Skip to content

Explore

Without a link: what is left of the doctrine

Remove any link — a verse, chapter, book, group of books, person, school or work — and see across the whole corpus which positions of documents (confessions, catechisms, charters, rulings) keep printed links to their sources and which lose all of them. No target to choose: everything affected is computed, and the most affected comes first.

List several links separated by «;». Cyrillic references are read in Synodal numbering (Пс 22 = KJV Ps 23), Latin ones in KJV; what exactly is selected is shown below before anything is computed.

Examples (optional)

Traditions

Attribution of books

Options

Documents (optional) — all documents

By default every document of the corpus, one edition of each document (repeated editions are not independent). Tick documents to narrow the run.

Christianity

  • Anabaptist (Swiss Brethren)

  • Ancient councils (no denomination)

  • Ancient creeds (shared, no denomination)

  • Anglican (Church of England)

  • Anglican (Episcopal Church, USA)

  • Anglican (Oxford Movement)

  • Baptist

  • Baptist (Southern)

  • Congregationalist

  • Eastern Orthodox

  • Eastern Orthodox (Russian)

  • English Presbyterian (Nonconformist)

  • Evangelical (interdenominational)

  • Church Fathers

  • Apostolic Fathers

  • Jansenist (Roman Catholic)

  • Liberal Protestant

  • Lutheran

  • Mennonite (Anabaptist)

  • Methodist (Methodist Episcopal Church)

  • Methodist (Wesleyan holiness)

  • Old Catholic (Union of Utrecht)

  • Orthodox Church of Ukraine

  • Particular Baptist

  • Presbyterian (USA)

  • Quaker (Religious Society of Friends)

  • Reformed (Church of Scotland)

  • Reformed (Continental)

  • Reformed (French)

  • Reformed (Presbyterian)

  • Reformed (Swiss)

  • Reformed (Upper German)

  • Restoration Movement (Stone-Campbell)

  • Roman Catholic

  • Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate)

  • Scottish Secession (Presbyterian)

  • Seventh-day Adventist

  • Southern Baptist Convention

  • Waldensian

Islam

  • Islamic literature

  • Sunni

Judaism

  • Philosophy

  • Rabbinic literature

  • scriptures

  • Reform Judaism

Start from your own phrase → Paste your text — the library finds the places it rests on and shows what is left without them.

What will be removed

Remove: New Testament. That is 7957 verses in KJV numbering.

  • group of booksNew Testament«group:nt»

    • Matt · 1071
    • Mark · 678
    • Luke · 1151
    • John · 879
    • Acts · 1007
    • Rom · 433
    • 1 Cor · 437
    • 2 Cor · 257
    • Gal · 149
    • Eph · 155
    • Phil · 104
    • Col · 95
    • 1 Thess · 89
    • 2 Thess · 47
    • 1 Tim · 113
    • 2 Tim · 83
    • Titus · 46
    • Phlm · 25
    • +9

In short

  • Checked 213542 positions in 142 documents; 73924 have printed links to sources — only those can be assessed by this method.
  • Lose all printed links: 5753 of 73924 positions with printed links. Keep some of their links: 1862.
  • By document (each document weighs the same): 44 of 90 documents with printed links are affected; in 44 at least one position loses all links; a document loses 29.8% of such positions on average (median 0%). Of the raw count of 5753, 55.3% fall in two documents: Henry's Scripture Catechism — 1592, Fisher's Catechism — 1588.
  • Most affected topic: «Salvation, grace and faith» (automatic tag): 2098 positions in 35 documents lose all printed links — of 5405 positions on this topic with printed links.
  • On this topic no printed link is left in 3 documents: Confession of Dositheus (Greek), Methodist Articles, Declaration of Utrecht.
  • Documents affected most (share of their own positions with printed links): Philaret's Longer Catechism — 87.6% (198 of 226); Canons of Dort — 84.1% (37 of 44); John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11) — 83.7% (432 of 516).
  • Of the document groups the most affected is «Church Fathers»: positions lose all links in 8 of its 8 documents with printed links; 56.6% per document on average (1336 of 2271 positions in all).

Total over the chosen documents

5753 of 73924

lose all printed links

0 of 73924

left only through what was removed

0 of 73924

depend on a disputed attribution

1862 of 73924

keep some of their links

66309 of 73924

untouched

139618 of 213542

not assessable (no printed links)

Denominator: 73924 positions with printed links out of 213542 checked.

