History models
History models
Explicit causal models. Outcomes are conditional and compared, not merged into one story.
Dataset presets
Custom intervention
What the models contain — before the run
Without Augustine — M1: no compensation M1 — no compensation · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example
Assumptions
- Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
- The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
- The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
- LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
- Only observed mechanisms are allowed.
Variables (9)
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available
text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written
text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history)
decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council
A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI
Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
text available · 407–2011 · observed · la
Mechanisms (4)
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
Exogenous preconditions
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
Without Augustine — M2a: documented channels (LG 42 exogenous) M2 — documented alternative channels · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example
Assumptions
- Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
- The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
- The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
- LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
- Adds the route through LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16, whose availability is documented by S06.
Variables (9)
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available
text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written
text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history)
decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council
A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI
Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
text available · 407–2011 · observed · la
Mechanisms (5)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
assumption: Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
Exogenous preconditions
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled M2 — documented alternative channels · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example
Assumptions
- Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
- The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
- The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
- Coarse simplification: LG 42 as a whole requires at least one source of note 12*. The independence of Thomas and Pius XII from Augustine is unknown, so without Augustine the form of LG 42 is undetermined (IG-23).
Variables (12)
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available
text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written
text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V
decision · 1964 · observed · Second Vatican Council
Augustine writes the Enchiridion (ch. 121)
text written · c. 420–422 · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled)
decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council
A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI
Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine
text available · 1265–1950 (approximate dates; not checked) · observed · availability unknown
Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
text available · 407–2011 · observed · la
Mechanisms (7)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
assumption: Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.
LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) ← The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V + Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine
documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
assumption: The same note names Thomas and Pius XII; their independence from Augustine is not established.
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) ← The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V + Augustine writes the Enchiridion (ch. 121)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
assumption: Note 12* of LG 42 cites Enchiridion 121, 32.
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
Exogenous preconditions
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V; Augustine writes the Enchiridion (ch. 121); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
Without Augustine — M3: hypothetical replacement formula M3 — hypothetical replacement · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example
Assumptions
- Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
- The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
- The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
- LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
- Allows a hypothetical replacement of the formula by an unnamed later author; results are marked hypothetical.
- A mechanism using a post-2011 source is included only to check that dates reject it.
Variables (11)
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available
text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full
formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI
The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written
text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
Test placeholder: a restatement dated after 2011
formulation · 2012–2020 (later than the address; must be rejected) · not observed
LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history)
decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council
A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI
Hypothesis: an unnamed later author coins an equivalent formula that reaches the speaker
formulation · 431–2010 (hypothetical period) · not observed
Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
text available · 407–2011 · observed · la
Mechanisms (7)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
assumption: Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Hypothesis: an unnamed later author coins an equivalent formula that reaches the speaker
hypothetical · source: no source
assumption: Pure hypothesis: no such author or text is identified; the model does not invent a person.
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← Test placeholder: a restatement dated after 2011 + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
hypothetical · source: no source
assumption: Temporal-discipline check (IG-22): a source dated after 2011 cannot compensate in 2011.
The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.
The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place
observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)
Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)
Hypothetical mechanisms are model assumptions, not observations.
Exogenous preconditions
The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; Test placeholder: a restatement dated after 2011; LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Hypothesis: an unnamed later author coins an equivalent formula that reaches the speaker; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8
Observed history does not change; only the scenario branch does.
Model outcomes are a conditional scenario branch; observed documents and records are not changed. Counts of considered models are shown, not probabilities.
Printable report- Models:
- Without Augustine — M1: no compensation; Without Augustine — M2a: documented channels (LG 42 exogenous); Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled; Without Augustine — M3: hypothetical replacement formula
- Horizon:
- 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address)
- Availability:
- Enforce dates (a later text cannot compensate an earlier event)
- Compensation:
- hypothetical replacement
- Event (variables):
- none — only the variables of the selected contributions change
| Target | M1Without Augustine — M1: no compensation | M2Without Augustine — M2a: documented channels (LG 42 exogenous) | M2Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled | M3Without Augustine — M3: hypothetical replacement formula | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scenario: the formula in the 2011 address | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | derived | Model-dependentderived in 1 of 4 considered models |
| Scenario: 'guided by love, guided by God' in 2011 | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | derived | undeterminedwithout intervention: derived | derived | Model-dependentderived in 2 of 4 considered models |
| Scenario: holiness as charity in 2011 | derived | derived | undeterminedwithout intervention: derived | derived | Model-dependentderived in 3 of 4 considered models |
| Scenario: LG 42 promulgated in its form (1964) | derived | derived | undeterminedwithout intervention: derived | derived | Model-dependentderived in 3 of 4 considered models |
| Scenario: Homily VII is preached | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | not derivedwithout intervention: derived | Not derived in any considered modelderived in 0 of 4 considered models |
Scenario: the formula in the 2011 address
The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 1 of 4 considered models (not derived: 3, undetermined: 0); this is not a probability of alternative history. In some models the result rests on hypothetical assumptions; it is a hypothesis, not a historical finding.
Scenario: 'guided by love, guided by God' in 2011
The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 2 of 4 considered models (not derived: 1, undetermined: 1); this is not a probability of alternative history.
Scenario: holiness as charity in 2011
The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 3 of 4 considered models (not derived: 0, undetermined: 1); this is not a probability of alternative history.
Scenario: LG 42 promulgated in its form (1964)
The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 3 of 4 considered models (not derived: 0, undetermined: 1); this is not a probability of alternative history.
Scenario: Homily VII is preached
The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 0 of 4 considered models (not derived: 4, undetermined: 0); this is not a probability of alternative history.
Historical scenario
- Common to all considered models
- Scenario: Homily VII is preachedderived in 0 of 4 considered models
- Differs between models
- Scenario: the formula in the 2011 addressderived in 1 of 4 considered models
- Scenario: 'guided by love, guided by God' in 2011derived in 2 of 4 considered models
- Scenario: holiness as charity in 2011derived in 3 of 4 considered models
- Scenario: LG 42 promulgated in its form (1964)derived in 3 of 4 considered models
- Undetermined for lack of a mechanism
—
- Depends on an assumption
Show assumptions (12)
- Pure hypothesis: no such author or text is identified; the model does not invent a person.
- Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
- The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
- The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
- LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
- Only observed mechanisms are allowed.
- Adds the route through LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16, whose availability is documented by S06.
- Coarse simplification: LG 42 as a whole requires at least one source of note 12*. The independence of Thomas and Pius XII from Augustine is unknown, so without Augustine the form of LG 42 is undetermined (IG-23).
- Allows a hypothetical replacement of the formula by an unnamed later author; results are marked hypothetical.
- A mechanism using a post-2011 source is included only to check that dates reject it.
- Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.
- Model "Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled": the outcome depends on an assumption about source availability — the availability of "Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine" is unknown.
- Model enumeration incomplete
- no
Models considered: 4. These are not all possible histories. The share of models is not a probability of a real alternative history.
Targets outside the history model
- 2011 address: use of Augustine's formulaAll annotated justifications in the selected profile are disabled. This does not establish that the claim is false. Only the broader claim remains; the refinement is no longer justified.