Skip to content

Contradiction · An older source

Quran 28:38

Whose text

Islam· as a whole

What is said

Quran 28:38 (also 28:6, 40:36–37): Pharaoh orders his official Haman to fire clay and build a tower so that he may climb up to the God of Moses.

Where it is said

What contradicts it

2
  • Gen 11:3–4· 9th–6th c. BCE (dating debated)

    A tower of burnt brick 'with its top in heaven' is the story of Babel, not of Egypt.

  • Esth 3:1· 4th–2nd c. BCE

    Haman the Agagite is a minister of the Persian king Ahasuerus/Xerxes (5th c. BCE), many centuries after Moses.

How the tradition answers

Muslim tradition takes Haman to be a different person, a minister or builder of Pharaoh; sharing a name with the figure in Esther does not mean identity. Some modern apologists (M. Bucaille, 1994) pointed to an Egyptian name Hmn in hieroglyphic dictionaries; Egyptological literature does not support that reading as the title of such an official.

Note

The comparison with Esther and the tower of Babel was made in European scholarship already by A. Geiger (1833).
Quran 28:38 (also 28:6, 40:36–37): Pharaoh orders his official Haman to fire clay and… · Versemora