Skip to content

Explore

Without a link: what is left of the doctrine

Remove any link — a verse, chapter, book, group of books, person, school or work — and see across the whole corpus which positions of documents (confessions, catechisms, charters, rulings) keep printed links to their sources and which lose all of them. No target to choose: everything affected is computed, and the most affected comes first.

List several links separated by «;». Cyrillic references are read in Synodal numbering (Пс 22 = KJV Ps 23), Latin ones in KJV; what exactly is selected is shown below before anything is computed.

Examples (optional)

Traditions

Attribution of books

Options

Documents (optional) — all documents

By default every document of the corpus, one edition of each document (repeated editions are not independent). Tick documents to narrow the run.

Christianity

  • Anabaptist (Swiss Brethren)

  • Ancient councils (no denomination)

  • Ancient creeds (shared, no denomination)

  • Anglican (Church of England)

  • Anglican (Episcopal Church, USA)

  • Anglican (Oxford Movement)

  • Baptist

  • Baptist (Southern)

  • Congregationalist

  • Eastern Orthodox

  • Eastern Orthodox (Russian)

  • English Presbyterian (Nonconformist)

  • Evangelical (interdenominational)

  • Church Fathers

  • Apostolic Fathers

  • Jansenist (Roman Catholic)

  • Liberal Protestant

  • Lutheran

  • Mennonite (Anabaptist)

  • Methodist (Methodist Episcopal Church)

  • Methodist (Wesleyan holiness)

  • Old Catholic (Union of Utrecht)

  • Orthodox Church of Ukraine

  • Particular Baptist

  • Presbyterian (USA)

  • Quaker (Religious Society of Friends)

  • Reformed (Church of Scotland)

  • Reformed (Continental)

  • Reformed (French)

  • Reformed (Presbyterian)

  • Reformed (Swiss)

  • Reformed (Upper German)

  • Restoration Movement (Stone-Campbell)

  • Roman Catholic

  • Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate)

  • Scottish Secession (Presbyterian)

  • Seventh-day Adventist

  • Southern Baptist Convention

  • Waldensian

Islam

  • Islamic literature

  • Sunni

Judaism

  • Philosophy

  • Rabbinic literature

  • scriptures

  • Reform Judaism

Start from your own phrase → Paste your text — the library finds the places it rests on and shows what is left without them.

What will be removed

Remove: Paul. That is 2336 verses in KJV numbering.

  • personPaul«person:paul»

    • Rom · 433
    • 1 Cor · 437
    • 2 Cor · 257
    • Gal · 149
    • Eph · 155
    • Phil · 104
    • Col · 95
    • 1 Thess · 89
    • 2 Thess · 47
    • 1 Tim · 113
    • 2 Tim · 83
    • Titus · 46
    • Phlm · 25
    • Heb · 303
    • 12 more: not counted in this profile

    Who is covered:Paul

In short

  • Checked 213542 positions in 142 documents; 73924 have printed links to sources — only those can be assessed by this method.
  • Lose all printed links: 2694 of 73924 positions with printed links. Keep some of their links: 2191.
  • By document (each document weighs the same): 43 of 90 documents with printed links are affected; in 40 at least one position loses all links; a document loses 14.2% of such positions on average (median 0%). Of the raw count of 2694, 58.9% fall in two documents: Henry's Scripture Catechism — 822, Fisher's Catechism — 765.
  • Most affected topic: «Salvation, grace and faith» (automatic tag): 946 positions in 34 documents lose all printed links — of 5405 positions on this topic with printed links.
  • On this topic no printed link is left in 3 documents: Confession of Dositheus (Greek), Methodist Articles, Declaration of Utrecht.
  • Documents affected most (share of their own positions with printed links): John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) — 74.8% (386 of 516); Christian Perfection — 46% (17 of 37); Augustine, On Christian Doctrine (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/2) — 45% (36 of 80).
  • Of the document groups the most affected is «Church Fathers»: positions lose all links in 8 of its 8 documents with printed links; 27.5% per document on average (699 of 2271 positions in all).

Total over the chosen documents

2694 of 73924

lose all printed links

0 of 73924

left only through what was removed

0 of 73924

depend on a disputed attribution

2191 of 73924

keep some of their links

69039 of 73924

untouched

139618 of 213542

not assessable (no printed links)

Denominator: 73924 positions with printed links out of 213542 checked.

By document: each document weighs the same

The raw numbers above add up the positions of all documents, and one large catechism (thousands of short questions) can outweigh dozens of short confessions. Here every document weighs the same; the denominator is the documents that print links.

  • 43 of 90 documents with printed links affected
  • at least one position loses all links in 40 of 90
  • a document loses 14.2% of its positions with links on average (median 0%)
  • 58.9% of the raw count falls in: Henry's Scripture Catechism — 822 / 2707; Fisher's Catechism — 765 / 2905

Documents affected most

The share is of the document's own positions with printed links. Documents with fewer than 5 such positions come after the others: one position of one is already 100%.

