Skip to content

2011 address: use of Augustine's formula

Dataset: Pilot: Augustine and loveProfile: Scripture and Augustine (research profile)

Other profiles:Demo profile: Scripture, Augustine and magisterial documents — not a description of any church's actual rulesScripture only (research profile)

What changes without one link? →Critical dependencies (minimal sets) →

What does it rest on without them?

Each action computes the scenario on the server at once and opens the result.

What does it rest on?

Foundations in the chosen profile, without interventions.

  • attested

    Arguments: 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love

    Original foundations

    • First Epistle of John, 4:16⊘ exclude this source

      We know and have believed the love which God has for us. God is love, and he who remains in love remains in God, and God remains in him.

      reading: 'God is love' (4:16)

      origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)⊘ exclude this contributionJohn the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)⊘ exclude this contribution
    • Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.8⊘ exclude this source

      See what we are insisting upon; that the deeds of men are only discerned by the root of charity. … Once for all, then, a short precept is given thee: Love, and do what thou wilt: whether thou hold thy peace, through love hold thy peace; whether thou cry out, through love cry out; whether thou correct, through love correct; whether thou spare, through love do thou spare: let the root of love be within, of this root can nothing spring but what is good.

      reading: 'Love, and do what you will'

      origins:Augustine of Hippo: The formula 'Love, and do what you will' (VII.8)⊘ exclude this contributionAugustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)⊘ exclude this contribution
  • attested

    Arguments: 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love; Hom. VII.7: one act distinguished by love (1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32); Hom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will'

    Original foundations

    • First Epistle of John, 4:16⊘ exclude this source

      We know and have believed the love which God has for us. God is love, and he who remains in love remains in God, and God remains in him.

      reading: 'God is love' (4:16)

      origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)⊘ exclude this contributionJohn the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)⊘ exclude this contribution
    • First Epistle of John, 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11)⊘ exclude this source

      Beloved, let’s love one another, for love is of God; and everyone who loves has been born of God and knows God. He who doesn’t love doesn’t know God, for God is love. … In this is love, not that we loved God, but that he loved us, and sent his Son as the atoning sacrifice for our sins. Beloved, if God loved us in this way, we also ought to love one another.

      reading: Love shown in sending the Son

      origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)⊘ exclude this contributionJohn the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)⊘ exclude this contribution
    • Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32)⊘ exclude this source

      “He that spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all, how hath He not with Him also freely given us all things?”

      reading: Augustine's quotation of Rom 8:32

      origins:Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)⊘ exclude this contributionAugustine of Hippo: Uses of 1 Jn 4, Rom 5:5 and Rom 8:32 in Homily VII⊘ exclude this contributionPaul the Apostle: Romans (selected passages)⊘ exclude this contribution
  • attested

    Arguments: 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love; Hom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will'

    Original foundations

    • First Epistle of John, 4:16⊘ exclude this source

      We know and have believed the love which God has for us. God is love, and he who remains in love remains in God, and God remains in him.

      reading: 'God is love' (4:16)

      origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)⊘ exclude this contributionJohn the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)⊘ exclude this contribution
    • Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7⊘ exclude this source

      Behold the Father delivered up Christ; Judas delivered Him up; does it not seem as if the thing done were of the same sort? … This: that the Father and the Son did it in love, but Judas did this in treacherous betrayal. Ye see that not what the man does is the thing to be considered; but with what mind and will he does it.

      reading: Discernment by intention

      origins:Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)⊘ exclude this contributionAugustine of Hippo: Arguments of Homily VII.6-7⊘ exclude this contribution

? Unresolved dependencies

  • Shared roots of the alternative sets: «Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)», «John the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)», «Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)».

Through whom did it come?

Documented links: arrows point from the source to the dependent passage.

