Перейти к содержанию

Платон. Горгий (англ. пер. Б. Джоуэтта) · Stephanus 467

Вид текста

Размер шрифта: 19px

Перейти к месту
То же место в другом издании

Опорное место: Pl.Grg.467

Сравнить рядом

Нажмите на номер или текст фрагмента, чтобы выбрать его.

fool, and that rhetoric is an art and not a flattery—and so you will have refuted me; but if you leave me unrefuted, why, the rhetoricians who do what they think best in states, and the tyrants, will have nothing upon which to congratulate themselves, if, as you say, power be indeed a good, admitting at the same time that what is done without sense is an evil. Pol. Yes; I admit that. Soc. How then can the rhetoricians or the tyrants have great power in states, unless Polus can refute Socrates, and prove to him that they do as they will? Pol. This fellow— Soc. I say that they do not do as they will;—now refute me. Pol. Why, have you not already said that they do as they think best? Soc. And I say so still. Pol. Then surely they do as they will? Soc. I deny it. Pol. But they do what they think best? Soc. Aye. Pol. That, Socrates, is monstrous and absurd. Soc. Good words, good Polus, as I may say in your own peculiar style; but if you have any questions to ask of me, either prove that I am in error or give the answer yourself. Pol. Very well, I am willing to answer that I may know what you mean. Soc. Do men appear to you to will that which they do, or to will that further end for the sake of which they do a thing? when they take medicine, for example, at the bidding of a physician, do they will the drinking of the medicine which is painful, or the health for the sake of which they drink? Pol. Clearly, the health. Soc. And when men go on a voyage or engage in business, they do not will that which they are doing at the time; for who would desire to take the risk of a voyage or the trouble of business?—But they will, to have the wealth for the sake of which they go on a voyage. Pol. Certainly. Soc. And is not this universally true? If a man does something for the sake of something else, he wills not that which he does, but that for the sake of which he does it. Pol. Yes. Soc. And are not all things either good or evil, or intermediate and indifferent? Pol. To be sure, Socrates. Soc. Wisdom and health and wealth and the like you would call goods, and their opposites evils? Pol. I should.

Источник и условия: Платон. Горгий (англ. пер. Б. Джоуэтта) · общественное достояние · Plato, Gorgias, tr. Benjamin Jowett, The Dialogues of Plato, 3rd ed., vol. II (Oxford University Press, American Branch, New York, 1892); Project Gutenberg eBook #76464. · условия

Закладки, заметки и место чтения хранятся только в этом браузере.