Map of relations: Reform Judaism
Influences
19 influences · Open the listWhat one tradition took from another — stories, concepts, laws, rites, words. Each influence has its evidence and how certain it is.
Ritualafter 70 — the Mishnah (c. 200)Debated
The Passover Seder and the Greek symposium
Ancient philosophyintoRabbinic Judaism
The Seder described in the Mishnah (Pesachim 10) is shaped like a Graeco-Roman banquet: reclining, cups of wine, dipped hors d'œuvres, a learned table discussion; the word “afikoman” is Greek epikōmon (“after-dinner revelry”). After the Temple's destruction the Passover meal replaced the sacrifice and took the form of the learned table-talk known from Plato's Symposium and Plutarch's Table Talk.
Concept70 – c. 200 (from Yavneh to the Mishnah)Documented
The Pharisees' “tradition of the fathers” → the rabbis' Oral Torah
PhariseesintoRabbinic Judaism
According to Josephus the Pharisees handed down to the people ordinances “from the fathers” that are not in the Law of Moses, and the Sadducees rejected them. The Mishnah derives its teaching from a chain of tradition from Moses and sides with the Pharisees in disputes with the Sadducees; outside sources call its early teachers, Gamaliel and his son Simeon, Pharisees outright.
Ritualc. 80–100 (Yavneh)Debated
Birkat ha-minim — the benediction against the “heretics”
The Early ChurchintoRabbinic Judaism
The Talmud reports that at Yavneh under Gamaliel II Samuel the Small composed the twelfth benediction of the Amidah against the minim. Palestinian texts from the Cairo Genizah also name the “notzrim” (Nazarenes). Justin (c. 155–160) writes that Jews curse believers in Christ in their synagogues; Epiphanius and Jerome that they curse the “Nazoraeans”. Whether it was originally a response to Christianity is debated.
What traditions claim about each other — and what the sources say to it. One standard for every side.
Verdict: Not supportedDoctrinesura 9 (late Medinan)
“The Jews say: ʿUzayr (Ezra) is the son of God” (Quran 9:30).
IslamaboutJudaism
Verdict: Not supportedHistorical claimfrom c. 178 (Celsus); the narrative — 6th–10th c.
Jesus was the illegitimate son of a soldier, Pandera (Panthera), and worked miracles with the stolen Name of God (Toledot Yeshu).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutChristianity
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesCorrupted textc. 155–180 (Justin, Irenaeus)
Jewish translators (Aquila, Theodotion) corrupted Isa 7:14, replacing “virgin” with “young woman” to remove the prophecy of Christ.
The Early ChurchaboutJudaism
Contradictions
6 contradictions · Open the listStatements of a tradition's texts and the texts that contradict them: older sources, other traditions, its own texts, history. Each with the tradition's own answer.
The historical recordJudaismDan 5:1–2
Dan 5–6: Belshazzar is king of Babylon, son of Nebuchadnezzar; on the night of his feast Babylon falls and 'Darius the Mede received the…
What contradicts it: The Cyrus Cylinder (not in the library); The Nabonidus Chronicle; the Verse Account of Nabonidus (not in the library)
The tradition's own textsJudaism2 Sam 24:1
2 Sam 24:1: 'the anger of the LORD was kindled against Israel, and He moved David against them, saying: Go, number Israel and Judah'.
What contradicts it: 1 Chr 21:1
The historical recordRabbinic JudaismAvodah Zarah, 1
The Talmud ('Avodah Zarah 9a, following Seder Olam): Persian rule during the Second Temple lasted 34 years; the Second Temple stood 420…
What contradicts it: Babylonian chronicles, Herodotus, the Persepolis tablets (not in the library); Yoma, 5
Ethically contested texts
11 contested texts · Open the listTexts a tradition relies on that draw ethical objection. For each: what the text says, what the objection is, how the tradition itself reads it.
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, Christianity
1 Sam 15:2–3
Samuel gives Saul the word of the LORD: He remembers what Amalek did to Israel on the way from Egypt; 'go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass'. Saul spares King Agag and the best of the livestock and is rejected as king for it (15:9–23); Samuel kills Agag (15:33).
WarViolenceChildren
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Deut 20:10–18
The law of war: a distant city is first offered peace; if it refuses, all its males are killed and the women, children and livestock taken as spoil (20:10–15). But in the cities of the peoples God gives as an inheritance, 'thou shalt save alive nothing that breatheth': the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites are to be utterly destroyed, 'that they teach you not to do after all their abominations' (20:16–18).
WarViolenceChildren
Canonical collectionRabbinic Judaism
Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 54b (also 55b; Ketubot 11b)
In discussing the prohibition of male intercourse (Lev 18:22) and its penalty, the baraita says: 'with a male, they did not treat a minor as an adult'. Rav: intercourse with a boy younger than nine is not treated as with a nine-year-old; Shmuel: younger than three. The question is from what age the act makes the adult liable to the Torah's death penalty. In Sanhedrin 55b and Ketubot 11b the legal status of a girl under three years and a day is set in the same way: intercourse with her does not change her status as a virgin ('like a finger in the eye', Ketubot 11b).
ChildrenWomen
Text basis
38 directionsWhat each direction's texts rest on: inherited texts, its own, and those written after another tradition's texts.
- Two JudaismsJudaism
- Second Temple Judaism
- Rabbinic Judaism
- The Early Church
- Sunni Islam
- The Samaritan community
- Catholicism
- Eastern Orthodoxy
- Russian Orthodox Church
- Orthodox Church of Ukraine
- Waldensians
- Protestantism
- Lutheranism
- Reformed Christianity (Calvinism)
- Presbyterianism
- Congregationalism
- Anglicanism
- The Radical Reformation (Anabaptism)
- Baptists
- Particular Baptists
- Southern Baptist Convention
- Methodism
- Plymouth Brethren
- The Presocratics
- Platonism and the Academy
- Neoplatonism
- Aristotle and the Peripatetics
- Stoicism
- Shia Islam
- Ibadi Islam
- Pharisees
- Sadducees
- Essenes and the Qumran community
- Karaite Judaism
- Gnosticism
- Church of the East
- Oriental Orthodox churches
- Old Believers
- The Zoroastrian community