By document: each document weighs the same

The raw numbers above add up the positions of all documents, and one large catechism (thousands of short questions) can outweigh dozens of short confessions. Here every document weighs the same; the denominator is the documents that print links.

  • 44 of 90 documents with printed links affected
  • at least one position loses all links in 44 of 90
  • a document loses 29.8% of its positions with links on average (median 0%)
  • 55.3% of the raw count falls in: Henry's Scripture Catechism — 1592 / 2707; Fisher's Catechism — 1588 / 2905

Documents affected most

The share is of the document's own positions with printed links. Documents with fewer than 5 such positions come after the others: one position of one is already 100%.

  1. Philaret's Longer Catechism

    87.6% (198 of 226)

  2. Canons of Dort

    84.1% (37 of 44)

  3. John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11)

    83.7% (432 of 516)

  4. Christian Perfection

    78.4% (29 of 37)

  5. Second Helvetic Confession

    76.5% (91 of 119)

  6. Helvetic Consensus

    76.5% (13 of 17)

  7. Barclay's Apology

    73.3% (176 of 240)

  8. Formula of Concord (English)

    72.9% (35 of 48)

  9. Augsburg Confession (Latin)

    70.6% (12 of 17)

By tradition

GroupDocs losingMean share
ChristianityLose all: 5753 · With links: 1016444 / 4559.5%
IslamLose all: 0 · With links: 107860 / 60%
JudaismLose all: 0 · With links: 529740 / 390%

By denomination and group of documents

GroupLose allThrough removedDisputedSome linksUntouchedWith linksNot assessable
Church Fathers (8)Docs losing: 8 / 8 · Mean share: 56.6%13360057336222711999
Reformed (Swiss) (8)Docs losing: 3 / 3 · Mean share: 72.2%11100297147282
Reformed (Continental) (3)Docs losing: 3 / 3 · Mean share: 43.2%8600112520356
Reformed (Presbyterian) (4)Docs losing: 3 / 3 · Mean share: 34.5%1640026444472148
Eastern Orthodox (2)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 79.7%87004118146134
Lutheran (3)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 71.8%470012665224
Roman Catholic (3)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 65.5%440013865188
Particular Baptist (2)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 39.6%11400138252771
Baptist (2)Docs losing: 2 / 2 · Mean share: 29.9%37004949010
Reformed (Upper German) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%40000421
Liberal Protestant (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%100001346
Methodist (Methodist Episcopal Church) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%10000124
Old Catholic (Union of Utrecht) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%1000017
Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate) (5)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 100%100001405
Eastern Orthodox (Russian) (3)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 87.6%198009192261493
Methodist (Wesleyan holiness) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 78.4%29002637473
Quaker (Religious Society of Friends) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 73.3%176002935240947
Mennonite (Anabaptist) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 62.9%2200121354
Ancient councils (no denomination) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 61.1%110043188
Southern Baptist Convention (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 60%1500100251
English Presbyterian (Nonconformist) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 58.8%159200411112707154
Scottish Secession (Presbyterian) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 54.7%15880044587229051033
Jansenist (Roman Catholic) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 50%100012835
Seventh-day Adventist (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 43.3%1300413301788
Presbyterian (USA) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 38.6%660010051710
Reformed (Church of Scotland) (1)Docs losing: 1 / 1 · Mean share: 34.8%800123233
Anabaptist (Swiss Brethren) (1)0000009
Ancient creeds (shared, no denomination) (9)00000066
Anglican (Church of England) (1)00000039
Anglican (Episcopal Church, USA) (1)00000038
Anglican (Oxford Movement) (1)000000361
Baptist (Southern) (1)00000020
Islamic literature (11)00002667266737436
Philosophy (28)00009829826265
Rabbinic literature (11)0000519925199282116
scriptures (1)000000209
Apostolic Fathers (9)0000001940
Orthodox Church of Ukraine (2)000000332
Reform Judaism (1)0000008
Reformed (French) (1)00001141
Restoration Movement (Stone-Campbell) (1)00000080
Sunni (2)00008119811960
Waldensian (1)00000014

