Claim · Historical claim
The Church sold indulgences for money, promising to release souls from purgatory: “as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from…
Who claims
Lutheranism· Christianity
About
Catholicism· Christianity
Claim
Where it is claimed
1M. Luther, Ninety-five Theses (1517), theses 27–28not in the library
What the sources show
That indulgences around 1500 were granted for money and that preachers promised immediate release of souls is confirmed by the sources and acknowledged by the Council of Trent itself. The coin couplet is a saying attributed to Tetzel; Catholic teaching on indulgences as such is not exhausted by it.
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
2Scholarship
Instruction of Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz (Instructio summaria, 1515); the preaching of Johann Tetzelnot in the library
The indulgence for building St Peter's was granted for set payments; half the German proceeds went to Albrecht to repay his debt to the Fugger bankers. Indulgences for the dead were granted without the giver's repentance.
Text
Paragraph 1Council of Trent (English)
Council of Trent, session 25, decree on indulgences (1563)
The council, while retaining indulgences, acknowledges “abuses” and orders that “all evil gains” from them be “wholly abolished”; in 1567 Pius V forbade attaching them to money payments.