Skip to content

History models

History models

Explicit causal models. Outcomes are conditional and compared, not merged into one story.

Dataset presets

Custom intervention

What changes in history
Models
Model event (optional)

Checked variables of the chosen models are set false in the scenario branch (intervene_variable_ids).

Horizon

Prefilled with the union of the chosen models' horizons; editable.

What the models contain — before the run

Without Augustine — M1: no compensation M1 — no compensation · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example

Assumptions

  • Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
  • The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
  • LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
  • Only observed mechanisms are allowed.

Variables (9)

  • The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available

    text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written

    text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history)

    decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council

  • A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI

  • Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    text available · 407–2011 · observed · la

Mechanisms (4)

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

    assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

Exogenous preconditions

The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

Without Augustine — M2a: documented channels (LG 42 exogenous) M2 — documented alternative channels · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example

Assumptions

  • Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
  • The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
  • LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
  • Adds the route through LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16, whose availability is documented by S06.

Variables (9)

  • The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available

    text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written

    text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history)

    decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council

  • A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI

  • Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    text available · 407–2011 · observed · la

Mechanisms (5)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

    assumption: Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

    assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

Exogenous preconditions

The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled M2 — documented alternative channels · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example

Assumptions

  • Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
  • The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
  • Coarse simplification: LG 42 as a whole requires at least one source of note 12*. The independence of Thomas and Pius XII from Augustine is unknown, so without Augustine the form of LG 42 is undetermined (IG-23).

Variables (12)

  • The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available

    text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written

    text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V

    decision · 1964 · observed · Second Vatican Council

  • Augustine writes the Enchiridion (ch. 121)

    text written · c. 420–422 · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled)

    decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council

  • A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI

  • Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine

    text available · 1265–1950 (approximate dates; not checked) · observed · availability unknown

  • Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    text available · 407–2011 · observed · la

Mechanisms (7)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

    assumption: Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.

  • LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) ← The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V + Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine

    documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

    assumption: The same note names Thomas and Pius XII; their independence from Augustine is not established.

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

    assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

  • LG 42 promulgated (dependence on note 12* modelled) ← The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V + Augustine writes the Enchiridion (ch. 121)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

    assumption: Note 12* of LG 42 cites Enchiridion 121, 32.

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

Exogenous preconditions

The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; The Council drafts and approves LG chapter V; Augustine writes the Enchiridion (ch. 121); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

Without Augustine — M3: hypothetical replacement formula M3 — hypothetical replacement · 354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address) synthetic example

Assumptions

  • Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
  • The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
  • LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
  • Allows a hypothetical replacement of the formula by an unnamed later author; results are marked hypothetical.
  • A mechanism using a post-2011 source is included only to check that dates reject it.

Variables (11)

  • The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available

    text available · 95–2011 (from estimated composition to 2011) · observed · grc

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will'

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula)

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full

    formulation · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · Benedict XVI

  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written

    text written · 397–400 (REF-W8) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • Test placeholder: a restatement dated after 2011

    formulation · 2012–2020 (later than the address; must be rejected) · not observed

  • LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history)

    decision · 1964 (21 November 1964) · observed · la · Second Vatican Council

  • A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    external condition · 2011 (13 April 2011) · observed · it · Benedict XVI

  • Hypothesis: an unnamed later author coins an equivalent formula that reaches the speaker

    formulation · 431–2010 (hypothetical period) · not observed

  • Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    text written · c. 407 (c. 407 (REF-W9)) · observed · la · Augustine of Hippo

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    text available · 407–2011 · observed · la

Mechanisms (7)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    documented alternative · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

    assumption: Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Hypothesis: an unnamed later author coins an equivalent formula that reaches the speaker

    hypothetical · source: no source

    assumption: Pure hypothesis: no such author or text is identified; the model does not invent a person.

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← Test placeholder: a restatement dated after 2011 + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    hypothetical · source: no source

    assumption: Temporal-discipline check (IG-22): a source dated after 2011 cannot compensate in 2011.

  • The 2011 address uses the formula 'Love and do what you will' ← A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

  • The 2011 address states that those guided by love are guided by God, because God is love (without the formula) ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place + Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35)

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

    assumption: In the address this statement follows and explains the Augustine quotation.

  • The 2011 address presents holiness as charity lived to the full ← The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available + LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history) + A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place

    observed · source: Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness); Vatican.va: Second Vatican Council, Lumen gentium (21 November 1964)

  • Homily VII is available to the 2011 speaker (the address cites PL 35) ← Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

    observed · source: CCEL: NPNF1-07, Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John, Homily VII (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers; ed. Ph. Schaff, 1888); Vatican.va: Benedict XVI, General Audience, 13 April 2011 (Holiness)

Hypothetical mechanisms are model assumptions, not observations.

Exogenous preconditions

The text of 1 John 4 (incl. 4:16) is available; The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is written; Test placeholder: a restatement dated after 2011; LG 42 promulgated (as given in observed history); A general-audience catechesis on holiness takes place; Hypothesis: an unnamed later author coins an equivalent formula that reaches the speaker; Augustine preaches Homily VII on 1 John with the formula in §8

Targets

Observed history does not change; only the scenario branch does.

