Lab
Lab
A target, a base and one intervention. The resulting diff comes first, the explanation second.
Dataset presets
Pick a preset — the server evaluates it right away
TARGET
Positions, norms or claims whose change you want to see. Optional: with none chosen, everything affected is evaluated
BASE
Sources, foundation profile, date and history model
Do not model history. Models are chosen in mode F of the intervention dialog
INTERVENTION
Author, contribution, rule or transmission
- DBreak transmission: School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional), all contributions, traditional attribution
Mode: D · Alternative justifications: Report attested alternatives
Hide only, no recomputation
Hiding is recorded in the report, but the semantic result is neither recomputed nor changed.
Resulting diff
Each target is a vector of separate dimensions, not a single verdict.
Mode: DBreak transmission: School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional), all contributions, traditional attribution
no targets
Control targets: the intervention did not change them. They stay visible so it is clear what was not affected.
no targets
norm
Norm: ruling 1
No change in any dimension of the status vector. The claim keeps a justification; paths lost: 1, surviving: 1. The adoption record in the provided version is kept; loss of justification does not revoke it.
Documented prevalence: 1Sets of original bases that do not pass through the excluded item by known links (relative to the model): 1— The number of places is not the number of independent foundations.
- Text
- Baseline: Wording present
- After interventionWording present
- Meaning
- Baseline: Exact claim preservedReadings unchanged · admissible readings: 2
- After interventionExact claim preservedReadings unchanged · admissible readings: 2
- Justification
- Baseline: Has a foundation in the profilepaths: 1
- After interventionHas a foundation in the profilepaths: 1
- Objections
- Baseline: No objections
- After interventionNo objections
- Normative status
- Baseline: Adopted under the provided record: yesPresent in the provided document: yes · Has an admissible justification in the scenario: yes
- After interventionAdopted under the provided record: yesPresent in the provided document: yes · Has an admissible justification in the scenario: yes
- Does not apply:
- Transmission, Sermon check, History model
| Dimension | Baseline | After intervention |
|---|---|---|
| Text | Wording present | Wording present |
| Meaning | Exact claim preserved Readings unchanged · admissible readings: 2 | Exact claim preserved Readings unchanged · admissible readings: 2 |
| Justification | Has a foundation in the profile paths: 1 | Has a foundation in the profile paths: 1 |
| Objections | No objections | No objections |
| Transmission | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| Normative status | Adopted under the provided record: yes Present in the provided document: yes · Has an admissible justification in the scenario: yes | Adopted under the provided record: yes Present in the provided document: yes · Has an admissible justification in the scenario: yes |
| Sermon check | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| History model | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Stage 1. Loss of bases
What disappeared and what remains of the attested bases.
✕ What was lost
- attestedpasses through an excluded contribution
Arguments: Ruling 1 from the X comment and 1:1
Original foundations
Scroll of the Spring, 1:1
Keep water for the traveller.
reading: Literal
origins:Keepers of the Scroll (fictional): Scroll of the SpringCompendium of Sayings, 17
The Grey Feathers said: 'the traveller' includes the enemy.
reading: Transmission of the School X comment
origins:Compiler of the Compendium (fictional): Compendium: transmission of the X commentSchool X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading of the travellerSchool X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X commentary (text)
● What remains
- attesteddoes not pass through the excluded author via known links
Arguments: Ruling 1 from the X comment and 1:1
Original foundations
Scroll of the Spring, 1:1⊘ exclude this source
Keep water for the traveller.
reading: Literal
origins:Keepers of the Scroll (fictional): Scroll of the Spring⊘ exclude this contributionCommentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 1⊘ exclude this source
'The traveller' includes your enemy.
reading: School X comment
origins:School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading of the traveller⊘ exclude this contributionSchool X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X commentary (text)⊘ exclude this contribution
✎ Stage 2. Search for reconstructions
No search for reconstructions was requested in this experiment.
Attested alternatives of stage 1 are listed under “What remains”.
Why? Justification paths
Loading…
Normative status
- Present in the provided document
- yes
- Adopted under the provided record
- yes
- Has an admissible justification in the scenario
- yes
Losing a justification does not revoke a recorded act of adoption.
Norm clause
synthetic example- Document
- Book of Rulings · Northern Spring tradition (fictional)
- Clause
- 1
- Version
- 1
- Clause text
- The well is open to enemies too.
- Position
- Ruling 1: the well is open to enemies
- Scope
- all villages of the tradition
- Exceptions
- no exceptions given
- Period in force
- from 820 (fictional date)
- Adoption
- Adopted by:
- Council of Rulings (fictional)
- Procedure:
- Decision of the Council of Rulings (fictional)
- Date:
- 820 (fictional date)
- Record:
- Council roll 1 (fictional)
synthetic example
Limits
Annotation coverage
- Passages annotated
- 12 / 12
- Relations reviewed
- 0 / 5
- Arguments annotated
- 5 / 5
- Dated
- 5 / 5
- Norms
- 2 / 2
Warnings
- Synthetic dataset: results illustrate the logic and are not a historical finding.
- Displayed justifications rely on relations not yet human-verified (review_status candidate): «Commentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 1 → Compendium of Sayings, 17».
What the intervention affects
Break transmission: School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional), all contributions, traditional attribution
contributions: 3 · passages: 2 · rules: 2 · relations: 2 · arguments: 0
School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading of the traveller; School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading rules; School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X commentary (text)
Commentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 1; Commentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 2
Engine: versemora-core 0.2.0 · Result hash: 092dfe9fbc0e6907 · state: 2fcd128a6a5c6a11
The graph as an explanation of the selected change
Norm: ruling 1
Loading…