Influence · Concept
The Rabbanite answer to the Karaites: the defence of the Oral Torah
10th–12th c.Documented
From
Karaite Judaism· Judaism
Into
Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism
What was taken and how it appears
The Karaite challenge made Rabbanite authors argue systematically for the Oral Torah and study the plain sense and grammar of Scripture more closely. Saadia Gaon (d. 942) wrote against Anan and the Karaites; Maimonides in his code rules on those who deny the Oral Torah and, separately, on those brought up among the Karaites.
Evidence
2Rebels, 3Mishneh Torah
Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Rebels 3:3
The children of those who went astray, born “among the Karaites” and raised by them, are “like a child taken captive”: they are to be drawn back with words of peace.
Saadia Gaon, Refutation of Anan (c. 905; in fragments); Book of Beliefs and Opinions IIInot in the library
Arguments that tradition is needed for the commandments to be kept.
How firmly established
Documented
What scholars say
R. Brody, The Geonim of Babylonia (1998); M. Polliack (ed.), Karaite Judaism: A Guide to its History and Literary Sources (2003).