Skip to content

Influence · Ritual

Birkat ha-minim — the benediction against the “heretics”

c. 80–100 (Yavneh)Debated

From

The Early Church· Christianity

Into

Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism

What was taken and how it appears

The Talmud reports that at Yavneh under Gamaliel II Samuel the Small composed the twelfth benediction of the Amidah against the minim. Palestinian texts from the Cairo Genizah also name the “notzrim” (Nazarenes). Justin (c. 155–160) writes that Jews curse believers in Christ in their synagogues; Epiphanius and Jerome that they curse the “Nazoraeans”. Whether it was originally a response to Christianity is debated.

Evidence

3
  • Berakhot, 23Bavli (Vilna)

    Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 28b

    Samuel the Small composes the benediction at Yavneh. (The censored Vilna text reads “tzadukim” for “minim”.)

  • Cairo Genizah fragments of the Amidah (ed. S. Schechter, 1898)not in the library

    “May the notzrim and the minim perish…” — the Palestinian rite.

  • Justin, Dialogue with Trypho 16, 47, 96not in the library

    A mid-2nd-century Christian witness to curses in the synagogues.

How firmly established

Debated

What scholars say

R. Kimelman (1981) and others hold that the minim were Jewish heretics generally and “notzrim” a later addition; others (W. Horbury) see an edge against Jewish Christians already in the 1st–2nd c.