Skip to content

Claim · Doctrine

The Shia by doctrine revile and curse the Prophet's Companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Aisha (tabarruʾ); this is part of their faith, not the…

Verdict: Partly supported14th–21st c.

Who claims

Sunni Islam· Islam

Claim

The Shia by doctrine revile and curse the Prophet's Companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Aisha (tabarruʾ); this is part of their faith, not the acts of individuals.

Where it is claimed

1
  • Ibn Taymiyya, Minhaj al-Sunna (14th c.); Sunni heresiographical literaturenot in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Partly supported

That Shia doctrine condemns Abu Bakr, Umar and some Companions over the caliphate, and that ritual cursing was practised — including by the Safavid state — is supported. But cursing cannot be called a required part of Shia faith: leading authorities (Khamenei in 2010) forbid insult.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

3
  • Scholarship

    R. Jaʿfariyan; K. Babayan, Mystics, Monarchs and Messiahs (2002): the tabarraʾiyan under the Safavidsnot in the library

    Under the Safavids (16th c.) public cursing of the first caliphs was state practice: the “tabarraʾiyan” cursed them in the streets. Ritual cursing also appears in some Shia devotional texts (Ziyarat ʿAshura).

  • Text

    Fatwa of Ayatollah Khamenei of 30 September 2010not in the library

    Iran's leader, answering Shia scholars of al-Ahsa, declared it forbidden to insult “the symbols of the Sunnis”, including the Prophet's wives, after Yasir al-Habib's attack on Aisha; al-Azhar welcomed the fatwa.

  • Scholarship

    Amman Message (2004–2005)not in the library

    Shia and Sunni scholars recognised each other as Muslims; Shia criticism of the Companions is a doctrinal judgement on their acts (over the caliphate), while cursing is a practice some Shia authorities permit and others forbid.

The Shia by doctrine revile and curse the Prophet's Companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Aisha… · Versemora