Skip to content

Contradiction · The tradition's own texts

Matt 1:1–17

Whose text

Christianity· as a whole

What is said

Jesus' genealogy in Matthew (1:1–17): from Abraham through David and Solomon to Joseph, son of Jacob; 'from David until the carrying away into Babylon are fourteen generations'.

Where it is said

What contradicts it

2
  • 1 Chr 3:10–16· 4th c. BCE

    Between Joram and Uzziah (Azariah) Chronicles names Ahaziah, Joash and Amaziah, absent from Matthew (1:8); Jehoiakim is also left out (1:11): without these omissions the 'fourteen generations' do not come out.

  • Luke 3:23–38· c. 80–90

    In Luke Joseph's father is Heli and the line runs from David through Nathan, not Solomon; from David to Jesus inclusive there are 43 names against Matthew's 28; the shared names Shealtiel and Zerubbabel have different fathers (Jechoniah / Neri).

How the tradition answers

Julius Africanus (Letter to Aristides, c. 220; in Eusebius, Church History 1.7): Jacob and Heli were half-brothers by the same mother, and Joseph was the son of one by nature and of the other by levirate law. Since the 15th century (Annius of Viterbo) a widespread reading is that Luke gives Mary's genealogy (Heli being her father). Matthew's omissions are taken as deliberate: the 3 × 14 scheme (the numerical value of the name David in Hebrew is 14) is theological, not a complete chronology.

Note

Both genealogies run the line through Joseph, although both Gospels speak of the virginal conception (Matt 1:16, Luke 3:23 'as was supposed').
Jesus' genealogy in Matthew (1:1–17): from Abraham through David and Solomon to Joseph… · Versemora