Lab
Lab
A target, a base and one intervention. The resulting diff comes first, the explanation second.
Dataset presets
Pick a preset — the server evaluates it right away
TARGET
Positions, norms or claims whose change you want to see. Optional: with none chosen, everything affected is evaluated
BASE
Sources, foundation profile, date and history model
Do not model history. Models are chosen in mode F of the intervention dialog
INTERVENTION
Author, contribution, rule or transmission
- EDo not accept as foundation: Augustine of Hippo, all contributions, traditional attribution
Mode: B + search for reconstructions (E) · Alternative justifications: Then separately propose reconstructions
Hide only, no recomputation
Hiding is recorded in the report, but the semantic result is neither recomputed nor changed.
Resulting diff
Each target is a vector of separate dimensions, not a single verdict.
Mode: B + search for reconstructions (E)Do not accept as foundation: Augustine of Hippo, all contributions, traditional attribution
Control targets: the intervention did not change them. They stay visible so it is clear what was not affected.
no targets
position
2011 address: use of Augustine's formula
All annotated justifications in the selected profile are disabled. This does not establish that the claim is false. Only the broader claim remains; the refinement is no longer justified.
Documented prevalence: 1Sets of original bases that do not pass through the excluded item by known links (relative to the model): 0— The number of places is not the number of independent foundations.
- Text
- Baseline: Wording present
- After interventionWording present
- Meaning◆ changed
- Baseline: Exact claim preservedReadings unchanged · admissible readings: 1
- After interventionOnly a broader claim remainsReadings unchanged · admissible readings: 1
- Justification◆ changed
- Baseline: Has a foundation in the profilepaths: 3
- After interventionNo known foundations in the profile (not falsity)paths: 0
- Objections
- Baseline: No objections
- After interventionNo objections
- Does not apply:
- Transmission, Normative status, Sermon check, History model
| Dimension | Baseline | After intervention |
|---|---|---|
| Text | Wording present | Wording present |
| Meaning◆ changed | Exact claim preserved Readings unchanged · admissible readings: 1 | Only a broader claim remains Readings unchanged · admissible readings: 1 |
| Justification◆ changed | Has a foundation in the profile paths: 3 | No known foundations in the profile (not falsity) paths: 0 |
| Objections | No objections | No objections |
| Transmission | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| Normative status | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| Sermon check | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| History model | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Stage 1. Loss of bases
What disappeared and what remains of the attested bases.
✕ What was lost
- attestedpasses through an excluded contribution
Arguments: 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love
Original foundations
First Epistle of John, 4:16
We know and have believed the love which God has for us. God is love, and he who remains in love remains in God, and God remains in him.
reading: 'God is love' (4:16)
origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)John the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.8
See what we are insisting upon; that the deeds of men are only discerned by the root of charity. … Once for all, then, a short precept is given thee: Love, and do what thou wilt: whether thou hold thy peace, through love hold thy peace; whether thou cry out, through love cry out; whether thou correct, through love correct; whether thou spare, through love do thou spare: let the root of love be within, of this root can nothing spring but what is good.
reading: 'Love, and do what you will'
origins:Augustine of Hippo: The formula 'Love, and do what you will' (VII.8)Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)
- attestedpasses through an excluded contribution
Arguments: 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love; Hom. VII.7: one act distinguished by love (1 Jn 4:9; Rom 8:32); Hom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will'
Original foundations
First Epistle of John, 4:16
We know and have believed the love which God has for us. God is love, and he who remains in love remains in God, and God remains in him.
reading: 'God is love' (4:16)
origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)John the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)First Epistle of John, 4:7-12 (cited: 7-8, 10-11)
Beloved, let’s love one another, for love is of God; and everyone who loves has been born of God and knows God. He who doesn’t love doesn’t know God, for God is love. … In this is love, not that we loved God, but that he loved us, and sent his Son as the atoning sacrifice for our sins. Beloved, if God loved us in this way, we also ought to love one another.
reading: Love shown in sending the Son
origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)John the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32)
“He that spared not His own Son, but delivered Him up for us all, how hath He not with Him also freely given us all things?”
