Claim · Historical claim
Jesus did not die on the cross nor rise again: he survived, went east to the lost tribes of Israel, died in Kashmir in old age and lies…
Who claims
Ahmadiyya· Islam
About
Christianity· as a whole
Claim
Where it is claimed
2Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, Masih Hindustan Mein (Jesus in India, 1899, publ. 1908)not in the library
Quran 23:50Quran (Tanzil)
Quran 23:50 (“We gave them shelter on a height with rest and springs”) in the Ahmadi reading
What the sources show
Jesus' death on the cross is attested by Christian and non-Christian sources of the 1st–2nd c.; the Roza Bal shrine is known from the 18th century as the grave of Yuz Asaf, a name going back to a Buddha legend, and the link to Jesus arose in the late 19th century. The resurrection is a matter of faith, but the Kashmir burial account contradicts the sources.
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
4Scholarship
Tacitus, Annals XV.44; Josephus, Antiquities XVIII.63–64 (the core text)not in the library
Non-Christian sources of the 1st–2nd c. report that Jesus was executed under Pontius Pilate; none of them speaks of survival.
Scholarship
Khwaja Muhammad Aʿzam Didamari, history of Kashmir (1747); Hajji Muhyiddin, Tahrik-i kabir-i Kashmir (1902)not in the library
The shrine is first described in 1747 as the grave of a foreign prophet-prince “Yuz Asaf”; the identification with Jesus first appears only in the 1890s–1900s.
Scholarship
The tale of Barlaam and Josaphat: Arabic Bilawhar wa Budhasaf (8th c.); P. Almond, “The Buddha of Christendom” (1987)not in the library
The name Yuzasaf/Budhasaf goes back through the Arabic tale to the Sanskrit “bodhisattva” — a legend of the Buddha, not of Jesus.
Text
Quran 4:158Quran (Tanzil)
Quran 4:157–158
Sunnis read “God raised him to Himself” as a bodily ascension while alive — the Ahmadi account contradicts both Christian and Sunni teaching.