Norms and their violations
In red: violence and coercion in a tradition's name (executions, torture, coercion, child marriage, slavery); teaching and disapproval without force are not marked. On a religion's overview line, red means that its own law and recognised leaders hold such a rule without contesting it, in proportion to the share of its followers in those schools and churches; it describes norms and institutions, not every believer. Red on a religion's overview line means that its own law and recognised leaders hold a rule of violence without contesting it and that it is applied, in proportion to the share of its followers in the schools and churches that hold it: when the whole community accepts it, the band fills the line's full thickness; when a minority does, the band is thinner. Orange: the rule has weakened — it is still in the law but not applied, or only extremely rarely (Not applied), or leading authorities of that direction have publicly rejected or suspended it (Contested); who, when and on what evidence is on the card. After its official repudiation there is no band. A sharp edge marks a break dated by a document or an event (a code, a council, a decree, an official repudiation); a blurred one, a gradual weakening. It describes norms and institutions, not every believer. Each violation is attributed to the actor's own direction and marked with its reach: Official — the tradition's own authoritative bodies, clergy or prevailing law did it or prescribe it; State — a state, or an authority ruling a territory, acting in the tradition's name; Group — a movement, sect or militia acting on its own, condemned or not followed by the tradition's mainstream. What a state did, and single acts of a tradition's bodies, are a thin strip on the religion's line and drawn in full on their own direction's lane; a Group violation appears only on the group's own lane, in the lists and cards. A violation is drawn only on its own direction's lane, never on another.
Norms
- The right to lifeEvery human being has the right to life; no one shall be arbitrarily deprived of it. International law allows the death penalty only for 'the most serious crimes' (the UN Human Rights Committee counts only intentional killing among them) and forbids it for acts that should not be crimes at all: belief, leaving a belief, blasphemy, consensual relations between adults. Destroying a group for its religion is genocide (Convention of 1948).UDHR art. 3; ICCPR art. 6; Genocide Convention (1948); UN Human Rights Committee, General Comment 36 (2018)violations: 6
- No torture or cruel punishmentNo one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. The UN Human Rights Committee reads the ban as covering corporal punishment imposed by sentence as well: flogging, amputation, stoning.UDHR art. 5; ICCPR art. 7; Convention against Torture (1984); HRC General Comment 20 (1992), para. 5violations: 2
- Freedom of thought, conscience and religionEveryone is free to have, adopt and change a religion or belief and to manifest it alone or in community, in public or in private. No one shall be subject to coercion that would impair this freedom. This covers leaving a religion (apostasy), forced conversion, and executions and penalties for heresy or another faith.UDHR art. 18; ICCPR art. 18 (para. 2: no coercion); UN Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief (1981)violations: 7
- Freedom of expressionEveryone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression, including criticism of a religion and its founders. The UN Human Rights Committee holds blasphemy laws incompatible with the Covenant (apart from the ban on incitement to violence and discrimination, art. 20).UDHR art. 19; ICCPR art. 19; HRC General Comment 34 (2011), para. 48violations: 1
- Equality before the lawAll are equal before the law without distinction of race, sex, religion or other status. Laws that place people below others for their faith or sex and are enforced by penalties (legal disabilities of other faiths, compulsory badges or dress, barring women from education) breach this equality.UDHR arts. 1, 2, 7; ICCPR arts. 2, 26; Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1979)violations: 1
- Sexual orientationThe UN Human Rights Committee found that criminalising consensual same-sex relations between adults violates the rights to privacy and equality (Toonen v. Australia, 1994), and that the death penalty for them is incompatible with the right to life. The UDHR does not name it: this is the reading of the UN treaty bodies.UDHR arts. 2, 7, 12; ICCPR arts. 17, 26; UN HRC, Toonen v. Australia (1994); General Comment 36 (2018), para. 36violations: 0
- Free consent to marriageMarriage shall be entered into only with the free and full consent of the intending spouses; men and women of full age have the right to marry without any limitation due to race, nationality or religion. Forced marriage, 'marriage' to a captive, compulsory polygamy are violations.UDHR art. 16; ICCPR art. 23; Convention on Consent to Marriage, Minimum Age for Marriage and Registration of Marriages (1962)violations: 0