  1. John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11)

    74.8% (386 of 516)

  2. Christian Perfection

    46% (17 of 37)

  3. Augustine, On Christian Doctrine (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/2)

    45% (36 of 80)

  4. Formula of Concord (English)

    43.8% (21 of 48)

  5. Helvetic Consensus

    41.2% (7 of 17)

  6. Canons of Dort

    40.9% (18 of 44)

  7. Philaret's Longer Catechism

    34.5% (78 of 226)

  8. Second Helvetic Confession

    33.6% (40 of 119)

  9. Council of Trent (English)

    33.3% (19 of 57)

By tradition

GroupDocs losingMean share
ChristianityLose all: 2694 · With links: 1016440 / 4528.5%
IslamLose all: 0 · With links: 107860 / 60%
JudaismLose all: 0 · With links: 529740 / 390%

By denomination and group of documents

GroupLose allThrough removedDisputedSome linksUntouchedWith linksNot assessable
Church Fathers (8)Docs losing: 8 / 8 · Mean share: 27.5%69900534103822711999
Reformed (Presbyterian) (4)Docs losing: 3 / 3 · Mean share: 6.7%290035093472148
Eastern Orthodox (2)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 58.6%26004674146134
Lutheran (3)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 30.7%2400221965224
Reformed (Swiss) (8)Docs losing: 2 / 3 · Mean share: 24.9%47005644147282
Roman Catholic (3)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 22.9%2000212465188
Reformed (Continental) (3)Docs losing: 2 / 3 · Mean share: 15.5%25001512720356
Particular Baptist (2)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 8.4%2400186672771
Methodist (Methodist Episcopal Church) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%10000124
Old Catholic (Union of Utrecht) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%1000017
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) (5)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%100001405
Reformed (Upper German) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 75%30010421
Jansenist (Roman Catholic) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 50%100012835
Methodist (Wesleyan holiness) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 46%170071337473
Eastern Orthodox (Russian) (3)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 34.5%7800221262261493
Quaker (Religious Society of Friends) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 31.3%750062103240947
English Presbyterian (Nonconformist) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 30.4%822001118742707154
Ancient councils (no denomination) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 27.8%50085188
Scottish Secession (Presbyterian) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 26.3%76500451168929051033
Seventh-day Adventist (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 13.3%400323301788
Mennonite (Anabaptist) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 11.4%400238354
Baptist (2)Docs losing: 1 / 2 · Mean share: 9.7%140051259010
Reformed (Church of Scotland) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 4.4%100175233
Presbyterian (USA) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 4.1%700147171710
Southern Baptist Convention (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 4%100222251
Anabaptist (Swiss Brethren) (1)0000009
Ancient creeds (shared, no denomination) (9)00000066
Anglican (Church of England) (1)00000039
Anglican (Episcopal Church, USA) (1)00000038
Anglican (Oxford Movement) (1)000000361
Baptist (Southern) (1)00000020
Islamic literature (11)00002667266737436
Philosophy (28)00009829826265
Rabbinic literature (11)0000519925199282116
scriptures (1)000000209
Apostolic Fathers (9)0000001940
Liberal Protestant (1)000011346
Orthodox Church of Ukraine (2)000000332
Reform Judaism (1)0000008
Reformed (French) (1)00001141
Restoration Movement (Stone-Campbell) (1)00000080
Sunni (2)00008119811960
Waldensian (1)00000014

By document

DocumentLose allThrough removedDisputedSome linksUntouchedWith linksNot assessable
John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11)Share: 74.8%386007555516263
Christian PerfectionShare: 46%170071337473
Augustine, On Christian Doctrine (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/2)Share: 45%3600162880168
Formula of Concord (English)Share: 43.8%2100151248180
Helvetic ConsensusShare: 41.2%700911710
Canons of DortShare: 40.9%180016104449
Philaret's Longer CatechismShare: 34.5%780022126226385
Second Helvetic ConfessionShare: 33.6%40003643119159
Council of Trent (English)Share: 33.3%1900182057157
Barclay's ApologyShare: 31.3%750062103240947
Henry's Scripture CatechismShare: 30.4%822001118742707154
Council of OrangeShare: 27.8%50085188
Fisher's CatechismShare: 26.3%76500451168929051033
Augustine, Enchiridion on Faith, Hope and Love (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/3)Share: 25.3%190028287547
Augustine, Confessions (tr. J. G. Pilkington, NPNF I/1)Share: 19.8%360043103182271
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7)Share: 19.5%12400146366636486
Puritan CatechismShare: 19.4%140033257210
Augsburg Confession (Latin)Share: 17.7%300771714
Mogila's Confession (English, OCR)Share: 17.2%25004674145109
Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Books I-V (tr. A. Roberts & W. H. Rambaut, ANF 1)Share: 14.5%550092233380365
The Great ControversyShare: 13.3%400323301788
Vatican I (English)Share: 12.5%10034828
Dordrecht ConfessionShare: 11.4%400238354
Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2)Share: 10.7%300093157280385
Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers, NPNF I/7)Share: 10.7%1300416812214
Shorter CatechismShare: 10.4%110050451061
London Baptist Confession 1689Share: 10%1600118261600
Keach's CatechismShare: 6.8%80068411171
Larger CatechismShare: 5.7%1100152311942
Heidelberg CatechismShare: 5.6%700101171254
Scots ConfessionShare: 4.4%100175233
Westminster Confession (1788)Share: 4.1%700147171710
Westminster ConfessionShare: 4.1%700148171720
The Baptist Faith and Message (1925)Share: 4%100222251
Statute of the Russian Orthodox Church (2000)Share: 100%100001350
Confession of Dositheus (Greek)Share: 100%10000125
Methodist ArticlesShare: 100%10000124
Declaration of UtrechtShare: 100%1000017
Tetrapolitan ConfessionShare: 75%30010421
Provincial LettersShare: 50%100012835

+97

By topic across documents

Topics are automatic tags from a word list, not an understanding of meaning. «Loses the topic» — in the document no position of this topic keeps a printed link.

