Skip to content

Catholicism · tenet

Papal primacy

Support: Places both for and againstStated: 1869–1870
Peter and his successors hold primacy of jurisdiction over the whole Church.

Why this colour

The tradition's positions rest on one place of the primary texts (The Bible) only — references printed: 3; quotations were found: Matt 16:16–18, Matt 16:18–19. The editors also list 4 places of the same primary texts that are read against it (see “Places read against it”) — so the colour is at most yellow. See the editors' note on what the primary texts do not state in plain words.

primary: 3quotations: 1against: 4statements: 3

Primary texts: The Bible

Places read against it

4

1 Cor 3:11Synodal· read against

For other foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus Christ.

In translation: KJV

Ибо никто не может положить другого основания, кроме положенного, которое есть Иисус Христос.

"Other foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus Christ": Protestants and many Orthodox interpreters cite this verse for the rock of the Church being Christ or faith in him, not Peter and his successors; Catholics (the First Vatican Council) read Matt 16:18 of Peter without denying that the foundation is Christ.

Matt 18:18Synodal· read against

Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.

In translation: KJV

Истинно говорю вам: что вы свяжете на земле, то будет связано на небе; и что разрешите на земле, то будет разрешено на небе.

"Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven": the Orthodox and Protestants point out that the power to bind and loose promised to Peter (Matt 16:19) is given to all the apostles; Catholics see in Peter and his successors a particular primacy within that shared power.

Gal 2:11Synodal· read against

But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.

In translation: KJV

Когда же Петр пришел в Антиохию, то я лично противостал ему, потому что он подвергался нареканию.

"I withstood him to the face": opponents of papal primacy (Protestants, the Orthodox) point out that Paul openly rebuked Peter at Antioch; Catholics take it as a rebuke of conduct that does not touch Peter's authority.

1 Pet 5:1–3Synodal· read against

The elders which are among you I exhort, who am also an elder, and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, and also a partaker of the glory that shall be revealed: Feed the flock of God which is among you, taking the oversight thereof, not b…

In translation: KJV

Пастырей ваших умоляю я, сопастырь и свидетель страданий Христовых и соучастник в славе, которая должна открыться: пасите Божие стадо, какое у вас, надзирая за ним не принужденно, но охотно и богоугодно, не для гнусной корысти, но из усерди…

"The elders which are among you I exhort, who am also an elder… feed the flock… neither as being lords over God's heritage": the Orthodox and Protestants point out that Peter calls himself one elder among others and forbids lordship over the flock; Catholics see here the apostle's humility, not a renunciation of primacy.

Places of the same primary texts that are read against this tenet; the note says how each side reads them. Because of them the grade is at most yellow.

What the texts do not say

Not stated in plain words in the primary texts

Scripture does not speak outright of Peter's successors or of their authority over the whole Church: the words about the rock and the keys (Matt 16:18–19) and 'feed my sheep' (John 21:15–17) are addressed to Peter; applying them to the bishops of Rome is an interpretation, fixed by the council of 1870.

Where the tradition says it

3

First Vatican Council: Dei Filius and Pastor Aeternus (English) · Of the Institution of the Apostolic Primacy in blessed Peter. · 1869–1870

Open in Read
The tradition's words
We therefore teach and declare that, according to the testimony of the Gospel, the primacy of jurisdiction over the universal Church of God was immediately and directly promised and given to blessed Peter the Apostle by Christ the Lord. For it was to Simon alone, to whom he had already said: 'Thou shalt be called Cephas,' that the Lord after the confession made by him, saying: 'Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God,' addressed these solemn words: 'Blessed art thou, Simon Bar-Jona, because flesh and blood have not revealed it to thee, but my Father who is in heaven. And I say to thee that thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven. And whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth, it shall be bound also in heaven; and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth, it shall…
References printed in the textprimary: 3 · secondary: 0
  • John 1:42primary text

    And he brought him to Jesus. And when Jesus beheld him, he said, Thou art Simon the son of Jona: thou shalt be called Cephas, which is by interpretation, A stone.

  • Matt 16:16–19primary text

    And Simon Peter answered and said, Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God. And Jesus answered and said unto him, Blessed art thou, Simon Barjona: for flesh and blood hath not revealed it unto thee, but my Father which is in heaven. And I say also unto thee, That thou art Peter, and upon this…

  • John 21:15–17primary text

    So when they had dined, Jesus saith to Simon Peter, Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou me more than these? He saith unto him, Yea, Lord; thou knowest that I love thee. He saith unto him, Feed my lambs. He saith to him again the second time, Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou me? He saith unto him, Yea,…

Quotations found2

  • Matt 16:16–18close

    «Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God. And Jesus answering said to him, Blessed art thou, Simon Bar-jona, for flesh and blood has not revealed [it] to thee, but my Father who is in the heavens. And I also, I say unto thee that thou art Peter»

  • Matt 16:18–19close

    «and on this rock I will build my assembly, and hades' gates shall not prevail against it. And I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of the heavens; and whatsoever thou mayest bind upon the earth shall be bound in the heavens; and whatsoever thou mayest loose on the earth shall be loosed in»

First Vatican Council: Dei Filius and Pastor Aeternus (English) · On the Perpetuity of the Primacy of blessed Peter in the Roman Pontiffs. · 1869–1870

Open in Read
The tradition's words
That which the Prince of Shepherds and great Shepherd of the sheep, Jesus Christ our Lord, established in the person of the blessed Apostle Peter to secure the perpetual welfare and lasting good of the Church, must, by the same institution, necessarily remain unceasingly in the Church; which, being founded upon the Rock, will stand firm to the end of the world. For none can doubt, and it is known to all ages, that the holy and blessed Peter, the Prince and Chief of the Apostles, the pillar of the faith and foundation of the Catholic Church, received the keys of the kingdom from our Lord Jesus Christ, the Saviour and Redeemer of mankind, and lives, presides, and judges, to this day and always, in his successors the Bishops of the Holy See of Rome, which was founded by him, and consecrated by his blood. Whence, whosoever succeeds to Peter in this See, does by the institution of Christ hims…

Here the document itself prints no references and quotes no primary text word for word.

First Vatican Council: Dei Filius and Pastor Aeternus (English) · On the Power and Nature of the Primacy of the Roman Pontiff. · 1869–1870

Open in Read
The tradition's words
Wherefore, resting on plain testimonies of the Sacred Writings, and adhering to the plain and express decrees both of our predecessors, the Roman Pontiffs, and of the General Councils, we renew the definition of the œcumenical Council of Florence, in virtue of which all the faithful of Christ must believe that the holy Apostolic See and the Roman Pontiff possesses the primacy over the whole world, and that the Roman Pontiff is the successor of blessed Peter, Prince of the Apostles, and is true vicar of Christ, and head of the whole Church, and father and teacher of all Christians; and that full power was given to him in blessed Peter to rule, feed, and govern the universal Church by Jesus Christ our Lord; as is also contained in the acts of the General Councils and in the sacred Canons. Hence we teach and declare that by the appointment of our Lord the Roman Church possesses a superiorit…

Here the document itself prints no references and quotes no primary text word for word.

What the colour shows

  • Rests directly on the primary texts
  • Rests on one place of the primary texts
  • Rests only on secondary texts
  • No support found in the library's texts
  • Not marked

If places of the primary texts are read against the tenet, the grade is at most yellow (“Places both for and against”); red stays red. The colour does not decide who is right.

The colour shows what the tradition's wording rests on in the library's texts — by the references printed in its documents, the quotations found in them and the places of the primary texts listed by the editors; when the same texts have places read against it, the colour is at most yellow. It is not a judgement of truth.