Claims: Jansenism
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
43 claims · its own: 25 · the religion as a whole: 18
Jansenism · 25
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimcomposed c. 750–850; invoked by the papal side in the dispute of 1053–1054
Emperor Constantine I granted the popes primacy over the Eastern patriarchs and rule over the West (the “Donation of Constantine”).
CatholicismaboutEastern Orthodoxy
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine1240
The Talmud blasphemes Jesus and Mary and should be banned and burned (Nicholas Donin, 1240).
CatholicismaboutRabbinic Judaism
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text1054 (after Photius, 867)
The Latins added the words “and from the Son” (Filioque) to the Creed on their own authority.
Eastern OrthodoxyaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text1054
The Greeks, “like the Pneumatomachi”, cut out of the Creed the procession of the Holy Spirit from the Son (Cardinal Humbert's bull, 1054).
CatholicismaboutEastern Orthodoxy
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1610 (the legend from c. 1250)
In the 9th century a woman reigned as pope (“Pope Joan”), exposed when she gave birth during a procession.
ProtestantismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1537–1646
The Pope of Rome is the Antichrist, the “man of sin” (2 Thess 2).
ProtestantismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1591–1593
Luther killed himself (by hanging), and his death from illness is an invention of his followers.
CatholicismaboutLutheranism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1604
Elizabeth's first archbishop, Matthew Parker, was “consecrated” in a mock ceremony at the Nag's Head tavern, not according to any rite.
CatholicismaboutAnglicanism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesOrigin1931 (Landmarkism from the 1850s)
Baptist churches have existed in unbroken succession since the apostles (“The Trail of Blood”).
Southern Baptist ConventionaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesOrigin14th–17th c.
The Waldensians are older than Valdes: they are the apostolic remnant from Pope Sylvester's time.
WaldensiansaboutCatholicism
Verdict: UnverifiableDoctrinec. 1523–1524
Moscow is the Third Rome, the last Christian empire.
Russian Orthodox ChurchaboutCatholicism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1870 (Pastor Aeternus; the dispute since the 5th–11th c.)
Christ gave the apostle Peter, and through him the bishops of Rome as his successors, a primacy of jurisdiction over the whole Church…
CatholicismaboutEastern Orthodoxy
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine1053–1054
The Latins celebrate the liturgy with unleavened bread (azymes) — a Jewish custom and an innovation; Christ and the apostles celebrated the…
Eastern OrthodoxyaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine1438 (Ferrara–Florence)
The doctrine of purgatory — a distinct place where souls undergo temporal punishment, including by fire, to make satisfaction for sins — is…
Eastern OrthodoxyaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine1755
Latin baptism by pouring is invalid: apostolic baptism is only by threefold immersion, so those who come from the Latins must be baptised…
Eastern OrthodoxyaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Partly supportedOrigin16th c. (Trent, 1546)
The principle of “Scripture alone” (sola scriptura) was invented by Luther and the Reformers in the 16th century; the ancient Church knew…
CatholicismaboutProtestantism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesOrigin19th–20th c.
The Catholic Church was founded by Emperor Constantine in the 4th century by merging Christianity with paganism; before him there was no…
Protestant fundamentalismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text16th–17th c.
Rome added the Apocrypha (Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch) to the Bible at the Council of Trent in 1546 to support the…
ProtestantismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted text19th–20th c.
The Protestants (Luther) threw seven books out of the Bible because they contradicted their teaching.
CatholicismaboutProtestantism
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text1522 (September Testament) – 1530
Luther added to Rom 3:28 the word “alone” (allein), which is not in the Greek text, to support his doctrine of justification by faith alone.
CatholicismaboutLutheranism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesDoctrine19th–20th c.
Catholics worship the Virgin Mary as a goddess: they give her divine worship and pray to her in place of God.
EvangelicalismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim19th–20th c.
Jesuits at their induction swear a secret “Extreme Oath” to exterminate Protestants — to “burn, boil, flay” — in obedience to the pope.
