A violation of a norm · Official · Law
The Torah's death penalties for religious offences as the law of Judaea
In the name of
- Second Temple Judaism· Judaism
- Pharisees· Judaism
- Sadducees· Judaism
- Essenes and the Qumran community· Judaism
What happened
Details
- Who
- The Jewish community of the Second Temple period: its court (later the Sanhedrin), the high priests and the sects' courts (Sadducees, Essenes)
- When
- c. 458 BCE (Ezra's mission) – 70 CE
- Reach
- Official
- Carried out by
- Law
- Severity
- Killings and executions
- Now
- Ended
- Victims
- Not counted; the sources name few cases: the eighty women of Ashkelon (a tradition), a priest's daughter (a report in the Mishnah), Stephen (by Acts), James and 'some others' (62 CE); by the Gospels, the Sanhedrin condemned Jesus, who was executed by the Romans.
How its law and leaders stood toward it
3458 BCE – 167 BCE · Not applied
The Torah is the community's law, recognised by the Persian crown (Ezra 7:25–26) and then under the Hellenistic kings; every direction holds its death penalties. But no execution under them is recorded for this period (the sources are few): the measures recorded against offenders are confiscation and exclusion from the community (Ezra 10:8) and expulsion (Neh 13:28).
167 BCE – 37 BCE · Prevailing
Applied under the Maccabees and the Hasmoneans: Mattathias killed a Jew who sacrificed at the king's command (1 Macc 2:24), Judas 'searched out the lawless… and burned those who troubled his people' (3:5), Simon 'did away with every lawless and wicked man' (14:14); the Mishnah relates that Simeon ben Shetah hanged eighty women in Ashkelon on one day (Sanhedrin 6:4; under Salome Alexandra, 76–67 BCE; a tradition the Sages treat as an exception). The Sadducees, Josephus says, were 'very rigid in judging offenders, above all the rest of the Jews' (Ant. 20.199).
37 BCE – 70 · Not applied
The law stayed and no direction contested it, but it was applied only extremely rarely: no court execution under the Torah's law is recorded under Herod (37–4 BCE), and from 6 CE the Roman prefect held the power of execution (War 2.117; cf. John 18:31, 'It is not lawful for us to put any man to death'); the Talmud dates the end of capital cases in the Sanhedrin to forty years before the destruction of the Temple (Sanhedrin 41a). By the Gospel account, the Sanhedrin found Jesus 'deserving of death' for blasphemy (Mark 14:64; Matt 26:65–66) and handed him to Pilate; the execution itself was a Roman crucifixion. The historicity and legality of that trial are debated by scholars (the Mishnah's rules in Sanhedrin 4–7 — no capital trial by night or on the eve of a Sabbath or festival, no conviction on the day of the trial, blasphemy only by pronouncing the Name — against the Gospel account). Other recorded cases: Stephen, stoned after a hearing before the council (Acts 6:12–7:60; Paul: 'when they were put to death, I gave my voice against them', Acts 26:10); a priest's daughter burned for adultery (Sanhedrin 7:2; the Talmud calls that court Sadducean, Sanhedrin 52b); James, the brother of Jesus, and others, stoned in 62 by the court the high priest Ananus convened, who was deposed for convening it without the procurator's consent (Ant. 20.200–203).
- Review of a study of the Sanhedrin's jurisdiction (Project MUSE): War 2.117 — Coponius received the power of capital punishment in 6 CE
- John 18:31 (Bible Hub)
- Mark 14:64 (Bible Hub)
- Matthew 26:66 (Bible Hub)
- Wikipedia, 'Sanhedrin trial of Jesus'
- Acts 7:58 (Bible Hub)
- Acts 26:10 (Bible Hub)
- Mishnah Sanhedrin 7:2 with English explanation (Sefaria)
- Wikipedia, 'Hall of Hewn Stones'
- Josephus, Antiquities 20.197–200
- 'Reflections on the Trial and Death of Jesus', Israel Law Review
Prevailing: the direction's law and recognised leaders hold the rule and do not contest it; contested: it is still in the law, but leading authorities have publicly rejected or suspended it; repudiated: officially abandoned.
The texts cited
3Deut 13:6–10KJV
'Thou shalt surely kill him' — of one who entices to serve other gods.
Exod 22:18KJV
'Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live' (22:17 in the Hebrew numbering).
Lev 20:13KJV
Death for male intercourse.
Places its perpetrators cited as grounds; this is not a judgement of the texts themselves.
Contested texts
2Sources
7In red: violence and coercion in a tradition's name (executions, torture, coercion, child marriage, slavery); teaching and disapproval without force are not marked. On a religion's overview line, red means that its own law and recognised leaders hold such a rule without contesting it, in proportion to the share of its followers in those schools and churches; it describes norms and institutions, not every believer.