Judaism › Second Temple Judaism
Sadducees
since 2nd century BCE (first named under the Hasmoneans) — until 70 CE (after the destruction of the Temple they are no longer mentioned as an active group)
Tenets: 14 (its own 3)
Branched from: Second Temple Judaism · Pharisees, Sadducees and Essenes under the Hasmoneans (c. 150–100 BCE)
At a glance
Key tenets
Primary texts
The Tanakh
texts in the library: 1, by link: 1
books in the library: 24
Texts
1Josephus on the Sadducees (Antiquities 13.10.6, 18.1.4; War 2.8.14)
Flavius Josephus · 75–94
History
Public domain
The religion's shared texts
1The Tanakh (Hebrew Bible)
books composed by the 2nd century BCE; canon settled by the 2nd century CE
Scripture
public domain · some editions online only
Tenets
Tenets: 14 (its own 3)How far the tenet's wording in the tradition's own texts rests on its primary texts.
- God's covenant with IsraelDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The SabbathOne placeOne placeSupport: Stated in plain words in one place of the primary texts
- CircumcisionDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The festivals of the TorahDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The dietary laws (kashrut)DirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Love thy neighbourOne placeOne placeSupport: Stated in plain words in one place of the primary texts
- The existence of GodDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The unity of GodFor and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- Creation of the worldDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- ProvidenceDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Commandments through Moses and the prophetsDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
Its own tenets
3- The written Law onlyOnly the written laws are binding; the fathers' tradition has no force.Not in plain words±Not in plain wordsSupport: Not stated in plain words; places against
- No resurrectionSouls perish with the body; no resurrection or reward follows death.For and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- Free will without fateThere is no fate: man chooses good or evil himself.For and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
The colour shows what the tradition's wording rests on in the library's texts — by the references printed in its documents, the quotations found in them and the places of the primary texts listed by the editors; when the same texts have places read against it, the colour is at most yellow. It is not a judgement of truth.
Norms and their violations
All violationsViolence and coercion in the tradition's name — and what was done to its people. Teaching and disapproval without force are not marked.
Done in its name · 5
CoercionStatec. 112–103 BCEEnded
The circumcision of the Idumeans and Itureans at the Hasmoneans' demand
In the name of: Second Temple Judaism
The Hasmonean rulers John Hyrcanus I and Aristobulus I
According to Josephus, John Hyrcanus, having taken Adora and Marisa, let the Idumeans stay in their land 'if they would circumcise their genitals and make use of the laws of the Jews' (Antiquities 13.257–258); Aristobulus I likewise 'compelled' the Itureans (13.318–319). Strabo says the Idumeans 'joined' the Judaeans, with no mention of coercion. Historians debate: forced conversion (S. Weitzman) or alliance and incorporation into the people (A. Kasher, S. Cohen, S. Mason). The Hasmoneans also destroyed the pagan shrines of conquered towns.
CoercionStatec. 111–110 BCEEnded
The destruction of the Samaritan temple on Mount Gerizim
In the name of: Second Temple Judaism
The Hasmonean ruler John Hyrcanus I
Victims: The Samaritan community
Josephus writes that Hyrcanus took Shechem and Gerizim and destroyed the temple of the 'Cutheans' (the Samaritans) (Antiquities 13.254–256); Yitzhak Magen's excavations date the destruction of the temple and town on Gerizim to c. 111–110 BCE. The Samaritans never rebuilt the temple, but the mountain remained their holy place.
Killings and executionsStatec. 88 BCEEnded
The crucifixion of eight hundred opponents by the high priest Alexander Jannaeus
In the name of: Second Temple Judaism
Alexander Jannaeus, high priest and king of Judaea of the Hasmonean dynasty
In a civil war in which Jannaeus's opponents called in the Syrian king Demetrius III, Jannaeus, according to Josephus (Jewish Antiquities 13.379–383; Jewish War 1.97–98), took them prisoner, crucified about 800 men in Jerusalem and had their wives and children killed before their eyes while he feasted with his concubines. Josephus does not call the executed Pharisees outright; this is inferred from Jannaeus's deathbed advice to the queen to make peace with the Pharisees (Antiquities 13.401–402) and from the Qumran Pesher on Nahum (4Q169), in which the 'Lion of Wrath' 'hangs men alive' for the alliance of the 'seekers of smooth things' with 'Demetrius'. It is an act of the head of the cult and the state against his fellow Jews in a political war; historians take Josephus's figure with caution.
