Judaism › Rabbinic Judaism › Conservative Judaism
Reconstructionist Judaism
since 1922–1968 (the Society for the Advancement of Judaism; the rabbinical college)
Tenets: 22 (its own 2)
Branched from: Conservative Judaism · The Society for the Advancement of Judaism (1922)
At a glance
Key tenets
Primary texts
The Tanakh
texts in the library: 1, by link: 1
books in the library: 24
Texts
1Mordecai M. Kaplan, Judaism as a Civilization
Mordecai M. Kaplan · 1934
Doctrine
© Protected by copyright — read on the rights holder's site
The religion's shared texts
1The Tanakh (Hebrew Bible)
books composed by the 2nd century BCE; canon settled by the 2nd century CE
Scripture
public domain · some editions online only
Tenets
Tenets: 22 (its own 2)How far the tenet's wording in the tradition's own texts rests on its primary texts.
- God created the worldDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The Torah given through MosesDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The SabbathOne placeOne placeSupport: Stated in plain words in one place of the primary texts
- CircumcisionDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The festivals of the TorahDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Love thy neighbourOne placeOne placeSupport: Stated in plain words in one place of the primary texts
- The existence of GodDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- The unity of God (Shema)For and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- The incorporeality of GodFor and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- Prophecy and the prophecy of MosesDirectDirectSupport: Rests on the primary texts
- The permanence of the TorahFor and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- Free willFor and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- Repentance (teshuvah)DirectDirectSupport: Rests on the primary texts
- The world to comeFor and against±For and againstSupport: Places both for and against
- God is the first and eternalOne placeOne placeSupport: Stated in plain words in one place of the primary texts
- Worship God aloneDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- God knows human deedsDirectDirectSupport: Stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Catholic Israel (Klal Yisrael)Not in plain wordsNot in plain wordsSupport: Not stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Revelation with a human shareNot in plain wordsNot in plain wordsSupport: Not stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Women's equality in religious lifeNot in plain wordsNot in plain wordsSupport: Not stated in plain words in the primary texts
Its own tenets
2- An evolving civilisationJudaism is the evolving religious civilisation of the Jewish people.Not in plain wordsNot in plain wordsSupport: Not stated in plain words in the primary texts
- Chosenness set asideThe doctrine of the chosen people is removed from the prayers.Not in plain words±Not in plain wordsSupport: Not stated in plain words; places against
The colour shows what the tradition's wording rests on in the library's texts — by the references printed in its documents, the quotations found in them and the places of the primary texts listed by the editors; when the same texts have places read against it, the colour is at most yellow. It is not a judgement of truth.
Does not share
8Tenets the direction would inherit but does not hold.
- Halakha binding and developingFrom “Conservative Judaism”
- Torah from HeavenFrom “Rabbinic Judaism”
- The Oral TorahFrom “Rabbinic Judaism”
- Resurrection of the deadFrom “Rabbinic Judaism”
- The MessiahFrom “Rabbinic Judaism”
- Reward and punishmentFrom “Rabbinic Judaism”
- God's covenant with IsraelFrom “Common to Judaism”
- The dietary laws (kashrut)From “Common to Judaism”
Norms and their violations
All violationsViolence and coercion in the tradition's name — and what was done to its people. Teaching and disapproval without force are not marked.
Done in its name · 5
Killings and executionsOfficialLawafter 70 (the Mishnah c. 200) – to this day in the law, suspendedOngoing
The biblical death penalties in rabbinic law: kept in theory, suspended
In the name of: Rabbinic Judaism, Orthodox Judaism
Rabbinic law — the Mishnah, the Talmuds, the codes (Maimonides) — and the rabbis who teach it
Rabbinic law keeps the four court deaths — stoning, burning, beheading and strangling — and the offences that carry them, among them Sabbath-breaking, idolatry, blasphemy, sorcery and male intercourse (Mishnah Sanhedrin chs. 6–11). But such cases may be tried only by a Sanhedrin of 71 sitting in the Chamber of Hewn Stone while the Temple stands, and according to the Talmud it stopped trying them forty years before the destruction (Sanhedrin 41a; Maimonides, Laws of the Sanhedrin 14:11–13). The Mishnah calls a Sanhedrin that executes once in seven years (R. Eleazar ben Azariah: once in seventy) 'destructive'; R. Tarfon and R. Akiva said that with them no one would ever have been executed, and Rabban Simeon ben Gamaliel answered that they would multiply murderers (Makkot 1:10). Beside it the Talmud keeps an emergency power: a court 'flogs and punishes not according to the Torah' to fence it in — a man who rode a horse on the Sabbath 'in the days of the Greeks' was stoned (Yevamot 90b; Sanhedrin 46a). Reform Judaism's Pittsburgh Platform (1885) accepted as binding only the moral laws of the Mosaic legislation.
