Claim · Doctrine
The Shia by doctrine revile and curse the Prophet's Companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Aisha (tabarruʾ); this is part of their faith, not the…
Who claims
Sunni Islam· Islam
About
Twelver (Imami) Shia· Islam
Claim
Where it is claimed
1Ibn Taymiyya, Minhaj al-Sunna (14th c.); Sunni heresiographical literaturenot in the library
What the sources show
That Shia doctrine condemns Abu Bakr, Umar and some Companions over the caliphate, and that ritual cursing was practised — including by the Safavid state — is supported. But cursing cannot be called a required part of Shia faith: leading authorities (Khamenei in 2010) forbid insult.
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
3Scholarship
R. Jaʿfariyan; K. Babayan, Mystics, Monarchs and Messiahs (2002): the tabarraʾiyan under the Safavidsnot in the library
Under the Safavids (16th c.) public cursing of the first caliphs was state practice: the “tabarraʾiyan” cursed them in the streets. Ritual cursing also appears in some Shia devotional texts (Ziyarat ʿAshura).
Text
Fatwa of Ayatollah Khamenei of 30 September 2010not in the library
Iran's leader, answering Shia scholars of al-Ahsa, declared it forbidden to insult “the symbols of the Sunnis”, including the Prophet's wives, after Yasir al-Habib's attack on Aisha; al-Azhar welcomed the fatwa.
Scholarship
Amman Message (2004–2005)not in the library
Shia and Sunni scholars recognised each other as Muslims; Shia criticism of the Companions is a doctrinal judgement on their acts (over the caliphate), while cursing is a practice some Shia authorities permit and others forbid.