Skip to content

Contradiction · Another tradition

Deut 27:4

Whose text

Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism

What is said

The Masoretic Text of Deut 27:4: the stones with the Law and the altar are to be set up 'in mount Ebal'; rabbinic tradition accuses the Samaritans of falsifying their Torah (Sotah 33b).

Where it is said

Deut 27:4WLC

Deut 27:4 (Masoretic Text)

What contradicts it

2
  • Deut, 27:4Samaritan Pentateuch· 2nd–1st c. BCE (Samaritan recension)

    Deut 27:4 (Samaritan Pentateuch)

    The Samaritan Torah reads 'on Mount Gerizim'.

  • Old Latin (Vetus Latina, Codex Lugdunensis), Deut 27:4 (not in the library)· 2nd–4th c.

    A witness independent of the Samaritans also reads 'Gerizim'; some textual critics (e.g. E. Tov) allow that 'Ebal' may be a later polemical substitution.

How the tradition answers

Jewish tradition holds 'Ebal' to be original: Joshua builds the altar on Ebal (Josh 8:30 in the Masoretic Text); Rabbi Eleazar son of Rabbi Yose tells the Samaritans: 'you have falsified your Torah' (Sotah 33b). Scholars are divided: some regard 'Gerizim' as a Samaritan revision, others as the original reading.

Note

The dispute between Jerusalem and Gerizim is the chief matter dividing Jews and Samaritans (cf. John 4:20).

Photographs

2
The Masoretic Text of Deut 27:4: the stones with the Law and the altar are to be set up… · Versemora