Killings and executionsState523Ended
The massacre of the Christians of Najran by the Jewish king of Himyar
In the name of: Judaism
The Jewish king of Himyar Yusuf As'ar Yath'ar (Dhu Nuwas) and his commanders
Victims: Oriental Orthodox churches
Yusuf (Dhu Nuwas), a king of Himyar who had embraced Judaism, besieged Najran in a war with the allies of Christian Aksum; after the town surrendered he executed the Christian elders led by al-Harith (Arethas) and burned the church with people inside. His commander's inscriptions (Ja 1028, Ry 507, 508) report the totals for the whole campaign without naming the victims' faith; the Syriac letters and the Martyrdom of Arethas speak of martyrdom for refusing to deny Christ. C. J. Robin stresses the political side of the conflict; Muslim exegetes link the event with the 'people of the ditch' (Quran 85:4–8). In 525 Aksum conquered Himyar.
Killings and executionsMovementsince 1980Ongoing
Killings by Jewish religious extremists
In the name of: Judaism
Kach supporters and religious-nationalist extremists (the Jewish Underground, B. Goldstein, Y. Amir, A. Ben-Uliel)
Victims: Islam
The 'Jewish Underground' from Gush Emunim circles bombed the cars of Palestinian mayors in 1980, attacked the Islamic College in Hebron in 1983 (3 killed) and plotted to blow up the Dome of the Rock. On 25 February 1994 the Kach supporter Baruch Goldstein shot worshippers in the Cave of the Patriarchs (29 killed); Israel outlawed Kach and Kahane Chai as terrorist. On 4 November 1995 Yigal Amir killed Prime Minister Rabin, invoking the 'law of the pursuer' (din rodef). On 31 July 2015 an arson attack in Duma killed three members of the Palestinian Dawabsheh family, among them an 18-month-old child (Amiram Ben-Uliel was convicted). Rabin called Goldstein 'a shame on Zionism and an embarrassment to Judaism'. In 2024 the United States sanctioned violent settlers and the Kahanist group Lehava.
Done to its people · 10
Killings and executionsInstitutionc. 271–293Ended
Kartir against the 'other faiths'; the death of Mani in prison
In the name of: The Zoroastrian community
The chief priest Kartir under the Sasanian kings (Bahram I and II)
Victims: Judaism, Church of the East
In his inscriptions on the Ka'ba-ye Zartosht and at Naqsh-e Rostam the Zoroastrian high priest Kartir writes that in the empire Jews, Buddhists, Brahmins, Nazarenes and Christians, 'baptists' (Makdag) and Zandiks (Manichaeans) 'were struck', and the shrines of demons destroyed. How far 'striking' meant violence is debated (P. O. Skjærvø allows a figurative sense). The prophet Mani, under Bahram I and with Kartir's backing, was imprisoned and died in prison at Belapat after a 26-day ordeal (274 or 277).
Killings and executionsState627Ended
The execution of the men of the Jewish tribe of Banu Qurayza
In the name of: Islam
The Muslim community of Medina led by Muhammad; the sentence was given by Sa'd ibn Mu'adh
Victims: Judaism
After the Battle of the Trench the Muslims besieged the Jewish tribe of Qurayza, accused of collusion with the Meccans. The tribe surrendered to the judgement of Sa'd ibn Mu'adh; according to al-Bukhari (no. 3043; Muslim no. 1768) he decreed that 'the fighters be killed and the offspring taken captive', and Muhammad approved. In Ibn Ishaq's Life 600–700 men were beheaded (other versions say up to 800–900), and the women and children enslaved. Quran 33:26 says: 'some you slew, and some you took captive'. All the information comes from Muslim sources only; some scholars (W. N. Arafat, 1976) doubted its scale, others (M. J. Kister, 1986) hold the account reliable.
