Skip to content

Old Catholic churches · tenet

Papal infallibility rejected

Support: Not stated in plain words; places againstStated: 1889
The papal dogmas of 1870 are not accepted.

Why this colour

The primary texts (The Bible) do not state it in plain words — see the editors' note. In the tradition's documents no references are printed; no quotation of the primary texts was found. The editors list 2 places of the same primary texts that are read against it (see “Places read against it”).

against: 2statements: 1

Primary texts: The Bible

Places read against it

2

Luke 22:32Synodal· read against

But I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not: and when thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren.

In translation: KJV

но Я молился о тебе, чтобы не оскудела вера твоя; и ты некогда, обратившись, утверди братьев твоих.

"I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not… strengthen thy brethren": the First Vatican Council (Pastor aeternus, ch. 4) cites these words as the ground of the infallibility of Peter's see; the Old Catholics, like the Orthodox and Protestants, refer the promise to Peter himself and to his turning back after the denial.

Matt 16:18–19Synodal· read against

And I say also unto thee, That thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on ear…

In translation: KJV

и Я говорю тебе: ты - Петр, и на сем камне Я создам Церковь мою, и врата ада не одолеют ее; и дам тебе ключи Царства Небесного: и что свяжешь на земле, то будет связано на небесах, и что разрешишь на земле, то будет разрешено на небесах.

"Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church… I will give unto thee the keys": the First Vatican Council (Pastor aeternus, ch. 1) derives from it the primacy of Peter and his successors; the Old Catholics, following many fathers, see the rock as Peter's confession of faith and do not extend the promise to the bishops of Rome as infallible.

Places of the same primary texts that are read against this tenet; the note says how each side reads them.

What the texts do not say

Not stated in plain words in the primary texts

Scripture says nothing about the bishop of Rome, neither for his infallibility nor against it; the Old Catholics reject the dogmas of 1870 by appeal to the faith of the ancient Church, not to a particular verse.

Where the tradition says it

1

The Declaration of Utrecht (1889; English translation in the Lambeth Conference report of 1930) · Declaration of the Church of Utrecht · 1889

Open in Read
The tradition's words
We therefore reject the decrees of the so-called Council of the Vatican, which were promulgated July 18th, 1870, concerning the infallibility and the universal Episcopate of the Bishop of Rome—decrees which are in contradiction with the faith of the ancient Church, and which destroy its ancient canonical constitution by attributing to the Pope the plenitude of ecclesiastical powers over all Dioceses and over all the faithful. By denial of his primatial jurisdiction we do not wish to deny the historic primacy which several Œcumenical Councils and the Fathers of the ancient Church have attributed to the Bishop of Rome by recognising him as the Primus inter pares.

Here the document itself prints no references and quotes no primary text word for word.

What the colour shows

  • Rests directly on the primary texts
  • Rests on one place of the primary texts
  • Rests only on secondary texts
  • No support found in the library's texts
  • Not marked

If places of the primary texts are read against the tenet, the grade is at most yellow (“Places both for and against”); red stays red. The colour does not decide who is right.

The colour shows what the tradition's wording rests on in the library's texts — by the references printed in its documents, the quotations found in them and the places of the primary texts listed by the editors; when the same texts have places read against it, the colour is at most yellow. It is not a judgement of truth.