Contested texts: Judaism
One standard for every tradition: the Hebrew Bible, the New Testament, the Talmud, the Quran and hadith, later church texts. The summary never goes beyond the text itself.
12 contested texts
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, Christianity
1 Sam 15:2–3
Samuel gives Saul the word of the LORD: He remembers what Amalek did to Israel on the way from Egypt; 'go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass'. Saul spares King Agag and the best of the livestock and is rejected as king for it (15:9–23); Samuel kills Agag (15:33).
WarViolenceChildren
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Deut 20:10–18
The law of war: a distant city is first offered peace; if it refuses, all its males are killed and the women, children and livestock taken as spoil (20:10–15). But in the cities of the peoples God gives as an inheritance, 'thou shalt save alive nothing that breatheth': the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites are to be utterly destroyed, 'that they teach you not to do after all their abominations' (20:16–18).
WarViolenceChildren
Canonical collectionRabbinic Judaism
Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 54b (also 55b; Ketubot 11b)
In discussing the prohibition of male intercourse (Lev 18:22) and its penalty, the baraita says: 'with a male, they did not treat a minor as an adult'. Rav: intercourse with a boy younger than nine is not treated as with a nine-year-old; Shmuel: younger than three. The question is from what age the act makes the adult liable to the Torah's death penalty. In Sanhedrin 55b and Ketubot 11b the legal status of a girl under three years and a day is set in the same way: intercourse with her does not change her status as a virgin ('like a finger in the eye', Ketubot 11b).
ChildrenWomen
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Num 31:14–18
After the war against Midian Moses is angry that the army has kept alive the women who on Balaam's counsel led Israel into the sin of Peor: 'kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman that hath known man by lying with him; but all the women children, that have not known man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves'.
WarViolenceWomenChildren
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Deut 21:18–21
If a man has a 'stubborn and rebellious son' who will not obey his father and mother, the parents bring him to the elders of the city and say 'he is a glutton and a drunkard'; 'and all the men of his city shall stone him with stones, that he die'.
PunishmentChildren
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Exod 21:20–21
'If a man smite his bondman, or his bondwoman, with a rod, and he die under his hand, he shall surely be punished. Notwithstanding if he continue a day or two, he shall not be punished; for he is his money'.
SlaveryViolence
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Lev 20:13
'If a man lie with mankind, as with womankind, both of them have committed abomination: they shall surely be put to death'.
Punishment
ScriptureSecond Temple Judaism, Rabbinic Judaism, The Samaritan community, Christianity
Exod 22:18 (Hebrew numbering 22:17)
'Thou shalt not suffer a witch (sorceress) to live'.
PunishmentWomen
Canonical collectionRabbinic Judaism
Babylonian Talmud, Bava Kamma 38a (Mishnah 4:3)
The Mishnah: 'An Israelite's ox that gores a Canaanite's (a gentile's) ox — the owner is exempt; a Canaanite's ox that gores an Israelite's ox — he pays full damages'. The Gemara justifies this by the nations' failure to keep the seven Noahide commandments. The same passage tells that Roman officials, having studied the Torah, declared it true 'except for this one thing'.
Attitude to others
Authoritative textRabbinic Judaism
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of the Murderer 4:10–11
Epikorsim (idolaters, those who sin provocatively, deniers of the Torah and of prophecy) — 'it was a commandment to kill them': whoever has power executes them openly by the sword, otherwise he brings about their death by stratagem (for instance, removing a ladder from a pit). Gentiles with whom there is no war are not killed, but 'it is forbidden to save them' when in mortal danger: one who falls into the sea is not pulled out (4:11).
ViolenceAttitude to others
Authoritative textRabbinic Judaism
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Rebels 3:1–3
One who openly denies the Oral Torah is counted among the heretics (epikorsim): such people “are not within the community of Israel”, and neither witnesses nor warning nor judges are needed for them; then come words omitted in some printings: “whoever kills one of them has performed a great commandment”. But this is said of one who denied by his own reasoning, “like Zadok and Boethus”; the children of those who went astray, born among the Karaites and brought up by them, are like a child taken captive and are to be drawn back with words of peace (3:3).
ViolenceAttitude to others
Authoritative textEssenes and the Qumran community
Community Rule (1QS) 1.9–11
One who enters the community undertakes “to love all the sons of light, each according to his lot in the counsel of God, and to hate all the sons of darkness, each according to his guilt, in the vengeance of God”.
Attitude to others