DiscriminationLaw8th c. – 1909Ended
The legal inequality of non-Muslim dhimmis
In the name of: Islam
The caliphates and Muslim states that applied the rules of dhimma (the 'Pact of Umar')
Victims: Judaism, Christianity, The Zoroastrian community, The Samaritan community
Under Islamic law the 'People of the Book' (Jews, Christians, later Zoroastrians) under Muslim rule paid a poll tax, the jizya (Quran 9:29: 'until they pay the jizya with willing hand, being brought low'), and lived under the restrictions of the so-called 'Pact of Umar' (ascribed to the caliph Umar; the known versions are no older than the 10th–11th centuries, M. Cohen; M. Levy-Rubin dates its formation to the late 8th–9th century): no new places of worship, no loud bells, distinctive dress (decrees of the caliph al-Mutawakkil, 850), no riding horses, no bearing arms; a dhimmi's testimony against a Muslim was not accepted. How strictly it was applied varied greatly by era. In the Ottoman Empire the jizya was abolished in 1855–1856 (the Hatt-ı Hümayun) but replaced by a military-exemption tax paid only by non-Muslims until 1909; the jizya on the Zoroastrians of Iran was lifted in 1882.
CoercionState1004–1021Ended
Al-Hakim's persecution of Christians and Jews; the destruction of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre
In the name of: Ismailis
The Fatimid caliph al-Hakim bi-Amr Allah
Victims: Christianity, Judaism
The Ismaili caliph of Egypt al-Hakim made the rules of dhimma harsher (heavy crosses and wooden blocks hung from the neck, special dress), ordered churches and synagogues destroyed — from late September 1009 the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem — and forced some Christians and Jews to accept Islam. In his last years (c. 1017–1021) the caliph allowed the converts to return to their faith; his son al-Zahir permitted the rebuilding of the Holy Sepulchre (1027–1028).
Killings and executionsMovement1099Ended
The massacre at the crusaders' capture of Jerusalem
In the name of: Catholicism
The army of the First Crusade
Victims: Islam, Judaism
On 15 July 1099 the crusaders took Jerusalem and killed much of its Muslim and Jewish population; Latin chroniclers write approvingly of blood 'up to the knees' at the Temple Mount, Jewish sources of a synagogue burned with people inside. Some captives, Jews among them (as the Cairo Genizah letters show), were ransomed.
Killings and executionsState1147–1230Ended
The Almohads: the forcible conversion of the Jews and Christians of the Maghreb and al-Andalus
In the name of: Islam
The Almohad caliphate (Abd al-Mu'min and his successors)
Victims: Judaism, Christianity
The Almohads, the movement of Ibn Tumart, after conquering the Maghreb and Muslim Spain (from 1147) refused to tolerate dhimmis: Jews and Christians were offered Islam, exile or death. Many fled (Maimonides' family — to Fez, then to Egypt), others accepted Islam outwardly; converts were suspected and made to wear special dress. In 1230 the caliph Idris al-Ma'mun renounced Ibn Tumart's doctrine and restored the dhimmis' right to their faith.
Relations and critique
What this tradition took from others and what others took from it, what is claimed about it and what it claims, contradictions and contested texts — one standard for everyone.
- TimelineDirections, events and documents — from here only
- Text basisBy the testimony of their opponents the Sadducees held only the written Law to be binding and rejected the tradition of the fathers; that they accepted the Pentateuch alone is said only by later church writers and is doubtful. No Sadducean writings survive. The book of Ben Sira (c. 180 BCE), with its reverence for the high priest and its silence on resurrection, is often thought close to the later Sadducees.inherited: 2 · own: 0 · after others: 0
- Influences20
- Claims15
- Contradictions3
- Ethically contested texts7
- Finds10
What the colour shows
- Rests directly on the primary texts
- Rests on one place of the primary texts
- Rests only on secondary texts
- No support found in the library's texts
- Not marked
The colour shows what the tradition's wording rests on in the library's texts — by the references printed in its documents, the quotations found in them and the places of the primary texts listed by the editors; when the same texts have places read against it, the colour is at most yellow. It is not a judgement of truth.