Claims
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
14 claims
Verdict: SupportedDoctrinec. 1170–1180
Muslims are not idolaters: they confess God's strict unity (Maimonides).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutIslam
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim
The Samaritans preserved the Torah's ancient script, while the Jews after the exile switched to another (“Assyrian”) script.
The Samaritan communityaboutSecond Temple Judaism
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text1054 (after Photius, 867)
The Latins added the words “and from the Son” (Filioque) to the Creed on their own authority.
Eastern OrthodoxyaboutCatholicism
Verdict: SupportedDoctrine1530
The Anabaptists forbid Christians to hold civil office (Augsburg Confession, art. 16).
LutheranismaboutThe Radical Reformation (Anabaptism)
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claimlate 3rd c.
The Book of Daniel was written under Antiochus Epiphanes (2nd c. BCE), and its “prophecies” are history after the fact (Porphyry).
NeoplatonismaboutThe Early Church
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text1665–1723
Nikon's correctors revised the books not from ancient manuscripts but from new Greek books printed in Venice.
Old BelieversaboutRussian Orthodox Church
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text1522 (September Testament) – 1530
Luther added to Rom 3:28 the word “alone” (allein), which is not in the Greek text, to support his doctrine of justification by faith alone.
CatholicismaboutLutheranism
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim1517
The Church sold indulgences for money, promising to release souls from purgatory: “as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from…
LutheranismaboutCatholicism
Verdict: SupportedOrigin1967–1968
Joseph Smith's “Book of Abraham” is not a translation of Abraham's writings: the papyri he “translated” from, rediscovered in 1966–1967…
EvangelicalismaboutLatter-day Saints (Mormons)
Verdict: SupportedOrigin1889–1982
Ellen White's writings, which Adventists regard as inspired, were largely copied from other authors without acknowledgement.
BaptistsaboutAdventism (Seventh-day Adventists)
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted textlate 3rd c.
The evangelists were ignorant: Mark ascribes to the prophet Isaiah words not found in Isaiah (“Behold, I send my messenger…” — from…
NeoplatonismaboutThe Early Church
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text20th c. (the dispute since the Middle Ages)
The Prophet said: “I leave among you two weighty things — the Book of God and my family (ʿitra), the people of my house”; the version…
Shia IslamaboutSunni Islam
Verdict: SupportedHistorical claim14th–20th c.
Celebrating the Prophet's birthday (mawlid) is an innovation unknown to the Prophet, the Companions and the first three generations; the…
Wahhabism and SalafismaboutSufism
Verdict: SupportedCorrupted text1593–1594
The evangelist Matthew ascribes to the prophets what is not in them: “He shall be called a Nazarene” (Matt 2:23) is in no prophet, and he…
Karaite JudaismaboutThe Early Church