- The child; no child marriageA child is a person under 18; the state must protect children from violence, abduction, recruitment into armed groups and removal from their families. The UN treats marriage under 18 as a harmful practice and calls for a minimum marriage age of 18 without exceptions.UDHR art. 25(2); Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989), arts. 9, 19, 35, 38; CEDAW art. 16(2); joint CEDAW General Recommendation 31 / CRC General Comment 18 (2014, rev. 2019)violations: 2
- No slaveryNo one shall be held in slavery or servitude; slavery and the slave trade are prohibited in all their forms, including the enslavement of captives and hereditary slavery.UDHR art. 4; ICCPR art. 8; Slavery Convention (1926); Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery (1956)violations: 1
- No human sacrificeKilling a person as an offering to a deity is murder under every legal order and a breach of the right to life; it is listed apart because the traditions themselves name and condemn it (Lev 18:21; Deut 12:31). Self-sacrifice (as Christians understand Christ's death) and the binding of Isaac (a text, not a practice) are not counted.UDHR art. 3; ICCPR art. 6violations: 0
- Liberty; no arbitrary detention or exileNo one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile; everyone has freedom of movement and residence. This covers the expulsion of whole religious communities, compulsory ghettos, and holding people in religious institutions against their will.UDHR arts. 9, 13; ICCPR arts. 9, 12violations: 2
- Incitement to violence and hatredAny advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence shall be prohibited by law; direct and public incitement to commit genocide is punishable whether or not genocide follows. Only calls by leaders, authorities or official documents of a tradition, movement or state are marked, not private opinions.ICCPR art. 20(2); Genocide Convention art. III(c)violations: 0
Violations
8 violations
CoercionStateState1492Repudiated: The Spanish state: the decree declared void (symbolically, 16 December 1968); Law 12/2015 granting citizenship to descendants of the 'unjustly expelled' Sephardim
The expulsion of the Jews from Spain: baptism or exile
In the name of: Catholicism
The Catholic Monarchs Ferdinand and Isabella (the Alhambra Decree)
Victims: Rabbinic Judaism
The decree of 31 March 1492 ordered all Jews of Castile and Aragon to be baptised or leave the kingdoms by the end of July, leaving their gold and silver behind; the reason given was to keep them from 'subverting' the baptised. The exiles went to Portugal, North Africa, Italy and the Ottoman Empire; those who stayed were baptised and came under the watch of the Inquisition. Navarre expelled its Jews in 1498.
Killings and executionsStateState1497–1506Repudiated: President Mário Soares of Portugal asked forgiveness of the Jewish communities of Portuguese origin (1987); the nationality law for Sephardic descendants (2013/2015)
The forced baptism of the Jews of Portugal (1497) and the Lisbon massacre (1506)
In the name of: Catholicism
King Manuel I; in 1506 a Lisbon crowd incited by Dominican friars
Victims: Rabbinic Judaism
Manuel I was bound by his marriage contract with a Spanish princess to expel the Jews (decree of 5 December 1496); instead, in spring 1497 he ordered Jewish children aged 4–14 taken from their families to be raised as Christians, and in October some 20,000 Jews gathered in Lisbon to sail were baptised by force. On 19–21 April 1506 a crowd in Lisbon, incited by Dominicans, killed 'New Christians'; the king executed two friars and about 50 rioters. In 2008 a memorial to the victims was unveiled on the Largo de São Domingos.
Killings and executionsStateState1501–1888Repudiated: John Paul II at Gorée (22 February 1992); the Southern Baptist Convention (1995); the General Synod of the Church of England (2006); the Jesuits and Georgetown University (2017)
The Atlantic slave trade and slavery with a religious justification
In the name of: Catholicism, Protestantism
The Christian states of Europe and the Americas (Portugal, Spain, Britain, France, the Netherlands, the United States and others), their trading companies, and churches that owned slaves
About 12.5 million people were shipped from Africa to the Americas. The trade was carried on by Christian states; theologians and preachers justified it by the 'curse of Ham/Canaan' (Gen 9:25), the law on slaves 'of the heathen' (Lev 25:44–46) and the words 'servants, be obedient to your masters' (Eph 6:5); the French Code Noir (1685) required slaves to be baptised. Church institutions owned slaves too (the Maryland Jesuits sold 272 people in 1838); the Southern Baptist Convention arose in 1845 from a dispute over slaveholding missionaries. Against slavery stood the Quakers, then the evangelical abolitionists.
Killings and executionsStateState1545–1655Repudiated: Pope Francis in the Waldensian temple of Turin, 22 June 2015: 'unchristian-like and even inhuman attitudes and conduct… In the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, forgive us!'
