Skip to content

Claim · Corrupted text

The evangelists were ignorant: Mark ascribes to the prophet Isaiah words not found in Isaiah (“Behold, I send my messenger…” — from…

Verdict: Supportedlate 3rd c.

Who claims

Neoplatonism· Ancient philosophy

About

The Early Church· Christianity

Claim

The evangelists were ignorant: Mark ascribes to the prophet Isaiah words not found in Isaiah (“Behold, I send my messenger…” — from Malachi).

Where it is claimed

1
  • Porphyry, Against the Christians (late 3rd c.), fr. 9 Harnack, via Jerome, Tractate on Mark 1:1–12not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: Supported

The text confirms Porphyry's observation: the first half of the quotation is not from Isaiah, and later scribes themselves altered the verse. Whether this was “ignorance” or an accepted way of naming a composite quotation is a judgement; the misattribution (or loose attribution) itself is established.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

3
  • Text

    Mark 1:2SBLGNT

    Mark 1:2 (Greek, SBL)

    “As it is written in Isaiah the prophet: Behold, I send my messenger…” — the opening words come from Mal 3:1 (and Exod 23:20); only the next verse is from Isa 40:3.

  • Manuscripts

    Mark 1:2RP2018

    Mark 1:2 in the Byzantine text

    Later manuscripts read “as it is written in the prophets” — scribes themselves smoothed the difficulty Porphyry noticed; the oldest (Sinaiticus, Vaticanus) read “in Isaiah”.

  • Scholarship

    Jerome, Tractatus in Marci Evangelium; J. Marcus, Mark 1–8 (2000)not in the library

    Jerome admits the words are not in Isaiah and explains them as a composite quotation; modern commentators see the custom of naming a composite quotation after its principal prophet.

The evangelists were ignorant: Mark ascribes to the prophet Isaiah words not found in… · Versemora