Positions

1251 positions under the chosen filter; the most affected first.

  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7) · 4 · Tractate XVII (Chapter IV. 1–18)

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Titus 2:12–13. It has no other printed links.

    Now let us see what He intended to signify in the case of that one whom He Himself, keeping the mystery of unity, as I said before, deigned to heal out of so many sick folk. He found in the number of this man’s years the… Text of the position

    Now let us see what He intended to signify in the case of that one whom He Himself, keeping the mystery of unity, as I said before, deigned to heal out of so many sick folk. He found in the number of this man’s years the number, so to speak, of infirmity: “He was thirty and eight years in infirmity.” How this number refers more to weakness than to health must be somewhat more carefully expounded. I wish you to be attentive; the Lord will aid us, so that I may fitly speak, and that you may sufficiently hear. The number forty is commended to our attention as one consecrated by a kind of perfection. This, I suppose, is well known to you, beloved. The Holy Scriptures very often testify to the fact. Fasting was consecrated by this number, as you are well aware. For Moses fasted forty days, and Elias as many; and our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ did Himself fulfill this number of fasting. By Moses is signified the law; by Elias, the prophets; by the Lord, the gospel. It was for this reason that these three appeared on that mountain, where He showed Himself to His disciples in the brightness of His countenance and vesture. For He appeared in the middle, between Moses and Elias, as the gospel had witness from the law and the prophets. Whether, therefore, in the law, or in the prophets, or in the gospel, the number forty is commended to our attention in the case of fasting. Now fasting, in its large and general sense, is to abstain from the iniquities and unlawful pleasures of the wo

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) · Rom.3.19 · Homily VII on Rom. iii. 9-18

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Gal 4:21–22. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    This then is why, next to Isaiah, who confessedly aimed at them, he brought in David; that he might show that these things also belonged to the same subject. For what need was there, he means, that a prophet who was sent… Text of the position

    This then is why, next to Isaiah, who confessedly aimed at them, he brought in David; that he might show that these things also belonged to the same subject. For what need was there, he means, that a prophet who was sent for your correction should accuse other people. For neither was the Law given to any else than you. And for what reason did he not say, we know that what things soever the prophet saith, but what things soever the Law saith? It is because Paul uses to call the whole Old Testament the Law. And in another place he says, “Do ye not hear the Law, that Abraham had two sons?” (Gal. iv. 21, 22.) And here he calls the Psalm the Law when he says, “We know that what things soever the Law saith, it saith to them who are under the Law.” Next he shows that neither are these things he said merely for accusation’s sake, but that he may again be paving the way for faith. So close is the relationship of the Old Testament with the New, since even the accusations and reproofs were entirely with a view to this, that the door of faith might open brightly upon them that hear it. For since it was the principal bane of the Jews that they were so conceited with themselves (which thing he mentioned as he went on, “how that being ignorant of the righteousness of God, and going about to establish their own righteousness, they submitted not themselves to the righteousness of God”) (Rom. x. 3), the Law and the Prophet by being beforehand with them cast down their high thoughts, and laid l

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Barclay's Apology · Barclay, § XXII · Proposition X. Concerning the MINISTRY

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: 2 Cor 2:17. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Now, though the grossest of these Abuses be swept away by Protestants; yet the evil Root still remains, and is nourished and upheld; and the Science kept up, as being deemed necessary for a Minister: For, while the pure … Text of the position

    Now, though the grossest of these Abuses be swept away by Protestants; yet the evil Root still remains, and is nourished and upheld; and the Science kept up, as being deemed necessary for a Minister: For, while the pure Learning of the Spirit of Truth is despised and neglected, and made ineffectual, Man’s fallen earthly Wisdom is upheld; and so in that he labours and works with the Scriptures, being out of the Life and Spirit which those that wrote them were in, by which only they are rightly understood, and made Use of. And so he that is to be a Minister, must learn this Art or Trade of Merchandizing with the Scriptures, and be that which the Apostle would not be, to wit, a Trader with them, 2 Cor. ii. 17. That he may acquire a Knack from a Verse of Scripture, by adding his own barren Notions and Conceptions to it, and his uncertain Conjectures, and what he hath stolen out of Books; for which End he must have of Necessity a good many by him, and may each Sabbath-day, as they call it, or oftener, make a Discourse for an Hour long; and this is called the Preaching of the Word: Whereas the Gift, Grace, and Spirit of God, to teach, open, and instruct, and to preach a Word in Season, is neglected, and so Man’s Arts and Parts, and Knowledge, and Wisdom, which is from below, are set up and established in the Temple of God, yea, and above the little Seed; which in Effect is Antichrist, working in the Mystery. And so the Devil may be as good and able a Minister as the best of them; f

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Henry's Scripture Catechism · 18.4c · Q. 18

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 7:21. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. And are there the seeds of sin in our souls? A. Yes: For when I would do good, evil is present with me, Rom. 7:21.