Killings and executionsOfficialLawfrom the Talmud (c. 500; earlier the Tosefta); codified by Maimonides (c. 1180) and the Shulchan Arukh (1565)Ongoing
'Cast down and do not raise up': the killing of heretics and informers in rabbinic law
In the name of: Rabbinic Judaism, Orthodox Judaism
The rabbinic codes (the Tosefta, the Talmud, Maimonides, the Shulchan Arukh) and those who acted on them
Besides the court penalties, rabbinic law has the rule 'cast down and do not raise up' (moridin ve-lo ma'alin) for informers, heretics and apostates (Tosefta Bava Metzia 2:13; Babylonian Talmud, Avodah Zarah 26a–b). Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, c. 1180) writes that the apikorsim who deny the Torah and prophecy it is 'a commandment to kill' (Laws of the Murderer 4:10), but holds that the descendants of heretics, such as the Karaites, are like 'children taken captive', to be brought back 'with words of peace' (Laws of Rebels 3:3). The Shulchan Arukh (1565) rules that 'it is permitted to kill an informer (moser) anywhere, even nowadays', even before he informs (Choshen Mishpat 388:10). Later authorities narrowed the rule: the Arukh HaShulchan (388:7) to unjust governments; R. E. Waldenberg (Tzitz Eliezer 19:52) holds that it does not forbid informing a just government; the Chazon Ish (Yoreh De'ah 2:16; d. 1953) holds that it does not apply to heretics in our time.
Killings and executionsStateState523Ended
The massacre of the Christians of Najran by the Jewish king of Himyar
In the name of: Judaism
The Jewish king of Himyar Yusuf As'ar Yath'ar (Dhu Nuwas) and his commanders
Victims: Oriental Orthodox churches
Yusuf (Dhu Nuwas), a king of Himyar who had embraced Judaism, besieged Najran in a war with the allies of Christian Aksum; after the town surrendered he executed the Christian elders led by al-Harith (Arethas) and burned the church with people inside. His commander's inscriptions (Ja 1028, Ry 507, 508) report the totals for the whole campaign without naming the victims' faith; the Syriac letters and the Martyrdom of Arethas speak of martyrdom for refusing to deny Christ. C. J. Robin stresses the political side of the conflict; Muslim exegetes link the event with the 'people of the ditch' (Quran 85:4–8). In 525 Aksum conquered Himyar.
CoercionOfficialLaw12th c. – mid-20th c.Repudiated: The sources themselves restrict the right (Rav, Maimonides); the State of Israel — the Marriage Age Law (1950; 18 years in 2013)
The betrothal of minor daughters by their fathers in halakha
In the name of: Rabbinic Judaism
Fathers who married off minor daughters under the halakhic right, and the communities where this was custom (medieval Europe, Yemen)
Under the Mishnah a father has authority to betroth his daughter while she is a minor (Ketubot 4:4; Kiddushin 2:1). The Talmud records Rav's prohibition: 'one may not betroth one's daughter while she is a minor until she grows up and says: I want so-and-so' (Kiddushin 41a); Maimonides repeats it: the father has the right, but the Sages commanded not to use it (Laws of Marriage 3:19). The Tosafists (12th–13th c.) note that 'now we betroth our daughters even as minors' because 'every single day the exile prevails over us' and a dowry may later be lacking. Early marriage of girls persisted among Yemenite Jews into the 20th century. Israel set a minimum marriage age of 17 for girls (1950) and 18 (2013).
