Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

Emperor Constantine I granted the popes primacy over the Eastern patriarchs and rule over the West (the “Donation of Constantine”).

Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcescomposed c. 750–850; invoked by the papal side in the dispute of 1053–1054

Who claims

Catholicism· Christianity

About

Eastern Orthodoxy· Christianity

Claim

Emperor Constantine I granted the popes primacy over the Eastern patriarchs and rule over the West (the “Donation of Constantine”). The charter was supposedly given to Pope Sylvester (314–335) and his successors.

Where it is claimed

2
  • Constitutum Constantini (composed c. 750–850), included in the Pseudo-Isidorian Decretalsnot in the library

  • Pope Leo IX, letter to Patriarch Michael Cerularius “In terra pax” (1053)not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Contradicted by the sources

The document was composed more than four centuries after Constantine; this was shown already in the 15th century (Nicholas of Cusa, Valla) and is universally accepted, including by Catholic historians. Its use in the disputes with the East (1053–1054) rested on a forged text.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

4
  • Scholarship

    Lorenzo Valla, De falso credita et ementita Constantini donatione (1440)not in the library

    The charter's language is 8th-century Latin with anachronisms (e.g. “satraps”; Constantinople is named a patriarchal see although the charter is dated before the city was founded in 330); the early sources on Constantine and Sylvester are silent about any donation.

  • Scholarship

    Nicholas of Cusa, De concordantia catholica, book III (1433)not in the library

    Independently of Valla showed that the charter is absent from early collections and from Constantine's contemporaries.

  • Text

    Eusebius of Caesarea, Life of Constantine (c. 337–339)not in the library

    The detailed contemporary source on Constantine knows neither the donation nor the healing from leprosy by Sylvester.

  • Scholarship

    H. Fuhrmann (ed.), Das Constitutum Constantini, MGH Fontes iuris 10 (1968)not in the library

    The critical edition dates the text to the second half of the 8th century (Rome).