  • Fisher's Catechism · 33.13 · Q. 33

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Rom 6:7, Eph 1:6. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. What are the constituent parts of justification? A. They are two; that in which he pardons all our sins, Rom. 6:7; and that in which he accepts us as righteous in his sight, Eph. 1:6.

  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7) · 9 · Tractate XXII (Chapter V. 24–30)

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Gal 2:20. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    And how hath He? Even as the Father hath. Hear Himself saying, “For as the Father hath life in Himself, so also hath He given to the Son to have life in Himself.” Brethren, I shall speak as I shall be able. For these are… Text of the position

    And how hath He? Even as the Father hath. Hear Himself saying, “For as the Father hath life in Himself, so also hath He given to the Son to have life in Himself.” Brethren, I shall speak as I shall be able. For these are those words that perplex the puny understanding. Why has He added, “in Himself”? It would suffice to say, “For as the Father hath life, so also hath He given to the Son to have life.” He added, “in Himself:” for the Father “hath life in Himself,” and the Son hath life in Himself. He meant us to understand something in that which He saith, “in Himself.” And here a secret matter is shut up in this word; let there be knocking, that there may be an opening. O Lord, what is this that Thou hast said? Wherefore hast Thou added, “in Himself”? For did not Paul the apostle, whom Thou madest to live, have life? He had, said He. As for men that were dead to be made alive, and at Thy word to pass unto life by believing; when they shall have passed, will they not have life in Thee? They shall have life; for I said also a little before, “Whoso heareth my words, and believeth Him that sent me, hath eternal life.” Therefore those that believe in Thee have life; and Thou hast not said, “in themselves.” But when Thou speakest of the Father, “even as the Father hath life in Himself;” again, when Thou speakest of Thyself, Thou saidst, “So also hath He given to the Son to have life in Himself.” Even as He hath, so gave He to have. Where hath He? “In Himself.” Where gave He to have

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) · Rom.3.20 · Homily VII on Rom. iii. 9-18

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 3:20. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Ver. 20. “For by the Law is the knowledge of sin.”

  • Henry's Scripture Catechism · 18.4d · Q. 18

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 3:23. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. And is the stain of sin upon both? A. Yes: For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God, Rom. 3:23.

  • Fisher's Catechism · 33.41 · Q. 33

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Gal 3:13, Eph 5:2. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    • quotationGal 3:13 quotes Deut 21:23 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Deut 21:23 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    Q. What is his passive obedience? A. His satisfaction for sin, by enduring the infinite execution of the curse, upon him in his death, Gal. 3:13, to the full compensation of all the injuries done to the honour of an infi… Text of the position

    Q. What is his passive obedience? A. His satisfaction for sin, by enduring the infinite execution of the curse, upon him in his death, Gal. 3:13, to the full compensation of all the injuries done to the honour of an infinite God, by all the sins of an elect world, Eph. 5:2.

  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7) · 2 · Tractate XXVI (Chapter VI. 41–59)

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 10:10. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    What then did the Lord answer to such murmurers? “Murmur not among yourselves.” As if He said, I know why ye are not hungry, and do not understand nor seek after this bread. “Murmur not among yourselves: no man can come … Text of the position

    What then did the Lord answer to such murmurers? “Murmur not among yourselves.” As if He said, I know why ye are not hungry, and do not understand nor seek after this bread. “Murmur not among yourselves: no man can come unto me, except the Father that sent me draw him.” Noble excellence of grace! No man comes unless drawn. There is whom He draws, and there is whom He draws not; why He draws one and draws not another, do not desire to judge, if thou desirest not to err. Accept it at once and then understand; thou art not yet drawn? Pray that thou mayest be drawn. What do we say here, brethren? If we are “drawn” to Christ, it follows that we believe against our will; so then is force applied, not the will moved. A man can come to Church unwillingly, can approach the altar unwillingly, partake of the sacrament unwillingly: but he cannot believe unless he is willing. If we believed with the body, men might be made to believe against their will. But believing is not a thing done with the body. Hear the apostle: “With the heart man believeth unto righteousness.” And what follows? “And with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.” That confession springs from the root of the heart. Sometimes thou hearest a man confessing, and knowest not whether he believes. But thou oughtest not to call him one confessing, if thou shouldest judge him to be one not believing. For to confess is this, to utter the thing that thou hast in thy heart: if thou hast one thing in thy heart, and another

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) · Rom.4.4 · Homily VIII on Rom. iv. 1, 2

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 4:7. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    • quotationRom 4:7 quotes Ps 32:1–2 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Ps 32:1–2 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    For reflect how great a thing it is to be persuaded and have full confidence that God is able on a sudden not to free a man who has lived in impiety from punishment only, but even to make him just, and to count him worth… Text of the position