Killings and executionsOfficialInstitutionc. 1270 – 1380 (Castile) / 1391 (Aragon)Ended
Executions of informers by Jewish communal courts in Castile and Aragon
In the name of: Rabbinic Judaism
The communal courts and leaders of the Jewish communities (aljamas) of Castile and the Crown of Aragon, acting under royal licence; the rabbis who approved the sentences (Asher ben Jehiel in Toledo)
In the 13th–14th centuries the Jewish communities of Castile and Aragon applied to the kings for, and obtained, the right to condemn informers (malsines) to death — a right inherited from al-Andalus; in Aragon James I did much to further it in his last years (d. 1276). The sentence was carried out by royal officials for a set fee; its legal basis was the court's emergency power and the law of the informer (moser). Asher ben Jehiel (the Rosh), rabbi of Toledo from 1305 (d. 1327), attests to the practice and himself passed such a sentence on an informer. On 21 August 1379 the royal treasurer Joseph Pichon was put to death by the royal executioner on a writ obtained by Jewish leaders; the angered Juan I had the Cortes of Soria (1380) take criminal jurisdiction away from the Jewish courts of Castile, and in Aragon Queen Violante in 1390 named Hasdai Crescas sole judge of informers. Around 1300 Iberian Jewry was the largest in Europe: Castile alone had about 100,000 Jews (J. Hinojosa Montalvo's estimate) of about 1.2 million Jews worldwide (S. DellaPergola), some 8%, not counting Aragon, Navarre and Portugal.
Done to its people · 26
Killings and executionsOfficialInstitutionc. 271–293Ended
Kartir against the 'other faiths'; the death of Mani in prison
In the name of: The Zoroastrian community
The chief priest Kartir under the Sasanian kings (Bahram I and II)
Victims: Judaism, Church of the East
In his inscriptions on the Ka'ba-ye Zartosht and at Naqsh-e Rostam the Zoroastrian high priest Kartir writes that in the empire Jews, Buddhists, Brahmins, Nazarenes and Christians, 'baptists' (Makdag) and Zandiks (Manichaeans) 'were struck', and the shrines of demons destroyed. How far 'striking' meant violence is debated (P. O. Skjærvø allows a figurative sense). The prophet Mani, under Bahram I and with Kartir's backing, was imprisoned and died in prison at Belapat after a 26-day ordeal (274 or 277).
Killings and executionsOfficialInstitution414–415Ended
The expulsion of the Jews of Alexandria and the killing of Hypatia (414–415)
In the name of: The Early Church
The circle of Bishop Cyril of Alexandria: a crowd led by the reader Peter; the parabalani
Victims: Rabbinic Judaism, Neoplatonism
Socrates Scholasticus, a church historian and contemporary (Ecclesiastical History 7.13–15), reports: after a night attack by Jews on Christians, Bishop Cyril with a crowd seized the synagogues, drove the Jews from the city and let their property be plundered; the prefect Orestes protested to the emperor. Monks of the Nitrian desert attacked Orestes; the monk Ammonius wounded him with a stone, and the prefect had him tortured to death, while Cyril declared him a martyr. In March 415 a crowd led by the reader Peter seized the Neoplatonist philosopher Hypatia, held to stand in the way of Cyril's reconciliation with Orestes, killed her in the church called the Caesareum, tore her body apart and burned it. Socrates writes that this 'brought no small opprobrium upon Cyril and the Alexandrian church'. A direct order by Cyril is not attested: the pagan Damascius (6th c.) accuses him of envy, the Coptic bishop John of Nikiu (7th c.) approves the killing. E. Watts and M. Dzielska place the responsibility on Cyril's circle and the climate he created. A law of 416 (Theodosian Code 16.2.42), after a complaint from Alexandria, limited the number of the parabalani and put them under the prefect.