By document

DocumentLose allThrough removedDisputedSome linksUntouchedWith linksNot assessable
Philaret's Longer CatechismShare: 87.6%19800919226385
Canons of DortShare: 84.1%3700614449
John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11)Share: 83.7%432006222516263
Christian PerfectionShare: 78.4%29002637473
Second Helvetic ConfessionShare: 76.5%9100217119159
Helvetic ConsensusShare: 76.5%1300401710
Barclay's ApologyShare: 73.3%176002935240947
Formula of Concord (English)Share: 72.9%35009448180
Augsburg Confession (Latin)Share: 70.6%1200321714
Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers, NPNF I/7)Share: 70.5%860031512214
Council of Trent (English)Share: 68.4%390011757157
Augustine, On Christian Doctrine (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/2)Share: 63.8%5100151480168
First Confession of BaselShare: 63.6%70040112
Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7)Share: 63.5%4040014884636486
Dordrecht ConfessionShare: 62.9%2200121354
Augustine, Enchiridion on Faith, Hope and Love (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/3)Share: 62.7%470018107547
Vatican I (English)Share: 62.5%50021828
Council of OrangeShare: 61.1%110043188
The Baptist Faith and Message (1925)Share: 60%1500100251
Mogila's Confession (English, OCR)Share: 59.3%86004118145109
Henry's Scripture CatechismShare: 58.8%159200411112707154
Fisher's CatechismShare: 54.7%15880044587229051033
London Baptist Confession 1689Share: 49.4%79007651600
Puritan CatechismShare: 48.6%35003347210
Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Books I-V (tr. A. Roberts & W. H. Rambaut, ANF 1)Share: 47.4%1800013664380365
The Great ControversyShare: 43.3%1300413301788
Westminster Confession (1788)Share: 38.6%660010051710
Westminster ConfessionShare: 37.8%650010251720
Heidelberg CatechismShare: 36.8%46007541254
Augustine, Confessions (tr. J. G. Pilkington, NPNF I/1)Share: 35.7%65004869182271
Scots ConfessionShare: 34.8%800123233
Larger CatechismShare: 33.5%6500114151942
Shorter CatechismShare: 32.1%340048241061
Keach's CatechismShare: 29.9%350062201171
Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2)Share: 25.4%710011594280385
New Hampshire ConfessionShare: 11.1%200160180
Belgic Confession (French)Share: 8.8%300310343
Tetrapolitan ConfessionShare: 100%40000421
Statute of the Russian Orthodox Church (2000)Share: 100%100001350
Confession of Dositheus (Greek)Share: 100%10000125

+97

Sections of the document: Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2)

SectionLose allThrough removedDisputedSome linksUntouchedWith linksNot assessable
Book I300341027
Book II00011227
Book IV30001430
Book V40002621
Book VII10000135
Book VIII20021522
Book IX30010419
Book X600631517
Book XI300691816
Book XII200551215
Book XIII200561311
Book XIV400114199
Book XV400671710
Book XVI1001323376
Book XVII200107195
Book XVIII1001462133
Book XIX400641414
Book XX1000135282
Book XXI1000611710
Book XXII600731614

Sections without changes: 2.

By topic across documents

Topics are automatic tags from a word list, not an understanding of meaning. «Loses the topic» — in the document no position of this topic keeps a printed link.

  • Salvation, grace and faith2098 of 5405

    documents with this topic: 69

    Lose the topic: Confession of Dositheus (Greek), Methodist Articles, Declaration of Utrecht

  • Sin and repentance1202 of 5520

    documents with this topic: 66

    Lose the topic: The Great Controversy, Confession of Dositheus (Greek)

  • Church and community913 of 3118

    documents with this topic: 59

    Lose the topic: Christian Perfection, Puritan Catechism, Statute of the Russian Orthodox Church (2000), Declaration of Utrecht

  • Scripture and the Word1343 of 7846

    documents with this topic: 54

    Lose the topic: Christian Perfection, Methodist Articles

  • Family and marriage1096 of 5347

    documents with this topic: 62

    Lose the topic: Christian Perfection

  • Last things and judgement680 of 3953

    documents with this topic: 50

    Lose the topic: Declaration of Utrecht, Provincial Letters

  • Baptism and sacraments521 of 771

    documents with this topic: 34

    Lose the topic: The Baptist Faith and Message (1925), New Hampshire Confession, Vatican I (English), Methodist Articles, Declaration of Utrecht

  • Authority, obedience and leadership500 of 5184

    documents with this topic: 68

    Lose the topic: What is Christianity?, Christian Perfection

  • Holy Spirit and gifts995 of 2680

    documents with this topic: 49

    Lose the topic: Augsburg Confession (Latin)

  • Suffering and trials795 of 2252

    documents with this topic: 56

    Lose the topic: Christian Perfection

Positions

113 positions under the chosen filter; the most affected first.

