Skip to content

Claim · Doctrine

The Mishnah and Talmud are human additions to the Torah, which the Torah itself forbids (Deut 4:2).

Verdict: A matter of interpretation10th–12th c.

Who claims

Karaite Judaism· Judaism

About

Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism

Where it is claimed

2
  • Salmon ben Yeruham, Book of the Wars of the Lord (c. 950)not in the library

  • Judah Hadassi, Eshkol ha-Kofer (1148)not in the library

What the sources show

Verdict: A matter of interpretation

That the Mishnah and Talmud contain ordinances not found in Scripture and record the disputes of the sages is stated by these texts themselves. Whether this is the forbidden “adding” (Deut 4:2) or the interpretation that Scripture itself authorises (Deut 17:8–11) is a question of how the Torah is to be read.

The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.

Evidence

3
  • Text

    Deut 4:2WLC

    Deuteronomy 4:2

    “You shall not add to the word which I command you, nor take from it” — the Karaites' chief argument.

  • Text

    Deut 17:11WLC

    Deuteronomy 17:11

    “According to the law which they shall teach you… you shall do” — the Rabbanites' argument for the authority of the sages.

  • Internal evidence

    Avot, 1Mishnah (Kulp)

    Mishnah, Avot 1:1

    “Make a fence around the Torah” — the Mishnah itself speaks of additional, protective ordinances.

The Mishnah and Talmud are human additions to the Torah, which the Torah itself forbids… · Versemora