Skip to content

Lab

Lab

A target, a base and one intervention. The resulting diff comes first, the explanation second.

Dataset presets

Pick a preset — the server evaluates it right away

TARGET

Positions, norms or claims whose change you want to see. Optional: with none chosen, everything affected is evaluated

selected: 7
norms
readings
rulings

BASE

Sources, foundation profile, date and history model

synthetic setsynthetic example
History model

Do not model history. Models are chosen in mode F of the intervention dialog

INTERVENTION

Author, contribution, rule or transmission

  • DBreak transmission: School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional), all contributions, traditional attribution

Intervention

One dialog — six different operations. Choose exactly what to remove.

Mode
Scope of exclusion
Attribution

Adds two joint interventions for one participant: “not accepted as a basis” (B) and “break transmission” (D).

Policies
Quotations of an excluded source
Preserve lineage, no re-entry through paraphrase
Norms
Preserve recorded acts of adoption
Unknown
Keep unknown
Alternative justifications

Mode: D · Alternative justifications: Report attested alternatives

Hide only, no recomputation

Hiding is recorded in the report, but the semantic result is neither recomputed nor changed.

Resulting diff

Each target is a vector of separate dimensions, not a single verdict.

Mode: DBreak transmission: School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional), all contributions, traditional attribution

Changed0

no targets

    Preserved7

    Control targets: the intervention did not change them. They stay visible so it is clear what was not affected.

    Unknown / not annotated0

    no targets

      norm

      Norm: ruling 1

      No change in any dimension of the status vector. The claim keeps a justification; paths lost: 1, surviving: 1. The adoption record in the provided version is kept; loss of justification does not revoke it.

      Documented prevalence: 1Sets of original bases that do not pass through the excluded item by known links (relative to the model): 1— The number of places is not the number of independent foundations.

      Text
      Baseline: Wording present
      After interventionWording present
      Meaning
      Baseline: Exact claim preservedReadings unchanged · admissible readings: 2
      After interventionExact claim preservedReadings unchanged · admissible readings: 2
      Justification
      Baseline: Has a foundation in the profilepaths: 1
      After interventionHas a foundation in the profilepaths: 1
      Objections
      Baseline: No objections
      After interventionNo objections
      Normative status
      Baseline: Adopted under the provided record: yesPresent in the provided document: yes · Has an admissible justification in the scenario: yes
      After interventionAdopted under the provided record: yesPresent in the provided document: yes · Has an admissible justification in the scenario: yes
      Does not apply:
      Transmission, Sermon check, History model

      Stage 1. Loss of bases

      What disappeared and what remains of the attested bases.

      ✕ What was lost
      • attestedpasses through an excluded contribution

        Arguments: Ruling 1 from the X comment and 1:1

        Original foundations

        • Scroll of the Spring, 1:1

          Keep water for the traveller.

          reading: Literal

          origins:Keepers of the Scroll (fictional): Scroll of the Spring
        • Compendium of Sayings, 17

          The Grey Feathers said: 'the traveller' includes the enemy.

          reading: Transmission of the School X comment

          origins:Compiler of the Compendium (fictional): Compendium: transmission of the X commentSchool X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading of the travellerSchool X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X commentary (text)
      ● What remains
      • attesteddoes not pass through the excluded author via known links

        Arguments: Ruling 1 from the X comment and 1:1

        Original foundations

      ✎ Stage 2. Search for reconstructions

      No search for reconstructions was requested in this experiment.

      Attested alternatives of stage 1 are listed under “What remains”.

      Why? Justification paths

      Loading…

      Normative status

      Present in the provided document
      yes
      Adopted under the provided record
      yes
      Has an admissible justification in the scenario
      yes

      Losing a justification does not revoke a recorded act of adoption.

      Norm clause

      synthetic example
      Document
      Book of Rulings · Northern Spring tradition (fictional)
      Clause
      1
      Version
      1
      Clause text
      The well is open to enemies too.
      Position
      Ruling 1: the well is open to enemies
      Scope
      all villages of the tradition
      Exceptions
      no exceptions given
      Period in force
      from 820 (fictional date)
      Adoption
      Adopted by:
      Council of Rulings (fictional)
      Procedure:
      Decision of the Council of Rulings (fictional)
      Date:
      820 (fictional date)
      Record:
      Council roll 1 (fictional)
      synthetic example

      Limits

      Enumeration complete

      Annotation coverage

      Passages annotated
      12 / 12
      Relations reviewed
      0 / 5
      Arguments annotated
      5 / 5
      Dated
      5 / 5
      Norms
      2 / 2

      Warnings

      • Synthetic dataset: results illustrate the logic and are not a historical finding.
      • Displayed justifications rely on relations not yet human-verified (review_status candidate): «Commentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 1 → Compendium of Sayings, 17».
      What the intervention affects
      • Break transmission: School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional), all contributions, traditional attribution

        contributions: 3 · passages: 2 · rules: 2 · relations: 2 · arguments: 0

        School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading of the traveller; School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X reading rules; School X — House of Grey Feathers (fictional): School X commentary (text)

        Commentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 1; Commentary of the House of Grey Feathers, 2

      Engine: versemora-core 0.2.0 · Result hash: 092dfe9fbc0e6907 · state: 2fcd128a6a5c6a11

      The graph as an explanation of the selected change

      Norm: ruling 1

      Loading…