Claim · Identity
“Allah” is an ancient Arabian moon god (or Baal), not the God of the Bible.
Who claims
Protestantism· Christianity
About
Islam· as a whole
Where it is claimed
2R. Morey, The Moon-God Allah in the Archeology of the Middle East (1994)not in the library
Popular evangelical tracts and online polemic (the Baal identification)not in the library
What the sources show
The linguistic and epigraphic evidence shows “Allāh” to be the Arabic word for God, used by pre-Islamic Arab Christians for the God of the Bible; Arabia's moon deities had other names, and the Islamic sources set Hubal against Allah. The claim contradicts the sources. (Whether Jews, Christians and Muslims understand God in the same way is a separate theological question that evidence does not settle.)
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
5Scholarship
Etymology: Arabic Allāh < al-ilāh “the God”; Aramaic/Syriac ʾAlāhā; Hebrew ʾElōahnot in the library
The word is the common Semitic term for God with the article; it does not derive from Baal (b-ʿ-l, “lord”).
Archaeology
Trilingual inscription of Zabad (512 CE), martyrium of St Sergiusnot in the library
Pre-Islamic Arab Christians invoke “al-ilāh” — the same God as in the Greek and Syriac parts of the inscription.
Text
Gen, 1:1Peshitta OT
Peshitta, Genesis 1:1
The Syriac Bible calls God “ʾAlāhā” — a cognate; Arabic Bibles and Arab Christians still say “Allāh”.
Text
الجهاد والسير, 3039Bukhari
Bukhari 3039 (battle of Uhud)
Abu Sufyan cries “Be exalted, Hubal!”, the Muslims answer “Allah is higher” — the Islamic sources set Hubal (the Kaaba idol) against Allah.
Scholarship
South Arabian epigraphy: ʿAmm, Wadd, Sīn; Almaqah (J. Ryckmans; A. Jamme)not in the library
The moon and other deities of South Arabia had their own names; the Hazor temple cited by Morey is Canaanite, 2nd millennium BCE, and unrelated to Arabia. The crescent became an Islamic emblem only in the Ottoman era.