Skip to content

Claim · Corrupted text

When the ʿUthmānic codex was made, passages about Ali and the imams were removed from the Quran.

Verdict: Not supported10th–19th c.

Who claims

Shia Islam· Islam

About

Sunni Islam· Islam

Claim

When the ʿUthmānic codex was made, passages about Ali and the imams were removed from the Quran. So some early Shia traditions say; most Shia scholars reject them.

Where it is claimed

1
  • Ali ibn Ibrahim al-Qummi, Tafsir (10th c.); al-Nuri al-Tabarsi, Fasl al-Khitab (1881)not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Not supported

No manuscript contains such passages, and the “suras” about Ali appear only in the 17th century. The reports of the redaction under ʿUthmān speak of variant readings, not of removed sections. The same standard as for the charges that the Bible was altered.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

4
  • Text

    فضائل القرآن, 4987Bukhari

    al-Bukhārī 4987

    ʿUthmān had the sheets copied into standard codices and the others burned, because of disagreements in recitation; the report says nothing of removed passages about Ali.

  • Manuscripts

    Sanaa palimpsest (DAM 01-27.1), lower text; Birmingham folios (Mingana 1572a)not in the library

    The oldest manuscripts, including those with pre-ʿUthmānic variants, contain no passages about Ali or the imams.

  • Scholarship

    Dabistan-i Madhahib (17th c.): the “Sura of the Two Lights”; W. St. Clair Tisdall, The Moslem World 3 (1913)not in the library

    The “suras” about Ali first appear in the 17th century; both Shia and Western scholars regard them as a late forgery.

  • Internal evidence

    Ibn Babawayh, Risalat al-Iʿtiqadat; al-Khoei, al-Bayan (1957)not in the library

    The Shia tradition itself, in its chief authorities, rejects this view.

When the ʿUthmānic codex was made, passages about Ali and the imams were removed from the… · Versemora