Protestant fundamentalismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim1517
The Church sold indulgences for money, promising to release souls from purgatory: “as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from…
LutheranismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1896–1897
Anglican ordinations are “absolutely null and utterly void” through defect of form (the Edwardine Ordinal of 1550/1552 does not express the…
CatholicismaboutAnglicanism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1888–1911
The papacy “thought to change times and laws” (Dan 7:25): it transferred the holiness of the Sabbath to Sunday, and Sunday observance is…
Adventism (Seventh-day Adventists)aboutCatholicism
Christianity — the religion as a whole · 18
Entries about the religion as a whole: the direction inherits them.
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesProphecyQuran 61:6 (Medina); the Paraclete identification from the mid-8th c.
Jesus foretold Muhammad: “a messenger whose name is Aḥmad” (Quran 61:6) is the Comforter (Paraclete) promised in John 14–16.
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text20th c.
John 14–16 originally read περικλυτός (“praised one” = Aḥmad), and Christians replaced it with παράκλητος (“comforter”).
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Not supportedHistorical claimfrom c. 178 (Celsus); the narrative — 6th–10th c.
Jesus was the illegitimate son of a soldier, Pandera (Panthera), and worked miracles with the stolen Name of God (Toledot Yeshu).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted textQuran (7th c.); polemic — 10th–11th c.
Christians corrupted the Gospel (Injīl).
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrineMedinan period (sura 5)
Christians took Jesus and his mother “as two gods besides God” and say “God is the third of three” (Quran 5:116; 5:73; 4:171).
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Partly supportedOrigin8th–10th c.
Paul and the later church turned Jesus' prophetic monotheism into the worship of Christ as God.
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: Not supportedProphecymid-8th – 9th c.
The Christian monk Baḥīrā at Bostra recognised the boy Muhammad as a future prophet by signs from his books.
IslamaboutChristianity
Verdict: UnverifiableHistorical claimlate 1st c. (attested in Matthew)
The disciples stole Jesus' body by night, which is why the tomb was empty.
Second Temple JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: A matter of interpretationProphecyRashi (11th c.); the Jewish reading known from the 3rd c.
The Suffering Servant of Isa 52:13–53:12 is the people of Israel, not the Messiah Jesus.
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: A matter of interpretationDoctrine1168 (Commentary on the Mishnah)
Christians are idolaters (ʿovdei ʿavodah zarah), so the laws on idolatry apply to them (Maimonides).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimfrom c. 1150 (Norwich) to 1913 (Kyiv)
Jews murder Christian children and use their blood in rituals (the “blood libel”).
ChristianityaboutRabbinic Judaism
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted text9th–10th c.
The Quran did not come down in its original form: it was edited under ʿUthmān and other copies were burned (the Apology of al-Kindī).
ChristianityaboutIslam
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimfrom the 6th c. (Julius Honorius, Gregory of Tours); 1998 and 2015 (B. Carson)
The Egyptian pyramids are granaries built by Joseph.
ChristianityaboutThe patriarchs: Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (by tradition)
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesProphecy2011
On 21 May 2011 the faithful will be 'raptured' and the Day of Judgement will begin, and on 21 October 2011 the world will be destroyed…
ChristianityaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text1830
The “great and abominable church” took away from the Bible “many parts which are plain and most precious” of the gospel and covenants of…
Latter-day Saints (Mormons)aboutChristianity
Verdict: Not supportedCorrupted text1950
In John 1:1 the anarthrous θεός must be rendered indefinitely — “the Word was a god”; Trinitarian translators distorted the verse by…
Jehovah's WitnessesaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1899–1908
Jesus did not die on the cross nor rise again: he survived, went east to the lost tribes of Israel, died in Kashmir in old age and lies…
AhmadiyyaaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted text1908 (manuscripts 16th c.)
The Gospel of Barnabas is an authentic early Gospel suppressed by the Church: in it Jesus denies being the Son of God, names Muhammad as…
IslamaboutChristianity