A violation of a norm · Official · Law
'Cast down and do not raise up': the killing of heretics and informers in rabbinic law
In the name of
- Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism
- Orthodox Judaism· Judaism
What happened
Details
- Who
- The rabbinic codes (the Tosefta, the Talmud, Maimonides, the Shulchan Arukh) and those who acted on them
- When
- from the Talmud (c. 500; earlier the Tosefta); codified by Maimonides (c. 1180) and the Shulchan Arukh (1565)
- Reach
- Official
- Carried out by
- Law
- Severity
- Killings and executions
- Now
- Ongoing
- Victims
- Not counted; known are the executions of informers by the communal courts of Spain (a separate entry) and, according to Maimonides, in the Maghreb.
How its law and leaders stood toward it
3500 – 1884 · Not applied · Rabbinic Judaism
The norm was in the codes — the Talmud ('cast down and do not raise up', Avodah Zarah 26a–b), Maimonides (c. 1180: 'a commandment to kill' the apikorsim) and the Shulchan Arukh (1565: 'it is permitted to kill an informer anywhere, even nowadays') — and no leading authority contested it before the late 19th century, but it was not applied, or only extremely rarely. No case of a heretic killed under it is known (My Jewish Learning calls the Talmudic formula a hyperbole never followed in practice); Maimonides limits it to the founders of a heresy, not their descendants (the Karaites). Informers were killed in some medieval communities: in the Maghreb, Maimonides reports, it happened often; in Castile and Aragon the communal courts had them executed by royal licence (1270s–1391; a separate entry). Communities usually lacked the power to apply it.
- Rationalist Judaism, 'Rambam's Zealous Heresy-Hunting' (Laws of the Murderer 4:10)
- E. Brand, 'Instances in Jewish Literature of Extra-judicial Execution of Idol Worshippers, Informers, Apostates, and Heretics'
- Wikipedia, 'Mesirah'
- My Jewish Learning, 'Heresy in Judaism'
- Jewish Encyclopedia, 'Moser' (1906)
1884 – 1900 · Contested · Rabbinic Judaism
Leading authorities began to narrow the norm: the Arukh HaShulchan of R. Yechiel Michel Epstein (printed in small volumes in 1884–1893, beginning with Choshen Mishpat; 388:7) — the laws of the informer apply only under an unjust government. From 1900 Orthodoxy is counted (the next item).
1900 – · Contested · Orthodox Judaism
Leading authorities narrowed or suspended the rule: the Arukh HaShulchan (R. Y. M. Epstein, Choshen Mishpat 388:7; the work printed in 1884–1893, beginning with Choshen Mishpat) — the laws of the informer apply only under an unjust government; R. E. Waldenberg (Tzitz Eliezer 19:52) — informing a just government, e.g. of child abuse, is permitted; the Chazon Ish (Yoreh De'ah 2:16, in his laws of slaughter; d. 1953; the volume's year was not established) — moridin applies only when divine providence is manifest, and in our time those who stray are to be brought back 'with cords of love', and he regards today's non-observant Jews as 'children taken captive'. Yigal Amir's appeal to the 'law of the pursuer' (1995) is in the entry on the extremists. From 1900 Orthodoxy is counted: Reform Judaism does not hold halakha binding (the Pittsburgh Platform, 1885).
- Etzion, 'The Status of Chilonim in Halakha (Part 2)'
- Tradition, 'Orthodoxy and Her…' (Chazon Ish, Yoreh De'ah 2:16)
- Gray Matter IV, 'The Mesirah Dilemma' (Sefaria)
- R. C. Jachter, 'The Mesirah Dilemma' (Kol Torah): Arukh HaShulchan, Choshen Mishpat 388:7; Tzitz Eliezer 19:52
- Drisha: 'The Law of Moridin Nowadays' (Hazon Ish, Yoreh De'ah 2)
Prevailing: the direction's law and recognised leaders hold the rule and do not contest it; contested: it is still in the law, but leading authorities have publicly rejected or suspended it; repudiated: officially abandoned.
The texts cited
1Murderer and the Preservation of Life, 6Mishneh Torah
The law of the 'pursuer' (rodef), from which the codes derive the right to kill an informer who threatens Jewish lives or property.
Places its perpetrators cited as grounds; this is not a judgement of the texts themselves.
Sources
7- Rationalist Judaism, 'Rambam's Zealous Heresy-Hunting'
- E. Brand, 'Instances in Jewish Literature of Extra-judicial Execution…'
- Shulchan Arukh, Choshen Mishpat 388 (translation, Wikisource)
- Daf Yomi, Gittin 56: 'One may kill a moser'
- Wikipedia, 'Mesirah'
- Wikipedia, 'Tinok shenishba'
- Etzion, 'The Status of Chilonim in Halakha (Part 2)'
In red: violence and coercion in a tradition's name (executions, torture, coercion, child marriage, slavery); teaching and disapproval without force are not marked. On a religion's overview line, red means that its own law and recognised leaders hold such a rule without contesting it, in proportion to the share of its followers in those schools and churches; it describes norms and institutions, not every believer.