Skip to content

Contradiction · The historical record

Avodah Zarah, 1

Whose text

Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism

What is said

The Talmud ('Avodah Zarah 9a, following Seder Olam): Persian rule during the Second Temple lasted 34 years; the Second Temple stood 420 years (Yoma 9a).

Where it is said

Avodah Zarah, 1Bavli (Vilna)

Babylonian Talmud, Avodah Zarah 9a

What contradicts it

2
  • Babylonian chronicles, Herodotus, the Persepolis tablets (not in the library)· 539–330 BCE

    The Persian empire lasted from 539 to 330 BCE (some 200 years and more than ten kings); the Second Temple stood from about 516 BCE to 70 CE, some 585 years.

  • Yoma, 5Bavli (Vilna)· c. 500–600

    Babylonian Talmud, Yoma 9a

    The '420 years' figure enters the traditional Jewish count of years from creation, which therefore differs from the historical one by about 165 years.

How the tradition answers

Many traditional authorities keep the Seder Olam reckoning as received tradition. Azariah de' Rossi (Me'or Einayim, 1573) already pointed out the discrepancy with outside sources; it is explained by the sages counting only the kings named in Scripture (Dan 11:2): the reckoning served theological and calendrical, not historiographical, ends.