Skip to content

Claim · Doctrine

Their faith bids the Shia hide their convictions and speak untruth (taqiyya), so their word cannot be trusted.

Verdict: Partly supportedc. 1310–1320

Who claims

Sunni Islam· Islam

About

Shia Islam· Islam

Where it is claimed

1
  • Ibn Taymiyya, Minhaj al-Sunna (c. 1310–1320)not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Partly supported

Taqiyya, concealing one's faith under threat, is indeed part of Twelver teaching; so far the claim has a basis. But the notion rests on verses of the Quran that Sunni commentators also read as permission to hide one's faith under compulsion. The conclusion that the word of the Shia cannot be trusted at all does not follow from the texts.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

5
  • Text

    Quran 3:28

    “…unless you guard yourselves against them” (tuqātan) — the verse on which the notion itself rests.

  • Text

    Quran 16:106

    One who denies under compulsion, “while his heart is at rest in faith”, is not condemned.

  • Text

    Sura 3: Aal-i-Imraan (The Family of Imraan) — آل عمران, Sura 3: Aal-i-Imraan (The Family of Imraan) — آل عمرانJalalayn (Arabic)

    Tafsīr al-Jalālayn on 3:28

    A Sunni commentary: in danger it is allowed to show friendship “with the tongue but not the heart”.

  • Text

    al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, Book of Faith and Unbelief, chapter on taqiyyanot in the library

    A saying ascribed to the imams Muhammad al-Baqir and Jaʿfar al-Sadiq: “Taqiyya is my religion and the religion of my fathers.”

  • Scholarship

    E. Kohlberg, “Some Imāmī-Shīʿī Views on Taqiyya”, JAOS 95 (1975)not in the library

    The doctrine took shape under persecution; Shia law limits it to cases of danger.

Their faith bids the Shia hide their convictions and speak untruth (taqiyya), so their… · Versemora