  1. First Epistle of John, 4:16Author of 1 John (not identified)without them →John the Apostle (traditional attribution)without them →explicit citationBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”), paragraph 'What is the soul of holiness?'Benedict XVIwithout them →
    candidateexact formulation · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    via intermediary
    Intermediary:
    Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42 · Second Vatican Council without them →
    Link date:
    2011
  2. Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.8Augustine of Hippowithout them →explicit citationBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”), quotation of Augustine, Tract. VII.8 ('7,8 PL 35')Benedict XVIwithout them →
    human verifiedexact formulation · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    2011
  3. Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42Second Vatican Councilwithout them →explicit citationBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”), paragraph 'What is the soul of holiness?'Benedict XVIwithout them →
    human verifiedfragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    2011
  4. Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42Second Vatican Councilwithout them →explicit citationBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”), paragraph on St Augustine (speaker's own sentences)Benedict XVIwithout them →
    candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    2011
  5. First Epistle to Timothy, 1:5Unidentified author of the Pastoral Epistleswithout them →Paul the Apostlewithout them →explicit citationEnchiridion, 121 (§32 in the numbering cited by LG)Augustine of Hippowithout them →
    candidateexact formulation · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    c. 420–422
  6. candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    c. 420–422
  7. First Epistle of John, 4:16Author of 1 John (not identified)without them →John the Apostle (traditional attribution)without them →explicit citationLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42Second Vatican Councilwithout them →
    candidateexact formulation · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    1964
  8. Enchiridion, 121 (§32 in the numbering cited by LG)Augustine of Hippowithout them →explicit citationLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42Second Vatican Councilwithout them →
    candidategeneral idea · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    1964
  9. Epistle to the Romans, 13:8-10Paul the Apostlewithout them →explicit citationLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42Second Vatican Councilwithout them →
    candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    1964
  10. Epistle to the Romans, 5:5Paul the Apostlewithout them →explicit citationLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church), 42Second Vatican Councilwithout them →
    candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    1964
  11. candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    undated
  12. candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    undated
  13. First Epistle of John, 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11)Author of 1 John (not identified)without them →John the Apostle (traditional attribution)without them →explicit citationTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7Augustine of Hippowithout them →
    candidatefragment · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    c. 407
  14. Epistle to the Romans, 8:32Paul the Apostlewithout them →explicit citationTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32)Augustine of Hippowithout them →
    human verifiedexact formulation · adopts⊘ exclude this link
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    c. 407

Hypotheses and topical similarity

Shown separately and never used as established lineage.

  1. Epistle to the Romans, 13:8-10same topic (not dependence)Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.8
    not a transmission linecandidategeneral idea · neutral
    Access:
    access mode not established
    Intermediary:
    unknown (never filled in)
    Link date:
    undated

Who was first?

Earliest witness in the base
Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”), paragraph on St Augustine (speaker's own sentences)2011 (13 April 2011)
Earliest considered variant of the wording
Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”), paragraph on St Augustine (speaker's own sentences)
Estimated date of the work
Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”)2011 (13 April 2011)
Date of the surviving carrier
not given in the base
Date of discovery / publication
not given in the base
Authorship or origin

The earliest record in the dataset is not the moment of invention; an earlier date alone does not establish the direction of borrowing.

Dependency graph

Drag to pan; Ctrl/⌘ + wheel to zoom; Tab through nodes. Link labels appear for the selected node.