    For reflect how great a thing it is to be persuaded and have full confidence that God is able on a sudden not to free a man who has lived in impiety from punishment only, but even to make him just, and to count him worthy of those immortal honors. Do not then suppose that this one is lowered in that it is not reckoned unto the former of grace. For this is the very thing that makes the believer glorious; the fact of his enjoying so great grace, of his displaying so great faith. And note too that the recompense is greater. For to the former a reward is given, to the latter righteousness. Now righteousness is much greater than a reward. For righteousness is a recompense which most fully comprehends several rewards. Therefore after proving this from Abraham, he introduces David also as giving his suffrage in favor of the statement made. What then doth David say? and whom doth he pronounce blessed? is it him that triumphs in works, or him that hath enjoyed grace? him that hath obtained pardon and a gift? And when I speak of blessedness, I mean the chiefest of all good things; for as righteousness is greater than a reward, so is blessedness greater than righteousness. Having then shown that the righteousness is better, not owing to Abraham’s having received it only but also from reasonings (for he hath whereof to boast, he says, before God); he again uses another mode of showing that it is more dignified, by bringing David in to give his suffrage this way. For he also, he says, pro

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Henry's Scripture Catechism · 18.7a · Q. 18

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 8:7. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. Is this corruption of the mind sin? A. Yes: For it is enmity against God, Rom. 8:7.

  • Fisher's Catechism · 35.32 · Q. 35

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Rom 6:4, Rom 6:6. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. In what consists ACTUAL sanctification? A. In being enabled more and more to die unto sin, and live unto righteousness, Rom. 6:4, 6.

  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7) · 5 · Tractate XXX (Chapter VII. 19–24)

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Col 3:1–2. It has no other printed links.

    Perhaps, indeed, that circumcision pointed to the Lord Himself, at whom they were indignant, because He worked cures and healing. For circumcision was commanded to be applied on the eighth day: and what is circumcision b… Text of the position

    Perhaps, indeed, that circumcision pointed to the Lord Himself, at whom they were indignant, because He worked cures and healing. For circumcision was commanded to be applied on the eighth day: and what is circumcision but the spoiling of the flesh? This circumcision, then, signified the removal of carnal lusts from the heart. Therefore not without cause was it given, and ordered to be made in that member; since by that member the creature of mortal kind is procreated. By one man came death, just as by one man the resurrection of the dead; and by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin. Therefore every man is born with a foreskin, because every man is born with the vice of propagation; and God cleanses not, either from the vice with which we are born, or from the vices which we add thereto by ill living, except by the stony knife, the Lord Christ. For Christ was the Rock. Now they used to circumcise with stone knives, and by the name of rock they prefigured Christ; and yet when He was present with them they did not acknowledge Him, but besides, they sought to kill Him. But why on the eighth day, unless because after the seventh day of the week the Lord rose again on the Lord’s day? Therefore Christ’s resurrection, which happened on the third day indeed of His passion, but on the eighth day in the days of the week, that same resurrection it is that doth circumcise us. Hear of those that were circumcised with the real stone, while the apostle admonishes them: “If t

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) · Rom.4.16 · Homily VIII on Rom. iv. 1, 2

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 4:17. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    • quotationRom 4:17 quotes Gen 17:5 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Gen 17:5 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    You see that it is not the Law only that faith establisheth, but the promise of God also that it will not allow to fall to the ground. But the Law, on the other hand, by being kept to unseasonably, makes even the faith o… Text of the position

    You see that it is not the Law only that faith establisheth, but the promise of God also that it will not allow to fall to the ground. But the Law, on the other hand, by being kept to unseasonably, makes even the faith of none effect, and hindereth the promise. By this he shows that faith, so far from being superfluous, is even necessary to that degree, that without it there is no being saved. For the Law worketh wrath, as all have transgressed it. But this doth not even suffer wrath to arise at all: for “where no Law is,” he says, “there is no transgression.” Do you see how he not only does away with sin after it has existed, but does not even allow it to be produced? And this is why he says “by grace.” For what end? Not with a view to their being put to shame, but to the end that the promise might be sure to all the seed. Here he lays down two blessings, both that the things given are sure, and also that they are to all the seed, so gathering in those of the Gentiles, and showing that the Jews are without, if they contend against the faith. For this is a surer thing than that. For faith doeth thee no hurt (be not contentious), but even now thou art in danger from the Law, it preserves thee. Next having said, “to all the seed,” he defines what seed he meaneth. That which is of faith, he says, so blending with it their relationship to the Gentiles, and showing that they must not be proud of Abraham who do not believe as he did. And see a third thing which faith effected besid

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Henry's Scripture Catechism · 19.3c · Q. 19

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Eph 5:6. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. Are we so by reason of sin? A. Yes: For because of these things cometh the wrath of God upon the children of disobedience, Eph. 5:6.

