Claims: Hezbollah
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
9 claims · its own: 5 · the religion as a whole: 4
Hezbollah · 5
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim9th–10th c. (the hadith collections and creeds)
The Prophet appointed no successor, and the community unanimously chose Abu Bakr.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted text11th–20th c.
The Shia hold the Quran to be corrupted: passages about Ali and the Prophet's family are supposed to have been removed.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrinec. 1310–1320
Their faith bids the Shia hide their convictions and speak untruth (taqiyya), so their word cannot be trusted.
Sunni IslamaboutShia Islam
Verdict: Partly supportedDoctrine14th–21st c.
The Shia by doctrine revile and curse the Prophet's Companions — Abu Bakr, Umar, Aisha (tabarruʾ); this is part of their faith, not the…
Sunni IslamaboutTwelver (Imami) Shia
Verdict: Partly supportedHistorical claim14th–20th c.
The mourning rites of ʿAshura — processions, self-flagellation, bloodletting (tatbir) — are an innovation (bidʿa) introduced by the Buyids…
Wahhabism and SalafismaboutTwelver (Imami) Shia
Islam — the religion as a whole · 4
Entries about the religion as a whole: the direction inherits them.
Verdict: Contradicted by the sourcesIdentity1994
“Allah” is an ancient Arabian moon god (or Baal), not the God of the Bible.
ProtestantismaboutIslam
Verdict: SupportedDoctrinec. 1170–1180
Muslims are not idolaters: they confess God's strict unity (Maimonides).
Rabbinic JudaismaboutIslam
Verdict: Partly supportedOriginc. 743
Muhammad composed his teaching after coming across the Old and New Testaments and conversing with an Arian monk (John of Damascus).
The Early ChurchaboutIslam
Verdict: Partly supportedCorrupted text9th–10th c.
The Quran did not come down in its original form: it was edited under ʿUthmān and other copies were burned (the Apology of al-Kindī).
ChristianityaboutIslam