Claim · Corrupted text
The Anglican scholars Westcott and Hort (1881), dabblers in spiritism, based the new translations on corrupt Alexandrian manuscripts and…
Who claims
Protestant fundamentalism· Christianity
About
Anglicanism· Christianity
Claim
Where it is claimed
2P. S. Ruckman, The Christian's Handbook of Manuscript Evidence (1970); G. A. Riplinger, New Age Bible Versions (1993)not in the library
John 1:18Westcott-Hort
Westcott–Hort Greek New Testament (1881)
What the sources show
The readings on which Westcott–Hort and modern editions rest are attested by 2nd–3rd-century papyri discovered after 1881; the shorter texts were not “removed” but are absent from the oldest manuscripts. The Textus Receptus rests on a few late manuscripts and contains late insertions (1 John 5:7). The scholars' part in the “Ghostly Guild” is a fact but has no bearing on the readings.
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
4Manuscripts
John, 1:18𝔓75 (NT.VMR)
Papyrus P75 (c. 200–225), John 1:18
Found in the 1950s, a papyrus a century and a half older than Codex Vaticanus agrees with it in most readings: the “Alexandrian” text existed by about 200, not invented in the 19th century.
Text
1 John 5:7KJV
1 John 5:7 in the King James Bible and in the SBL Greek text
The Johannine Comma on the three in heaven stands in the KJV but appears in Greek only in a few late manuscripts (14th–16th c.); Erasmus put it into his 3rd edition (1522).
Text
John 1:18SBLGNT
John 1:18 (Greek, SBL)
Early manuscripts read “the only-begotten God”, late ones “the only-begotten Son”: here the “Alexandrian” text speaks more strongly of Christ's deity than the Textus Receptus.
Scholarship
A. Westcott, Life and Letters of B. F. Westcott (1903): the “Ghostly Guild” (Cambridge, 1851)not in the library
The student society collecting ghost stories in which Westcott and Hort took part did exist; it has no bearing on their text-critical method.