Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

Coins from Joseph's time, bearing his name and image, have been found in the Egyptian Museum.

Verdict: Contradicted by the sources22 September 2009 (Al-Ahram)

Claim

Coins from Joseph's time, bearing his name and image, have been found in the Egyptian Museum. So the Cairo daily Al-Ahram reported in September 2009, citing researchers led by Saʿīd Muḥammad Thābit: objects in the storerooms taken for amulets turned out, they said, to be coins with a year of minting and a value, one of them with Joseph's name and portrait; this, they said, confirms the Quran, where Joseph is sold “for a few dirhams” (12:20). The report spread across Jewish and Christian websites.

Where it is claimed

2
  • Wajih al-Saqqar, Al-Ahram, 22 September 2009; translation: MEMRI Special Dispatch No. 2561 (24 September 2009)not in the library

  • Quran 12:20Quran (Tanzil)

    Quran 12:20 (cited by the report)

What the sources show

Verdict: Contradicted by the sources

There were no coins anywhere before the late 7th century BCE, and Egypt began to strike them only in the 4th century BCE — a thousand years after any traditional date for Joseph; both the Bible and the Egyptian documents of the 2nd millennium BCE describe weighed silver. Objects of that age with royal names are scarabs, seals and amulets, not money. The report was never confirmed by a scholarly publication or by the museum.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

6
  • Scholarship

    C. M. Kraay, Archaic and Classical Greek Coins (1976)not in the library

    Coinage was invented in Lydia and the Ionian cities of Asia Minor in the late 7th century BCE (the electrum coins from the Artemision at Ephesus) — more than a thousand years after the tradition places Joseph.

  • Archaeology

    M. Price, N. Waggoner, Archaic Greek Coinage: The Asyut Hoard (1975); S. von Reden, Money in Ptolemaic Egypt (2007)not in the library

    Greek coins reached Egypt in the 6th–5th c. BCE as silver by weight (the Asyut hoard, c. 475 BCE); the first coins struck in Egypt itself date from the 4th c. BCE (the gold staters of Nectanebo II), and a regular coinage came with the Ptolemies.

  • Text

    Gen 37:28WLC

    Genesis 37:28

    In the Bible Joseph is sold “for twenty [shekels] of silver” — the shekel here is a weight.

  • Text

    Gen 43:21WLC

    Genesis 43:21

    The brothers bring back their silver “in full weight” (kaspenu be-mishqalo): silver was weighed, not counted out in coins.

  • Internal evidence

    Quran 12:20

    “And they sold him for a paltry price, a few dirhams.” The word dirham comes from the Greek drachma, a coin of the Quran's own time; Tafsir al-Jalalayn explains: twenty or twenty-two dirhams. The verse says nothing about minting in Egypt.

  • Scholarship

    J. R. Davila, PaleoJudaica, 25 September 2009; D. O. McClellan (blog, September 2009)not in the library

    No publication or photograph of a “Joseph coin” followed; in the pictures that went with the report scholars recognised scarabs — seal-amulets that often carry royal names.

Photographs

1