Skip to content

Claim · Historical claim

Joseph's palace, tomb and statue have been found at Avaris (Tell el-Dabʿa).

Verdict: Not supported1995 (D. Rohl's book); 2014 (the film)

Claim

Joseph's palace, tomb and statue have been found at Avaris (Tell el-Dabʿa). So holds the Egyptologist David Rohl (A Test of Time, 1995; he calls himself a historian without a religious aim): a late Middle Kingdom house with a garden cemetery, its chief tomb, found without a body, and the smashed statue of an Asiatic in a multicoloured cloak belonged to the biblical Joseph, whose remains, his followers add, the Israelites carried away at the Exodus (Exod 13:19). Christian, chiefly evangelical, apologetic publications and the film Patterns of Evidence: Exodus (2014) spread the idea widely.

Where it is claimed

2
  • D. Rohl, A Test of Time (London, 1995; in the US Pharaohs and Kings, pp. 360–367)not in the library

  • The film Patterns of Evidence: Exodus (dir. T. Mahoney, 2014)not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Not supported

The finds at Avaris are genuine and important: at the end of the Middle Kingdom a community of Asiatics lived in the eastern Delta, and one of them rose to high local rank — a background the Joseph story could fit. But nothing names the man Joseph: there is no inscription, the colourful dress is the common mark of Asiatics, and matching the dates needs a chronology Egyptologists do not accept, or moving the biblical dates. The identification cannot be disproved, but nothing supports it.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

6
  • Archaeology

    Austrian Archaeological Institute: Tell el-Dabʿa excavations, area F/I, stratum d/2 (auaris.at); R. Schiestl, Ägypten und Levante 16 (2006); Tell el-Dabʿa XVIII (2009)not in the library

    The fragments of the statue lie in tomb p/19-Nr. 1 and nearby tombs of stratum d/2 (late 12th Dynasty, 19th c. BCE): a seated official with a red “mushroom” hairstyle, yellow skin, a striped cloak and a throw-stick — the way Egyptians showed Asiatics. No name survives; the excavators see in him a local official of Asiatic origin.

  • Archaeology

    The painting in the tomb of Khnumhotep II at Beni Hasan (c. 1890 BCE)not in the library

    Patterned, many-coloured dress is the usual Egyptian mark of Asiatics: the 37 “Aamu” of the Beni Hasan painting wear the same. It marks an origin, not one person.

  • Text

    Gen 37:3WLC

    Genesis 37:3

    The Hebrew ketonet passim is obscure (a king's daughter wears the same, 2 Sam 13:18): “a long robe” or “a robe with sleeves”. The Greek and Latin translations made it “many-coloured”.

  • Text

    Gen 37:3LXX (Brenton)

    Genesis 37:3 (Septuagint)

    The Septuagint: χιτὼν ποικίλος, “a variegated tunic” — the source of the later “coat of many colours”.

  • Scholarship

    K. A. Kitchen, The Third Intermediate Period in Egypt, 3rd ed. (1996), preface; C. Bronk Ramsey et al., Science 328 (2010), pp. 1554–1557not in the library

    The identification rests on Rohl's “New Chronology”, which lowers Egyptian dates by about three centuries; Egyptologists have not accepted it, and the radiocarbon chronology of dynastic Egypt (2010) agrees with the conventional one.

  • Internal evidence

    The chronologies of Ussher and Seder Olamnot in the library

    On the conventional dates stratum d/2 (c. 1850 BCE) is older than both traditional dates for Joseph (the 18th–17th c. BCE by Ussher, the 16th–15th c. by Seder Olam): they can meet only if one of the chronologies is moved.

Photographs

2