Hom. VII.7: one act distinguished by love (1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32) → Augustine: deeds are discerned by the root of love: concludesHom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will' → Augustine's formula 'Love, and do what you will': concludesFirst Epistle of John 4:16 → 'God is love' (4:16): reading of passageFirst Epistle of John 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11) → 'God is love' (v. 8): reading of passageFirst Epistle of John 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11) → Love shown in sending the Son: reading of passageBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph 'What is the soul of holiness?' → 1 Jn 4:16 inside the LG 42 quotation: reading of passageBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph on St Augustine (speaker's own sentences) → Applying the formula to those guided by love: reading of passageBenedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) quotation of Augustine, Tract. VII.8 ('7,8 PL 35') → Quotation of Augustine's formula: reading of passageLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42 → Quotation of 1 Jn 4:16 in LG 42: reading of passageEpistle to the Romans 8:32 → God delivered up his Son for all: reading of passageTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.7 → Discernment by intention: reading of passageTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32) → Augustine's quotation of Rom 8:32: reading of passageTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.8 → 'Love, and do what you will': reading of passageAugustine: deeds are discerned by the root of love → Hom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will': premiseAugustine's formula 'Love, and do what you will' → 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love: premise'God is love' (predicate reading) → 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love: premiseLove shown in sending the Son → Hom. VII.7: one act distinguished by love (1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32): premiseAugustine's quotation of Rom 8:32 → Hom. VII.7: one act distinguished by love (1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32): premiseFirst Epistle of John 4:16 → Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph 'What is the soul of holiness?': explicit citationTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.8 → Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) quotation of Augustine, Tract. VII.8 ('7,8 PL 35'): explicit citationLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42 → Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph 'What is the soul of holiness?': explicit citationLumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42 → Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph on St Augustine (speaker's own sentences): explicit citationFirst Epistle of John 4:16 → Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42: explicit citationEnchiridion 121 (§32 in the numbering cited by LG) → Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42: explicit citationEpistle to the Romans 13:8-10 → Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42: explicit citationEpistle to the Romans 5:5 → Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42: explicit citationEpistle to the Romans 13:8-10 → Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.8: same topic (not dependence)First Epistle of John 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11) → Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.6: explicit citationFirst Epistle of John 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11) → Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.7: explicit citationEpistle to the Romans 8:32 → Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32): explicit citation'God is love' (4:16) → 'God is love' (predicate reading): yields claim'God is love' (v. 8) → 'God is love' (predicate reading): yields claim1 Jn 4:16 inside the LG 42 quotation → 'God is love' (predicate reading): yields claimQuotation of Augustine's formula → Augustine's formula 'Love, and do what you will': yields claimQuotation of 1 Jn 4:16 in LG 42 → 'God is love' (predicate reading): yields claimDiscernment by intention → Augustine: deeds are discerned by the root of love: yields claim'Love, and do what you will' → Augustine's formula 'Love, and do what you will': yields claim2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love → 2011 address: application of Augustine's formula: concludesconcludesApplying the formula to those guided by love → 2011 address: application of Augustine's formula: yields claimyields claimTen Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.8 — active● passageTen Homilies(Tractates) on theFirst Epistle of Joh…First Epistle of John 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11) — active● passageFirst Epistle of John4:7-12 (cited: 7-8,10-11)First Epistle of John 4:16 — active● passageFirst Epistle of John4:16Enchiridion 121 (§32 in the numbering cited by LG) — context (not a foundation)○ passageEnchiridion 121 (§32in the numberingcited by LG)Epistle to the Romans 13:8-10 — context (not a foundation)○ passageEpistle to the Romans13:8-10Epistle to the Romans 5:5 — context (not a foundation)○ passageEpistle to the Romans5:5Epistle to the Romans 8:32 — active● passageEpistle to the Romans8:32Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) quotation of Augustine, Tract. VII.8 ('7,8 PL 35') — active● passageBenedict XVI, GeneralAudience of 13 April2011 (“Holiness”)…Love shown in sending the Son — active● readingLove shown in sendingthe Son'Love, and do what you will' — active● reading'Love, and do whatyou will''God is love' (4:16) — active● reading'God is love' (4:16)'God is love' (v. 8) — active● reading'God is love' (v. 8)Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.7 — active● passageTen Homilies(Tractates) on theFirst Epistle of Joh…Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32) — active● passageTen Homilies(Tractates) on theFirst Epistle of Joh…Lumen gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church) 42 — active● passageLumen gentium(DogmaticConstitution on the…Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John Hom. VII.6 — context (not a foundation)○ passageTen Homilies(Tractates) on theFirst Epistle of Joh…God delivered up his Son for all — active● readingGod delivered up hisSon for allQuotation of Augustine's formula — active● readingQuotation ofAugustine's formulaDiscernment by intention — active● readingDiscernment byintentionAugustine's quotation of Rom 8:32 — active● readingAugustine's quotationof Rom 8:32Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph on St Augustine (speaker's own sentences) — active● passageBenedict XVI, GeneralAudience of 13 April2011 (“Holiness”)…Quotation of 1 Jn 4:16 in LG 42 — active● readingQuotation of 1 Jn4:16 in LG 42Benedict XVI, General Audience of 13 April 2011 (“Holiness”) paragraph 'What is the soul of holiness?' — active● passageBenedict XVI, GeneralAudience of 13 April2011 (“Holiness”)…Hom. VII.7: one act distinguished by love (1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32) — active● argumentHom. VII.7: one actdistinguished by love(1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32)Applying the formula to those guided by love — active● readingApplying the formulato those guided bylove1 Jn 4:16 inside the LG 42 quotation — active● reading1 Jn 4:16 inside theLG 42 quotationAugustine: deeds are discerned by the root of love — active● claimAugustine: deeds arediscerned by the rootof love'God is love' (predicate reading) — active● claim'God is love'(predicate reading)Hom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will' — active● argumentHom. VII.8: the shortprecept 'Love, and dowhat you will'Augustine's formula 'Love, and do what you will' — active● claimAugustine's formula'Love, and do whatyou will'2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love — active● argument2011 address:Augustine's formulaapplies because God…2011 address: application of Augustine's formula — active● claim2011 address:application ofAugustine's formula

Selected node

2011 address: application of Augustine's formula

activeclaim
  • 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love 2011 address: application of Augustine's formula · concludes
  • Applying the formula to those guided by love 2011 address: application of Augustine's formula · yields claim

Legend

Nodes

  • active
  • context (not a foundation)

Links

  • concludes
  • reading of passage
  • premise
  • explicit citation
  • same topic (not dependence)
  • yields claim

Arrows point from the source to the dependent passage.

Limits

Enumeration complete

Annotation coverage

Passages annotated
24 / 25
Relations reviewed
5 / 18
Arguments annotated
6 / 8
Dated
11 / 12
Norms
no data