  • Fisher's Catechism · 35.38 · Q. 35

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: 2 Cor 12:7–9, Rom 7:24–25. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. Why is not actual sanctification perfected in this life, but still a remainder of corruption left in God's people? A. To make them know from experience, the strength of sin, the necessity of mortifying grace, and of t… Text of the position

    Q. Why is not actual sanctification perfected in this life, but still a remainder of corruption left in God's people? A. To make them know from experience, the strength of sin, the necessity of mortifying grace, and of the abundance of pardoning grace, 2 Cor. 12:7-9; and to keep them exercised in prayer and humiliation, in the faith and hope of deliverance from a body of sin and death, through Christ, Rom. 7:24, 25.

  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7) · 11 · Tractate XLI (Chapter VIII. 31–36)

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 7:23–25. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    In the measure then spoken of above, he felt himself to be already free, and there fore said, “I delight in the law of God after the inward man.” I delight in the law, I delight in its requirements, I delight in righteou… Text of the position

    In the measure then spoken of above, he felt himself to be already free, and there fore said, “I delight in the law of God after the inward man.” I delight in the law, I delight in its requirements, I delight in righteousness itself. “But I see another law in my members”—this infirmity which remains—“warring against the law of my mind, and bringing me into captivity to the law of sin, which is in my members.” On this side he feels his captivity, where righteousness has not been perfected; for where he delights in the law of God, he is not the captive but the friend of the law; and therefore free, because a friend. What then is to be done with that which so remains? What, but to look to Him who has said, “If the Son shall make you free, then shall ye be free indeed”? Indeed he also who thus spake so looked to Him: “O wretched man that I am,” he says, “who shall deliver me from the body of this death? I thank God, through Jesus Christ our Lord.” Therefore “if the Son shall make you free, ye shall be free indeed.” And then he concluded thus: “So then, with the mind I myself serve the law of God; but with the flesh the law of sin.” I myself, he says; for there are not two of us contrary to each other, coming from different origins; but “with the mind I myself serve the law of God, and with the flesh the law of sin,” so long as languor struggles against salvation.

  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) · Rom.5.2 · Homily IX on Rom. iv. 23

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 5:3. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    If then He hath brought us near to Himself, when we were far off, much more will He keep us now that we are near. And let me beg you to consider how he everywhere sets down these two points; His part, and our part. On Hi… Text of the position

    If then He hath brought us near to Himself, when we were far off, much more will He keep us now that we are near. And let me beg you to consider how he everywhere sets down these two points; His part, and our part. On His part, however, there be things varied and numerous and diverse. For He died for us, and farther reconciled us, and brought us to Himself, and gave us grace unspeakable. But we brought faith only as our contribution. And so he says,” “by faith, unto this grace.” What grace is this? tell me. It is the being counted worthy of the knowledge of God, the being forced from error, the coming to a knowledge of the Truth, the obtaining of all the blessings that come through Baptism. For the end of His bringing us near was that we might receive these gifts. For it was not only that we might have simple remission of sins, that we were reconciled; but that we might receive also countless benefits. Nor did He even pause at these, but promised others, namely, those unutterable blessings that pass understanding alike and language. And this is why he has set them both down also. For by mentioning grace he clearly points at what we have at present received, but by saying, “And we rejoice in hope of the glory of God,” he unveils the whole of things to come. And he had well said, “wherein also we stand.” For this is the nature of God’s grace. It hath no end, it knows no bound, but evermore is on the advance to greater things, which in human things is not the case. Take an insta

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Henry's Scripture Catechism · 19.6c · Q. 19

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 6:23. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. Do we all deserve death? A. Yes: The wages of sin is death, Rom. 6:23.

  • Fisher's Catechism · 37.3 · Q. 37

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: 1 Cor 15:56, Gal 3:10. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    • quotationGal 3:10 quotes Deut 27:26 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Deut 27:26 itself remains; this position does not cite it.

    Q. What is the sting of death? A. The sting of death is sin, 1 Cor. 15:56; and the curse is the inseparable companion of sin, Gal. 3:10.

  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7) · 1 · Tractate XLIV (Chapter IX)

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Eph 2:3. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    We have just read the long lesson of the man born blind, whom the Lord Jesus restored to the light; but were we to attempt handling the whole of it, and considering, according to our ability, each passage in a way propor… Text of the position

    We have just read the long lesson of the man born blind, whom the Lord Jesus restored to the light; but were we to attempt handling the whole of it, and considering, according to our ability, each passage in a way proportionate to its worth, the day would be insufficient. Wherefore I ask and warn your Charity not to require any words of ours on those passages whose meaning is manifest; for it would be too protracted to linger at each. I proceed, therefore, to set forth briefly the mystery of this blind man’s enlightenment. All, certainly, that was done by our Lord Jesus Christ, both works and words, are worthy of our astonishment and admiration: His works, because they are facts; His words, because they are signs. If we reflect, then, on what is signified by the deed here done, that blind man is the human race; for this blindness had place in the first man, through sin, from whom we all draw our origin, not only in respect of death, but also of unrighteousness. For if unbelief is blindness, and faith enlightenment, whom did Christ find a believer at His coming? seeing that the apostle, belonging himself to the family of the prophets, says: “And we also in times past were by nature the children of wrath, even as others.” If “children of wrath,” then children of vengeance, children of punishment, children of hell. For how is it “by nature,” save that through the first man sinning moral evil rooted itself in us as a nature? If evil has so taken root within us, every man is born

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) · p1 · Homily X on Rom. v. 12

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 5:12. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    “Wherefore as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin, and so death passed upon (διἥλθεν6 mss. εἴς…) all men, for that all have sinned.”