The massacres of the Waldensians: Mérindol (1545) and the 'Piedmont Easter' (1655)
In the name of: Catholicism
The Parlement of Aix and the French crown (Mérindol, 1545); the Duke of Savoy (Piedmont, 1655)
Victims: Waldensians
In 1545, on a decree of the Parlement of Aix, troops destroyed the Waldensian villages of the Luberon (Mérindol, Cabrières), and 670 men were sent to the galleys; in 1561 the Waldensian communities of Calabria were destroyed; in April 1655 Savoyard troops massacred the valleys of Piedmont (the 'Piedmont Easter'), of which Milton and Cromwell wrote.
Killings and executionsStateState1547–1553Repudiated: Admirers of Calvin — the 'expiatory monument' at Champel (1903), condemning 'an error which was that of his century'
The burning of Michael Servetus in Geneva
In the name of: Reformed Christianity (Calvinism)
The Small Council of Geneva with the participation of John Calvin
Victims: Unitarianism
The physician and theologian Michael Servetus, who rejected the doctrine of the Trinity and infant baptism, was recognised in Geneva, charged on the accusation of Calvin's secretary Nicolas de la Fontaine, prepared with Calvin's participation, and burned at Champel on 27 October 1553. Calvin and the other ministers asked for a 'milder' death — beheading — and in his Defence of the Orthodox Faith (1554) he argued the magistrate's duty to execute heretics, relying on the law of Moses on false prophets (Deut 13). Sebastian Castellio replied: 'To kill a man is not to defend a doctrine, it is to kill a man.' In 1547 Jacques Gruet had been beheaded in Geneva for blasphemy and sedition.
CoercionStateState1555–1870Repudiated: Pope John Paul II at the Great Synagogue of Rome (13 April 1986): past discrimination and oppression of Jews were 'objectively gravely deplorable manifestations'
The Roman Ghetto, compulsory sermons and the Mortara case
In the name of: Catholicism
The popes as rulers of the Papal States (Paul IV and his successors; Pius IX)
Victims: Judaism
Paul IV's bull Cum nimis absurdum (July 1555) shut the Jews of Rome and other cities of the Papal States in ghettos, required yellow hats and kerchiefs, left one synagogue per city and banned them from owning land. At Ancona in 1556 about 25 Portuguese conversos were burned. From the 1570s–1580s Jews were herded to compulsory sermons (abolished in 1848). In June 1858, on the order of the inquisitor of Bologna, six-year-old Edgardo Mortara, secretly baptised by a servant, was taken from his family; Pius IX refused to return the child. The ghetto disappeared with the fall of the Papal States (1870).
Killings and executionsStateState1572Repudiated: Pope John Paul II in Paris, 23 August 1997 (regret, not a formal apology): 'Christians did things which the Gospel condemns'
The St Bartholomew's Day massacre
In the name of: Catholicism
The French court (Charles IX, Catherine de' Medici, the Guises), the Paris militia and Catholic crowds
Victims: Reformed Christianity (Calvinism)
In the night before 24 August 1572, on the court's decision, the Huguenot leaders gathered in Paris for Henry of Navarre's wedding were killed; then Catholic crowds killed the Protestants of Paris for several days, and the massacre spread to the provinces. Pope Gregory XIII had a Te Deum sung in thanksgiving and struck a commemorative medal.
Killings and executionsStateState1667 – early 18th c.Repudiated: The Patriarchal Synod under Metropolitan Sergius (1929) and the Local Council of the Russian Orthodox Church (1971): the oaths of 1656 and 1667 annulled 'as if they had never been' (without an apology for the persecution)
The persecution of the Old Believers
In the name of: Russian Orthodox Church
The Russian state (Tsar Alexis, Regent Sophia) on the decrees of the Great Moscow Council and with the hierarchy's support
Victims: Old Believers
The Great Moscow Council (1666–1667) anathematised those who kept the old rites. The Solovetsky Monastery, which refused the new books, was besieged by streltsy for eight years (1668–1676); after its fall many of the defenders were executed. Archpriest Avvakum and three fellow prisoners were burned in a log house at Pustozersk (1682). Regent Sophia's 'Twelve Articles' (1685), issued at Patriarch Joachim's urging, ordered obstinate schismatics who did not recant under torture to be burned, rebaptisers executed, and those who sheltered them knouted. Fleeing persecution, many Old Believers burned themselves.