reading: Augustine's quotation of Rom 8:32
origins:Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)Augustine of Hippo: Uses of 1 Jn 4, Rom 5:5 and Rom 8:32 in Homily VIIPaul the Apostle: Romans (selected passages)
- attestedpasses through an excluded contribution
Arguments: 2011 address: Augustine's formula applies because God is love; Hom. VII.8: the short precept 'Love, and do what you will'
Original foundations
First Epistle of John, 4:16
We know and have believed the love which God has for us. God is love, and he who remains in love remains in God, and God remains in him.
reading: 'God is love' (4:16)
origins:Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)John the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7
Behold the Father delivered up Christ; Judas delivered Him up; does it not seem as if the thing done were of the same sort? … This: that the Father and the Son did it in love, but Judas did this in treacherous betrayal. Ye see that not what the man does is the thing to be considered; but with what mind and will he does it.
reading: Discernment by intention
origins:Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)Augustine of Hippo: Arguments of Homily VII.6-7
● What remains
No attested foundations remain in the profile.
✎ Stage 2. Search for reconstructions
Search done: no admissible reconstructions were found in the remaining sources.
Attested alternatives of stage 1 are listed under “What remains”.
Why? Justification paths
Loading…
Assumptions that change the result
- Formalization by the dataset editors: the formula is presented as Augustine's, with 'because God is love' added.
- Formalization by the dataset editors; Augustine does not state a syllogism.
- §7 also quotes John 15:13 and Gal 2:20; they are not annotated (coverage gap).
- The precept is presented as a summary ('Once for all, then') of discerning deeds by the root of charity in §§7-8; the context is the commentary on 1 John 4.
? Unresolved dependencies
- Shared roots of the alternative sets: «Author of 1 John (not identified): 1 John 4 (reviewed attribution)», «John the Apostle (traditional attribution): 1 John 4 (traditional attribution)», «Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text)».
Limits
Annotation coverage
- Passages annotated
- 24 / 25
- Relations reviewed
- 5 / 18
- Arguments annotated
- 6 / 8
- Dated
- 11 / 12
- Norms
- no data
Warnings
- Target «Love of neighbour (Lev 19:18)»: synthetic readings «Restrictive contrast reading» take part — an illustrative contrast, not a historical interpretation.
- Target «Admissible readings of Lev 19:18»: synthetic readings «Restrictive contrast reading» take part — an illustrative contrast, not a historical interpretation.
What the intervention affects
Do not accept as foundation: Augustine of Hippo, all contributions, traditional attribution
contributions: 10 · passages: 10 · rules: 2 · relations: 9 · arguments: 3
Augustine of Hippo: Confessions VIII.12.29 (text); Augustine of Hippo: Reading of Rom 13:13-14 (self-report); Augustine of Hippo: On Christian Doctrine I.36 (text); Augustine of Hippo: Enchiridion 121 (text); Augustine of Hippo: Enchiridion 121 quotes 1 Tim 1:5 and Matt 22:40; Augustine of Hippo: The formula 'Love, and do what you will' (VII.8); Augustine of Hippo: Reading rule of the twofold love; Augustine of Hippo: Homily VII on 1 John (text); Augustine of Hippo: Arguments of Homily VII.6-7; Augustine of Hippo: Uses of 1 Jn 4, Rom 5:5 and Rom 8:32 in Homily VII
Confessions, VIII.12.29; Confessions, VIII.12.29 (quotation of Rom 13:13-14); On Christian Doctrine (De doctrina christiana), I.36.40-41; Enchiridion, 121 (§32 in the numbering cited by LG); Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.6; Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.6 (quotation of Rom 5:5); Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7; Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.7 (quotation of Rom 8:32); Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.8; Ten Homilies (Tractates) on the First Epistle of John, Hom. VII.9-11
Engine: versemora-core 0.2.0 · Result hash: c9b124c75e6bc276 · state: 401b3f185e7d1dbb
The graph as an explanation of the selected change
2011 address: use of Augustine's formula
Loading…