Claims
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
40 claims
Verdict: Not supportedHistorical claimfrom c. 178 (Celsus); the narrative — 6th–10th c.
Jesus was the illegitimate son of a soldier, Pandera (Panthera), and worked miracles with the stolen Name of God (Toledot Yeshu).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimcomposed c. 750–850; invoked by the papal side in the dispute of 1053–1054
Emperor Constantine I granted the popes primacy over the Eastern patriarchs and rule over the West (the “Donation of Constantine”).
CatholicismaboutEastern Orthodoxy
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimMedinan period (sura 4)
Jesus was neither killed nor crucified; it was only made to appear so (Quran 4:157).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: UnverifiableHistorical claimlate 1st c. (attested in Matthew)
The disciples stole Jesus' body by night, which is why the tomb was empty.
Second Temple JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim
The Samaritans preserved the Torah's ancient script, while the Jews after the exile switched to another (“Assyrian”) script.
The Samaritan communityaboutSecond Temple Judaism
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claimc. 170 (Melito); the term “deicide” — 4th c.
The Jews (as a people) killed Christ and are guilty of “deicide”.
The Early ChurchaboutJudaism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimfrom c. 1150 (Norwich) to 1913 (Kyiv)
Jews murder Christian children and use their blood in rituals (the “blood libel”).
ChristianityaboutRabbinic Judaism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1610 (the legend from c. 1250)
In the 9th century a woman reigned as pope (“Pope Joan”), exposed when she gave birth during a procession.
ProtestantismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1591–1593
Luther killed himself (by hanging), and his death from illness is an invention of his followers.
CatholicismaboutLutheranism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1604
Elizabeth's first archbishop, Matthew Parker, was “consecrated” in a mock ceremony at the Nag's Head tavern, not according to any rite.
CatholicismaboutAnglicanism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim2018
The Kyiv Metropolis has belonged to the Moscow Patriarchate since 1686, so the OCU's autocephaly is uncanonical.
Russian Orthodox ChurchaboutOrthodox Church of Ukraine
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claimlate 3rd c.
The Book of Daniel was written under Antiochus Epiphanes (2nd c. BCE), and its “prophecies” are history after the fact (Porphyry).
NeoplatonismaboutThe Early Church
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim4th c. (known to Jerome in 392)
The Stoic Seneca corresponded with the Apostle Paul and admired his teaching (14 letters).
The Early ChurchaboutStoicism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim8th–10th c.
At Ghadir Khumm the Prophet appointed Ali as his successor.
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim9th–10th c. (the hadith collections and creeds)
The Prophet appointed no successor, and the community unanimously chose Abu Bakr.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim10th–11th c.
Temporary marriage (mutʿa) was permitted by the Quran and the Prophet; only Caliph Umar forbade it.
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1656–1667
The two-finger sign and the other old Russian rites are a recent corruption that crept in through ignorance; to hold to them is heresy.
Russian Orthodox ChurchaboutOld Believers
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claimc. 80–90 (the Gospel of Matthew)
The Pharisees are hypocrites: they say and do not do, and care for outward things.
The Early ChurchaboutPharisees
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim2nd–1st c. BCE
The high priest in Jerusalem is the “Wicked Priest”, and the festivals are kept there on the wrong days.
Essenes and the Qumran communityaboutSecond Temple Judaism
Verdict: Not supportedHistorical claim1995 (D. Rohl's book); 2014 (the film)
Joseph's palace, tomb and statue have been found at Avaris (Tell el-Dabʿa).
EvangelicalismaboutThe patriarchs: Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (by tradition)
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim22 September 2009 (Al-Ahram)
Coins from Joseph's time, bearing his name and image, have been found in the Egyptian Museum.
IslamaboutThe patriarchs: Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (by tradition)
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claimfrom the 6th c. (Julius Honorius, Gregory of Tours); 1998 and 2015 (B. Carson)
The Egyptian pyramids are granaries built by Joseph.
ChristianityaboutThe patriarchs: Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (by tradition)
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim1990–1993
The Eastern Catholic (“Uniate”) churches were created by Rome to detach the Orthodox from their Church under pressure from the state: union…
Eastern OrthodoxyaboutEastern Catholic churches
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1946
The Lviv council of 1946 was the free decision of the Greek Catholics of Galicia to return to Orthodoxy and annul the Union of Brest.
Russian Orthodox ChurchaboutEastern Catholic churches
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim19th–20th c.
Jesuits at their induction swear a secret “Extreme Oath” to exterminate Protestants — to “burn, boil, flay” — in obedience to the pope.
Protestant fundamentalismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim1517
The Church sold indulgences for money, promising to release souls from purgatory: “as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from…
LutheranismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim1918
The miraculous gifts — tongues, prophecy, healing — ceased with the end of the apostolic age; church history knows them no more after the…
Reformed Christianity (Calvinism)aboutPentecostalism
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim1924–1935
The Church of Greece's move to the new (Revised Julian) calendar in 1924 falls under the anathemas of the Constantinopolitan councils of…
Old Calendarists (True Orthodox)aboutChurch of Greece
Verdict: UnverifiableHistorical claim1830–1838
After the death of the apostles the Church fell into a universal apostasy: priesthood authority was taken from the earth, and there was no…
Latter-day Saints (Mormons)aboutThe Early Church
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1888–1911
The papacy “thought to change times and laws” (Dan 7:25): it transferred the holiness of the Sabbath to Sunday, and Sunday observance is…
Adventism (Seventh-day Adventists)aboutCatholicism
Verdict: A matter of interpretationHistorical claim20th c. (the dispute since early Islam)
The Sunnis' own collections testify that many Companions “turned back on their heels” after the Prophet's death: in the hadith of the Basin…
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim14th–20th c.
The mourning rites of ʿAshura — processions, self-flagellation, bloodletting (tatbir) — are an innovation (bidʿa) introduced by the Buyids…
Wahhabism and SalafismaboutTwelver (Imami) Shia
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim14th–20th c.
Celebrating the Prophet's birthday (mawlid) is an innovation unknown to the Prophet, the Companions and the first three generations; the…
Wahhabism and SalafismaboutSufism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1899–1908
Jesus did not die on the cross nor rise again: he survived, went east to the lost tribes of Israel, died in Kashmir in old age and lies…
AhmadiyyaaboutChristianity
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim1848
In 1848 at Tabriz the Bab publicly recanted his claims and repented in writing — so he himself did not regard himself as the Qaʾim.
Twelver (Imami) ShiaaboutBabism
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim7th c.
The Children of Israel killed their prophets without right (Quran 2:61; 3:112; 4:155) — for this God's wrath came upon them.
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Not supportedHistorical claim2010s
The rabbis removed Isaiah 53 from the haftarah readings in the synagogue because it speaks too clearly of Jesus: it is “the forbidden…
Messianic JudaismaboutRabbinic Judaism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim1988
The Zionist plan has no bounds and is laid down in the “Protocols of the Elders of Zion”; with their money they were behind the French and…
Muslim BrotherhoodaboutJudaism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim2000–2010
No Jewish Temple ever stood on the Haram al-Sharif; the Jews have no historical connection to al-Aqsa, and the Western Wall is only the…
Sunni IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesHistorical claim2005–2014
The mass murder of the Jews of Europe is a myth, or at least an exaggeration, fabricated to justify the State of Israel; its reality is…
Twelver (Imami) ShiaaboutJudaism