Claim · Origin
The Samaritans are not Israelites but descendants of foreigners resettled by Assyria (the “Kutim”).
Who claims
Rabbinic Judaism· Judaism
About
The Samaritan community· Samaritanism
Claim
Where it is claimed
32 Kgs 17:24WLC
2 Kings 17:24–41
Josephus, Jewish Antiquities IX.288–291 (c. 93)not in the library
Kiddushin, 8Bavli (Vilna)
Babylonian Talmud, Kiddushin 75b
What the sources show
The Assyrian resettlements are a historical fact, and the population of Samaria did mix. But archaeology, epigraphy and genetics indicate that the Samaritans descend mainly from northern Israelites; the claim of a purely foreign origin does not match the sources. (The Samaritans themselves trace their descent from Ephraim, Manasseh and Levi.)
The verdict rests on the sources: manuscripts, texts, archaeology and scholarship. Claims of faith that no source can settle are marked “unverifiable”.
Evidence
5Internal evidence
Kiddushin, 8Bavli (Vilna)
Babylonian Talmud, Kiddushin 75b
The rabbis themselves disagreed: R. Ishmael — the Kutim “converted out of fear of the lions” (2 Kgs 17:25); R. Akiva — they are “true proselytes”.
Archaeology
Annals of Sargon II (Nimrud Prism)not in the library
Assyrian inscriptions confirm the deportation of part of the Israelites and the settlement of other peoples in Samaria.
Archaeology
Excavations on Mount Gerizim (Y. Magen, 1982–2006)not in the library
A 5th c. BCE sanctuary; the community's inscriptions are in Hebrew and Aramaic with Israelite names.
Scholarship
P. Shen et al., Human Mutation 24 (2004)not in the library
The Samaritans' paternal lineages are close to Jewish (Israelite) ones — against a purely foreign origin.
Scholarship
G. Knoppers, Jews and Samaritans (2013)not in the library
The Samaritans descend largely from the northern Israelite population; the break with the Jews formed gradually (by the 2nd c. BCE).