Skip to content

Contradiction · The historical record

On the Perpetuity of the Primacy of blessed Peter in the Roman Pontiffs.

Whose text

Catholicism· Christianity

What is said

Vatican I (Pastor aeternus, ch. 2): by Christ's institution Peter has 'perpetual successors' in the primacy over the whole church, the bishops of Rome, as 'has always been known'.

Where it is said

What contradicts it

3
  • prFirst Epistle of Clement to the Corinthians (Greek)· c. 96

    1 Clement, salutation

    Rome's letter to Corinth is written in the name of 'the church of God sojourning in Rome', without naming a bishop.

  • 2.4.3Shepherd of Hermas (Greek)· c. 100–150

    The Roman church is led by 'the presbyters who preside over the church': a college, not a single bishop.

  • 4.prIgnatius of Antioch, the seven letters (Greek)· c. 110

    Ignatius, Letter to the Romans

    Ignatius, who insists on the bishop in his other letters, mentions no bishop when writing to Rome.

How the tradition answers

Catholic theology understands succession as the continuity of the Petrine ministry and of the Roman church's special authority, attested already by Irenaeus, who c. 180 gives a list of Roman bishops from Linus (Against Heresies 3.3.3); the Jesuit scholar F. A. Sullivan (2001) accepts a gradual emergence of the single bishop in Rome by the mid-2nd century and holds this compatible with divine institution.

Note

Historians (P. Lampe, 1989; A. Brent) date the single bishop in Rome to the mid-2nd century.
Vatican I (Pastor aeternus, ch. 2): by Christ's institution Peter has 'perpetual… · Versemora