Killings and executionsStateState627Ended
The execution of the men of the Jewish tribe of Banu Qurayza
In the name of: Islam
The Muslim community of Medina led by Muhammad; the sentence was given by Sa'd ibn Mu'adh
Victims: Judaism
After the Battle of the Trench the Muslims besieged the Jewish tribe of Qurayza, accused of collusion with the Meccans. The tribe surrendered to the judgement of Sa'd ibn Mu'adh; according to al-Bukhari (no. 3043; Muslim no. 1768) he decreed that 'the fighters be killed and the offspring taken captive', and Muhammad approved. In Ibn Ishaq's Life 600–700 men were beheaded (other versions say up to 800–900), and the women and children enslaved. Quran 33:26 says: 'some you slew, and some you took captive'. All the information comes from Muslim sources only; some scholars (W. N. Arafat, 1976) doubted its scale, others (M. J. Kister, 1986) hold the account reliable.
CoercionStateState632–936Ended
The forced baptism of Jews in Byzantium
In the name of: The Early Church
The Byzantine emperors Heraclius, Leo III, Basil I, Romanos I
Victims: Rabbinic Judaism
Several emperors ordered the Jews of the empire baptised: Heraclius (c. 632), Leo III (c. 721–722), Basil I (c. 873–874, with rewards and threats), Romanos I Lekapenos (930s). The decrees were applied unevenly, many of the baptised returned to Judaism; some Jews fled to Khazaria and elsewhere.
DiscriminationStateLaw8th c. – 1909Ended
The legal inequality of non-Muslim dhimmis
In the name of: Islam
The caliphates and Muslim states that applied the rules of dhimma (the 'Pact of Umar')
Victims: Judaism, Christianity, The Zoroastrian community, The Samaritan community
Under Islamic law the 'People of the Book' (Jews, Christians, later Zoroastrians) under Muslim rule paid a poll tax, the jizya (Quran 9:29: 'until they pay the jizya with willing hand, being brought low'), and lived under the restrictions of the so-called 'Pact of Umar' (ascribed to the caliph Umar; the known versions are no older than the 10th–11th centuries, M. Cohen; M. Levy-Rubin dates its formation to the late 8th–9th century): no new places of worship, no loud bells, distinctive dress (decrees of the caliph al-Mutawakkil, 850), no riding horses, no bearing arms; a dhimmi's testimony against a Muslim was not accepted. How strictly it was applied varied greatly by era. In the Ottoman Empire the jizya was abolished in 1855–1856 (the Hatt-ı Hümayun) but replaced by a military-exemption tax paid only by non-Muslims until 1909; the jizya on the Zoroastrians of Iran was lifted in 1882.
CoercionStateState1004–1021Ended
Al-Hakim's persecution of Christians and Jews; the destruction of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre
In the name of: Ismailis
The Fatimid caliph al-Hakim bi-Amr Allah
Victims: Christianity, Judaism
The Ismaili caliph of Egypt al-Hakim made the rules of dhimma harsher (heavy crosses and wooden blocks hung from the neck, special dress), ordered churches and synagogues destroyed — from late September 1009 the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem — and forced some Christians and Jews to accept Islam. In his last years (c. 1017–1021) the caliph allowed the converts to return to their faith; his son al-Zahir permitted the rebuilding of the Holy Sepulchre (1027–1028).
Adherents
Estimates of the number of adherents by year; the timeline draws the lane's thickness from them.
- 202060Kestimates: 40K–120KEstimates of 40,000 to 50,000 adherents (JTA, Religion News Service) and about 2 % of US Jews (JTA); about 100 congregations; per the Pew Research Center (2020) all smaller branches together (Reconstructionist, Renewal, Humanistic) are 4 % of US Jews
Relations and critique
What this tradition took from others and what others took from it, what is claimed about it and what it claims, contradictions and contested texts — one standard for everyone.
What the colour shows
- Rests directly on the primary texts
- Rests on one place of the primary texts
- Rests only on secondary texts
- No support found in the library's texts
- Not marked
The colour shows what the tradition's wording rests on in the library's texts — by the references printed in its documents, the quotations found in them and the places of the primary texts listed by the editors; when the same texts have places read against it, the colour is at most yellow. It is not a judgement of truth.