Skip to content

Ruling 2

Dataset: Synthetic commentary school (§15)Profile: Scroll and school commentaries (fictional profile)synthetic example

Other profiles:Scroll only (fictional profile)

What changes without one link? →Critical dependencies (minimal sets) →

What does it rest on without them?

Each action computes the scenario on the server at once and opens the result.

What does it rest on?

Foundations in the chosen profile, without interventions.

  • attested

    Arguments: Ruling 2 through the School X rule

    Rules:

    Interpretive rule

    School X rule: the ban on taking includes selling

    derives a position

    While the rule is active, a claim is derived from the listed readings. Without the rule this derivation is not made.

    Formalization
    From the literal reading of 1:2 a ban on selling is derived.
    Whose contribution
    School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading rules
    Derives

    → School X: selling field produce on the seventh day is forbidden

    from readings:

    • Literal· passage: Scroll of the Spring, 1:2synthetic example
    Enabled in profiles
    in no profile
    ⊘ exclude this rule

    Original foundations

  • attested

    Arguments: Ruling 2 through the School Y comment

    Original foundations

Through whom did it come?

Documented links: arrows point from the source to the dependent passage.

  1. Commentary of the House of Blue Stones, 2School Y — House of Blue Stones (fictional)without them →explicit citationBook of Rulings, 2Council of Rulings (fictional)without them →
    candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    undated

Hypotheses and topical similarity

Shown separately and never used as established lineage.

No hypothetical links for this target.

Who was first?

Earliest witness in the base
Book of Rulings, 2800–850 (fictional date)
Earliest considered variant of the wording
Book of Rulings, 2
Estimated date of the work
Book of Rulings800–850 (fictional date)
Date of the surviving carrier
not given in the base
Date of discovery / publication
not given in the base
Authorship or origin

The earliest record in the dataset is not the moment of invention; an earlier date alone does not establish the direction of borrowing.

Dependency graph

Drag to pan; Ctrl/⌘ + wheel to zoom; Tab through nodes. Link labels appear for the selected node.

Decision of the Council of Rulings (fictional) → 1 2: adoption actSchool X rule: the ban on taking includes selling → School X: selling field produce on the seventh day is forbidden: derives by ruleScroll of the Spring 1:2 → Literal: reading of passageBook of Rulings 2 → Ruling 2: reading of passageCommentary of the House of Blue Stones 2 → School Y comment: reading of passageLiteral → Ruling 2 through the School Y comment: premiseSchool X: selling field produce on the seventh day is forbidden → Ruling 2 through the School X rule: premiseSchool Y: trading is taking → Ruling 2 through the School Y comment: premiseCommentary of the House of Blue Stones 2 → Book of Rulings 2: explicit citationSchool Y comment → School Y: trading is taking: yields claimRuling 2 through the School X rule → Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day: concludesconcludesRuling 2 through the School Y comment → Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day: concludesconcludesRuling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day → 1 2: norm of claimnorm of claimRuling 2 → Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day: yields claimyields claimDecision of the Council of Rulings (fictional) — active● adoptionDecision of theCouncil of Rulings(fictional)◇ synthetic exampleScroll of the Spring 1:2 — active● passageScroll of the Spring1:2◇ synthetic exampleSchool X rule: the ban on taking includes selling — active● interpretive ruleSchool X rule: theban on takingincludes sellingCommentary of the House of Blue Stones 2 — active● passageCommentary of theHouse of Blue Stones2◇ synthetic exampleBook of Rulings — active● documentBook of Rulings◇ synthetic exampleLiteral — active● readingLiteralSchool X: selling field produce on the seventh day is forbidden — active● claimSchool X: sellingfield produce on theseventh day is…◇ synthetic exampleBook of Rulings 2 — active● passageBook of Rulings 2◇ synthetic exampleSchool Y comment — active● readingSchool Y commentRuling 2 through the School X rule — active● argumentRuling 2 through theSchool X rule◇ synthetic exampleRuling 2 — active● readingRuling 2School Y: trading is taking — active● claimSchool Y: trading istaking◇ synthetic exampleRuling 2 through the School Y comment — active● argumentRuling 2 through theSchool Y comment◇ synthetic exampleRuling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day — active● claimRuling 2: the marketis closed on theseventh day◇ synthetic example1 2 — active● norm1 2◇ synthetic example

Selected node

Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day

activeclaim
  • Ruling 2 through the School X rule Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day · concludes
  • Ruling 2 through the School Y comment Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day · concludes
  • Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day 1 2 · norm of claim
  • Ruling 2 Ruling 2: the market is closed on the seventh day · yields claim

Legend

Nodes

  • active

Links

  • adoption act
  • concludes
  • derives by rule
  • reading of passage
  • norm of claim
  • premise
  • explicit citation
  • yields claim

Arrows point from the source to the dependent passage.

Limits

Enumeration complete

Annotation coverage

Passages annotated
12 / 12
Relations reviewed
0 / 5
Arguments annotated
5 / 5
Dated
5 / 5
Norms
2 / 2

Warnings

  • Synthetic dataset: results illustrate the logic and are not a historical finding.