Model outcomes are a conditional scenario branch; observed documents and records are not changed. Counts of considered models are shown, not probabilities.

Printable report
Historical run parameters
Models:
Without Augustine — M1: no compensation; Without Augustine — M2a: documented channels (LG 42 exogenous); Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled; Without Augustine — M3: hypothetical replacement formula
Horizon:
354–2011 (from Augustine's birth to the 2011 address)
Availability:
Enforce dates (a later text cannot compensate an earlier event)
Compensation:
hypothetical replacement
Event (variables):
none — only the variables of the selected contributions change
Result per model after the intervention; below it, when different, the outcome in the branch without the intervention.
TargetM1Without Augustine — M1: no compensationM2Without Augustine — M2a: documented channels (LG 42 exogenous)M2Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelledM3Without Augustine — M3: hypothetical replacement formulaSummary
Scenario: the formula in the 2011 addressnot derivedwithout intervention: derivednot derivedwithout intervention: derivednot derivedwithout intervention: derivedderivedModel-dependentderived in 1 of 4 considered models
Scenario: 'guided by love, guided by God' in 2011not derivedwithout intervention: derivedderivedundeterminedwithout intervention: derivedderivedModel-dependentderived in 2 of 4 considered models
Scenario: holiness as charity in 2011derivedderivedundeterminedwithout intervention: derivedderivedModel-dependentderived in 3 of 4 considered models
Scenario: LG 42 promulgated in its form (1964)derivedderivedundeterminedwithout intervention: derivedderivedModel-dependentderived in 3 of 4 considered models
Scenario: Homily VII is preachednot derivedwithout intervention: derivednot derivedwithout intervention: derivednot derivedwithout intervention: derivednot derivedwithout intervention: derivedNot derived in any considered modelderived in 0 of 4 considered models
  • Scenario: the formula in the 2011 address

    The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 1 of 4 considered models (not derived: 3, undetermined: 0); this is not a probability of alternative history. In some models the result rests on hypothetical assumptions; it is a hypothesis, not a historical finding.

  • Scenario: 'guided by love, guided by God' in 2011

    The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 2 of 4 considered models (not derived: 1, undetermined: 1); this is not a probability of alternative history.

  • Scenario: holiness as charity in 2011

    The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 3 of 4 considered models (not derived: 0, undetermined: 1); this is not a probability of alternative history.

  • Scenario: LG 42 promulgated in its form (1964)

    The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 3 of 4 considered models (not derived: 0, undetermined: 1); this is not a probability of alternative history.

  • Scenario: Homily VII is preached

    The target is a historical-model event: the justification layer does not apply; see the historical status. The target is derived in 0 of 4 considered models (not derived: 4, undetermined: 0); this is not a probability of alternative history.

Historical scenario

Common to all considered models
  • Scenario: Homily VII is preachedderived in 0 of 4 considered models
Differs between models
  • Scenario: the formula in the 2011 addressderived in 1 of 4 considered models
  • Scenario: 'guided by love, guided by God' in 2011derived in 2 of 4 considered models
  • Scenario: holiness as charity in 2011derived in 3 of 4 considered models
  • Scenario: LG 42 promulgated in its form (1964)derived in 3 of 4 considered models
Undetermined for lack of a mechanism

—

Depends on an assumption
Show assumptions (12)
  • Pure hypothesis: no such author or text is identified; the model does not invent a person.
  • Synthetic hypothetical model for Mode F; not a historical claim. Observed documents are never removed (IG-20).
  • The self-report of Confessions VIII.12.29 is a variable with no outgoing mechanisms: it is not made a necessary cause of later history (IG-18).
  • The number of models in which a target holds is not a probability (IG-26).
  • LG 42 is taken as exogenous. Its note 12* cites Augustine's Enchiridion; that dependence is not modelled here, so results relying on LG 42 depend on this assumption.
  • Only observed mechanisms are allowed.
  • Adds the route through LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16, whose availability is documented by S06.
  • Coarse simplification: LG 42 as a whole requires at least one source of note 12*. The independence of Thomas and Pius XII from Augustine is unknown, so without Augustine the form of LG 42 is undetermined (IG-23).
  • Allows a hypothetical replacement of the formula by an unnamed later author; results are marked hypothetical.
  • A mechanism using a post-2011 source is included only to check that dates reject it.
  • Availability of LG 42 and 1 Jn 4:16 to the speaker is documented by the same address; that they would have led to the same sentence without Augustine is an assumption of the model.
  • Model "Without Augustine — M2b: documented channels, LG 42 note 12* modelled": the outcome depends on an assumption about source availability — the availability of "Other sources of note 12* (Thomas, ST II-II q.184 a.1; Pius XII, 1950) as a route independent of Augustine" is unknown.
Model enumeration incomplete
no

Models considered: 4. These are not all possible histories. The share of models is not a probability of a real alternative history.

Targets outside the history model

  • 2011 address: use of Augustine's formulaAll annotated justifications in the selected profile are disabled. This does not establish that the claim is false. Only the broader claim remains; the refinement is no longer justified.