Ethically contested texts
One standard for every tradition: the Hebrew Bible, the New Testament, the Talmud, the Quran and hadith, later church texts. The summary never goes beyond the text itself.
3 contested texts
Canonical collectionRabbinic Judaism
Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 54b (also 55b; Ketubot 11b)
In discussing the prohibition of male intercourse (Lev 18:22) and its penalty, the baraita says: 'with a male, they did not treat a minor as an adult'. Rav: intercourse with a boy younger than nine is not treated as with a nine-year-old; Shmuel: younger than three. The question is from what age the act makes the adult liable to the Torah's death penalty. In Sanhedrin 55b and Ketubot 11b the legal status of a girl under three years and a day is set in the same way: intercourse with her does not change her status as a virgin ('like a finger in the eye', Ketubot 11b).
ChildrenWomen
Canonical collectionSunni Islam
al-Bukhari no. 5133 (Tawq al-Najat; English USC-MSA vol. 7, book 62, no. 64); also nos. 3894, 3896, 5134, 5158; Muslim no. 1422
'A'isha reports that the Prophet contracted marriage with her when she was six, the marriage was consummated (she was brought in to him) when she was nine, and she stayed with him nine years. In no. 3894 she tells it in detail: she was called from a swing where she was playing with friends, made ready and at nine taken to the Prophet.
ChildrenWomen
Canonical collectionSunni Islam
Muslim no. 1456 ('Abd al-Baqi numbering); Quran 4:24
After Hunayn a detachment sent to Awtas took women captive; some Companions refrained from intercourse with them because they had polytheist husbands, and God revealed: 'and married women [are forbidden to you], except those whom your right hands possess' (4:24), meaning they are lawful once their waiting period ('idda) is over.
WomenSlaveryWar