Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

Jesus did not die on the cross nor rise again: he survived, went east to the lost tribes of Israel, died in Kashmir in old age and lies…

Verdict: Contradicted by the sources1899–1908

Who claims

Ahmadiyya· Islam

About

Christianity· as a whole

Claim

Jesus did not die on the cross nor rise again: he survived, went east to the lost tribes of Israel, died in Kashmir in old age and lies buried in Srinagar in the Roza Bal shrine under the name Yuz Asaf.

Where it is claimed

2
  • Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, Masih Hindustan Mein (Jesus in India, 1899, publ. 1908)not in the library

  • Quran 23:50Quran (Tanzil)

    Quran 23:50 (“We gave them shelter on a height with rest and springs”) in the Ahmadi reading

What the sources show

Verdict: Contradicted by the sources

Jesus' death on the cross is attested by Christian and non-Christian sources of the 1st–2nd c.; the Roza Bal shrine is known from the 18th century as the grave of Yuz Asaf, a name going back to a Buddha legend, and the link to Jesus arose in the late 19th century. The resurrection is a matter of faith, but the Kashmir burial account contradicts the sources.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

4
  • Scholarship

    Tacitus, Annals XV.44; Josephus, Antiquities XVIII.63–64 (the core text)not in the library

    Non-Christian sources of the 1st–2nd c. report that Jesus was executed under Pontius Pilate; none of them speaks of survival.

  • Scholarship

    Khwaja Muhammad Aʿzam Didamari, history of Kashmir (1747); Hajji Muhyiddin, Tahrik-i kabir-i Kashmir (1902)not in the library

    The shrine is first described in 1747 as the grave of a foreign prophet-prince “Yuz Asaf”; the identification with Jesus first appears only in the 1890s–1900s.

  • Scholarship

    The tale of Barlaam and Josaphat: Arabic Bilawhar wa Budhasaf (8th c.); P. Almond, “The Buddha of Christendom” (1987)not in the library

    The name Yuzasaf/Budhasaf goes back through the Arabic tale to the Sanskrit “bodhisattva” — a legend of the Buddha, not of Jesus.

  • Text

    Quran 4:158Quran (Tanzil)

    Quran 4:157–158

    Sunnis read “God raised him to Himself” as a bodily ascension while alive — the Ahmadi account contradicts both Christian and Sunni teaching.

Jesus did not die on the cross nor rise again: he survived, went east to the lost tribes… · Versemora