
The Zoroastrians worship fire and acknowledge two gods.
IslamaboutThe Zoroastrian community
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim22 September 2009 (Al-Ahram)
Coins from Joseph's time, bearing his name and image, have been found in the Egyptian Museum.
IslamaboutThe patriarchs: Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (by tradition)
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text1908 (manuscripts 16th c.)
The Gospel of Barnabas is an authentic early Gospel suppressed by the Church: in it Jesus denies being the Son of God, names Muhammad as…
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Not supportedProphecy1976
Muhammad's name appears in the Hebrew Bible: Song of Songs 5:16 has the word “machmadim” — “Muhammad” with a plural of respect; the Jews…
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim7th c.
The Children of Israel killed their prophets without right (Quran 2:61; 3:112; 4:155) — for this God's wrath came upon them.
IslamaboutJudaism