Skip to content

Claim · Corrupted text

The Shia hold the Quran to be corrupted: passages about Ali and the Prophet's family are supposed to have been removed.

Verdict: Partly supported11th–20th c.

Who claims

Sunni Islam· Islam

About

Shia Islam· Islam

Where it is claimed

2
  • Ibn Hazm, al-Fisal fi al-Milal (11th c.)not in the library

  • Ihsan Ilahi Zahir, al-Shiʿa wa-l-Qurʾan (1983)not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Partly supported

Traditions about omissions do stand in the early Shia collections, and some scholars defended them as late as the 19th century; so far the claim has a basis. But since the 10th century the prevailing Twelver teaching has been that the Quran is intact, and they read the same text. As a description of Shia doctrine as a whole the claim does not match the sources.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

5
  • Text

    al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Book of the Excellence of the Quran; al-Nuri al-Tabarsi, Fasl al-Khitab (1881)not in the library

    Traditions about omissions from the Quran do stand in the early Imami collections; al-Nuri defended them in the 19th century.

  • Text

    Ibn Babawayh (al-Saduq, d. 991), Risalat al-Iʿtiqadatnot in the library

    “Our belief is that the Quran revealed to Muhammad is what is between the two covers and in people's hands, and no more.”

  • Text

    al-Tusi, al-Tibyan; al-Tabrisi, Majmaʿ al-Bayan; al-Khoei, al-Bayan (1957)not in the library

    The leading Shia commentators of the 11th–20th centuries reject the view that the text was altered.

  • Manuscripts

    Quran (Tanzil, ʿUthmānic text)

    Shia and Sunni read one and the same text; there is no separate “Shia Quran” in the manuscripts.

  • Scholarship

    H. Modarressi, Studia Islamica 77 (1993); E. Kohlberg, M. A. Amir-Moezzi, Revelation and Falsification (2009)not in the library

    The history of the debate on the integrity of the Quran in early Shiism.

The Shia hold the Quran to be corrupted: passages about Ali and the Prophet's family are… · Versemora