  • Henry's Scripture Catechism · 19.6h · Q. 19

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: 1 Cor 15:56. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. Is sin the sting of death? A. Yes: The sting of death is sin, 1 Cor. 15:56.

  • Fisher's Catechism · 46.4 · Q. 46

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Heb 11:6, Rom 14:23. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Q. What influence has obedience to the first, upon obedience to the other precepts of the law? A. As obedience to the First Commandment, is to believe that God is our God, upon the gift of himself to us, in these words, … Text of the position

    Q. What influence has obedience to the first, upon obedience to the other precepts of the law? A. As obedience to the First Commandment, is to believe that God is our God, upon the gift of himself to us, in these words, I am the Lord thy God; so, without believing this it is impossible we can do any thing else that will please him, Heb. 11:6; for "whatsoever is not of faith is sin," Rom. 14:23.

← back251–275 of 1251next →

Documented parallels

  • Six days of creation and 'rest' (Gen 2, Exod 31:17, Heb 4:4, Quran 50:38)

    Gen 2:2–3 · Exod 31:17 · Heb 4:4 · Quran 50:38

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

How the links were obtained

Quotations inside Scripture: Quotations of one Scripture place in another (e.g. Rom 13:9 quotes Lev 19:18) are known for 491 pairs: 355 explicit quotations and 136 allusions — from C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament» (1884, public domain; the book's headings and discussions, checked by shared words) and the recorded parallels.json groups. An explicit quotation of a removed place is not an independent basis; an allusion is shown as a note only. Other links carry no note: that is missing data, not a missing quotation.

How the links were obtained
  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF reference printed in the text (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1106; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 345; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF reference printed in the text (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); no CCEL osisRef, printed 'Acts ii:41' resolved by Versemora (unreviewed)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 31; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 22
  • Christian Perfection: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 53references read in the text: 49; new links added: 53; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, On Christian Doctrine (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/2): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 270; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX Psalm numbering (Ps.10.5); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX Psalm numbering (Ps.16.2); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Isa.61.10); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 4
  • Formula of Concord (English): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Formula of Concord, Epitome, English (Schaff), via Schaff, Creeds III)) — 117; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 97; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Helvetic Consensus: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Helvetic Consensus, tr. Klauber 1990, via Creeds.json)) — 53
  • Canons of Dort: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Canons of Dort, traditional English, via Reformed Standards)) — 100; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 91; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Philaret's Longer Catechism: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the answer (Longer Catechism, Blackmore's English, as printed by Schaff)) — 324; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the answer (Longer Catechism, Blackmore's English, as printed by Schaff); Psalm verse numbers may follow the Prayer-Book Psalter, mapping to KJV unverified) — 9; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 28references read in the text: 337; new links added: 28; reference-like strings not read: 7; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 1
  • Second Helvetic Confession: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Second Helvetic Confession, 20th-century English, via Creeds.json)) — 295
  • Council of Trent (English): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 184; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference given in the editor's footnote (Council of Trent, Waterworth's English, via Schaff, Creeds II); given for a quotation of the decree) — 0; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference given in the editor's footnote (Council of Trent, Waterworth's English, via Schaff, Creeds II); given for a quotation of the decree; Psalm numbering may differ from the KJV (Vulgate/Septuagint/Hebrew verse count), mapping unverified) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Barclay's Apology: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 684references read in the text: 562; new links added: 684; reference-like strings not read: 29; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Henry's Scripture Catechism: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Matthew Henry, Scripture Catechism 1703, via Creeds.json)) — 2729; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 20references read in the text: 2735; new links added: 20; reference-like strings not read: 7; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 5
  • Council of Orange: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Council of Orange, English translation, via Creeds.json)) — 40
  • Fisher's Catechism: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Fisher and Erskine, Shorter Catechism Explained, via Creeds.json)) — 4698; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 4references read in the text: 4506; new links added: 4; reference-like strings not read: 5; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 2
  • Augustine, Enchiridion on Faith, Hope and Love (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/3): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 237; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 1
  • Augustine, Confessions (tr. J. G. Pilkington, NPNF I/1): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 968; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); CCEL osisRef Ps.49 disagrees with the printed 'Ps. cxlix.'; re-read from the print) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in VUL Psalm numbering (Ps.26.12); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in VUL Psalm numbering (Ps.22.2); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 25
  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 130; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1920; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.131.17-Ps.131.18: Ps 131:17 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 132 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.36.8-Ps.36.13: Ps 36:8 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 37 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 23
  • Puritan Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 255; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Puritan Catechism, via Creeds.json)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augsburg Confession (Latin): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Augsburg Confession, Latin text, via Schaff, Creeds III)) — 75; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 61; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Mogila's Confession (English, OCR): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 332; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Orthodox Confession of Mogila, Lodvel's English, via archive.org OCR); reference read from OCR text and not checked) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 54references read in the text: 340; new links added: 54; reference-like strings not read: 57; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 7
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Books I-V (tr. A. Roberts & W. H. Rambaut, ANF 1): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1571; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.15.8: Ps 15:8 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 16 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.49.21: Ps 49:21 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 50 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Jonah.2.11: Hebrew Jonah 2:11 = KJV Jonah 2:10) — 1
  • The Great Controversy: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 55references read in the text: 51; new links added: 55; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Vatican I (English): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 23; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference given in the editor's footnote (Vatican I, Manning's English, via Schaff, Creeds II); given for a quotation of the decree) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Dordrecht Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 178; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Dordrecht Confession 1632, Sohm's translation, via en.wikisource)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1200; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Job.40.14); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 2; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF reference printed in the text (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Prov.10.5); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 1
  • Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers, NPNF I/7): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 10; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 408; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Prov.9.18); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Dan.3.50: Greek Daniel 3:24-90 = KJV Apocrypha 'Song of the Three Children' (PrAzar 1-68)) — 1
  • Shorter Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 447; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Shorter Catechism 1648, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • London Baptist Confession 1689: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 969; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Second London Confession 1677/1689, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Keach's Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 470; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Keach's Catechism, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the answer (Keach's Catechism, via Reformed Standards)) — 8; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 8; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Larger Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 2544; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Larger Catechism 1648, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Heidelberg Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1663; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Heidelberg Catechism, traditional English edition, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 3references read in the text: 5; new links added: 3; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Scots Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 150; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Scots Confession 1560, marginal references, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Westminster Confession (1788): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1788; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Confession, American revision 1788, reconstructed from Schaff's apparatus)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Westminster Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1823; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Confession 1647, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • The Baptist Faith and Message (1925): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 302; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 3; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Statute of the Russian Orthodox Church (2000): References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 1references read in the text: 1; new links added: 1; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Confession of Dositheus (Greek): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Confession of Dositheus, Greek text, via Schaff, Creeds II)) — 0
  • Methodist Articles: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 1references read in the text: 1; new links added: 1; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Declaration of Utrecht: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 4references read in the text: 3; new links added: 4; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Tetrapolitan Confession: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Tetrapolitan Confession, English translation, via Creeds.json)) — 11
  • Provincial Letters: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 3references read in the text: 2; new links added: 3; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Belgic Confession (French): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 799; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Belgic Confession, French text of 1619, via Schaff, Creeds III, marginal references)) — 0; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Belgic Confession, French text of 1619, via Schaff, Creeds III, marginal references); Psalm numbering may differ from the KJV (Vulgate/Septuagint/Hebrew verse count), mapping unverified) — 0
  • New Hampshire Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 483; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (New Hampshire Confession, as printed by Schaff)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • First Confession of Basel: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (First Confession of Basel, marginal references, via Creeds.json)) — 157
  • Bavli (Vilna): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 30204; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:Mishnah label) — 4401; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 14786; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 14432; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 809
  • Mishneh Torah: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 3425; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 10723; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Ein Mishpat Ner Mitzvah) — 28381; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (commentator:Mekorei HaRambam LeRashash) — 108; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 14491
  • Rashi on the Torah: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:structure) — 7816; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 4659
  • Jalalayn (Arabic): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the edition's own sura/ayah heading) — 6230
  • Onkelos: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:structure) — 5846
  • Shulchan Arukh (OC, YD): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 62; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 5324; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Ein Mishpat Ner Mitzvah) — 15784; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed source note) — 1190; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 2
  • Riyad al-Salihin: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (OpenITI @QB@..@QE@ quotation tag; ayah found by matching the quoted words with the Tanzil text) — 71; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the text itself: source formula naming Sahih al-Bukhari) — 931; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the text itself: source formula naming Sahih Muslim) — 1227; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the source formula names this collection; the hadith itself was found in it by matn shingle containment) — 1358; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 995
  • Ibn Kathir (Arabic): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the edition's own sura/ayah heading) — 6171; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the unit text quotes the ayah; the edition has no heading for it) — 55
  • Mekhilta R. Yishmael: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 2554; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 168; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 381
  • Sifrei Devarim: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 871; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 950; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 4466
  • Sifra: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 759; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 2952; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 2421; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 736
  • Bukhari: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the text itself: the edition prints the quotation with its «sura: ayah» reference) — 1043; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the quoted words run over this ayah too (match against the Tanzil text)) — 60
  • Tosefta: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 232; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 956; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 786; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 1249
  • Mishnah (Vilna): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 7089; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 3563; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 422; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 102
  • Sifrei Bamidbar: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 308; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 564; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 253; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 723
  • Philo, Allegorical Interpretation I-III (Greek): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek) — 227; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek; 'ibid.' resolved to the preceding reference) — 18
  • Philo, On Dreams I-II (Greek): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek) — 176; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek; 'ibid.' resolved to the preceding reference) — 24; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek; Septuagint numbering, KJV mapping unverified) — 4

Reproducibility: input hash 37595b01351b5713 · corpus release 628002c692f87c7c