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XX, Chapter 9. What the Reign of the Saints with Christ for a Thousand Years Is, and How It Differs from the Eternal Kingdom · Book XX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (13 links) point into what was removed: Matt 25:34, Matt 28:20, Matt 13:39–41, Matt 5:19 and 9 more. It has no other printed links.

    • allusionRev 20:4 alludes to Ezek 9:4 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Ezek 9:4 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    But while the devil is bound, the saints reign with Christ during the same thousand years, understood in the same way, that is, of the time of His first coming. For, leaving out of account that kingdom concerning which H… Text of the position

    But while the devil is bound, the saints reign with Christ during the same thousand years, understood in the same way, that is, of the time of His first coming. For, leaving out of account that kingdom concerning which He shall say in the end, “Come, ye blessed of my Father, take possession of the kingdom prepared for you,” the Church could not now be called His kingdom or the kingdom of heaven unless His saints were even now reigning with Him, though in another and far different way; for to His saints He says, “Lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the world.” Certainly it is in this present time that the scribe well instructed in the kingdom of God, and of whom we have already spoken, brings forth from his treasure things new and old. And from the Church those reapers shall gather out the tares which He suffered to grow with the wheat till the harvest, as He explains in the words “The harvest is the end of the world; and the reapers are the angels. As therefore the tares are gathered together and burned with fire, so shall it be in the end of the world. The Son of man shall send His angels, and they shall gather out of His kingdom all offenses.” Can He mean out of that kingdom in which are no offenses? Then it must be out of His present kingdom, the Church, that they are gathered. So He says, “He that breaketh one of the least of these commandments, and teacheth men so, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven: but he that doeth and teacheth thus shall be calle

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XX, Chapter 5. The Passages in Which the Saviour Declares that There Shall Be a Divine Judgment in the End of the World · Book XX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (9 links) point into what was removed: Matt 11:22, Matt 11:24, Matt 12:41–42, Matt 13:37–43 and 5 more. It has no other printed links.

    The Saviour Himself, while reproving the cities in which He had done great works, but which had not believed, and while setting them in unfavorable comparison with foreign cities, says, “But I say unto you, It shall be m… Text of the position

    The Saviour Himself, while reproving the cities in which He had done great works, but which had not believed, and while setting them in unfavorable comparison with foreign cities, says, “But I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon at the day of judgment than for you.” And a little after He says, “Verily, I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom in the day of judgment than for thee.” Here He most plainly predicts that a day of judgment is to come. And in another place He says, “The men of Nineveh shall rise in judgment with this generation, and shall condemn it: because they repented at the preaching of Jonas; and, behold, a greater than Jonas is here. The queen of the south shall rise up in the judgment with this generation, and shall condemn it: for she came from the utter most parts of the earth to hear the words of Solomon; and behold, a greater than Solomon is here.” Two things we learn from this passage, that a judgment is to take place, and that it is to take place at the resurrection of the dead. For when He spoke of the Ninevites and the queen of the south, He certainly spoke of dead persons, and yet He said that they should rise up in the day of judgment. He did not say, “They shall condemn,” as if they themselves were to be the judges, but because, in comparison with them, the others shall be justly condemned. Again, in another passage, in which He was speaking of the present intermingling and future separation of the g

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • All printed links of the position (7 links) point into what was removed: Gal 6:2, 1 Thess 5:14–15, Gal 6:1, Eph 4:26 and 3 more. It has no other printed links.

    • quotationEph 4:26 quotes Ps 4:4 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Ps 4:4 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    This sickliness—that is to say, that disobedience of which we spoke in the fourteenth book—is the punishment of the first disobedience. It is therefore not nature, but vice; and therefore it is said to the good who are g… Text of the position

    This sickliness—that is to say, that disobedience of which we spoke in the fourteenth book—is the punishment of the first disobedience. It is therefore not nature, but vice; and therefore it is said to the good who are growing in grace, and living in this pilgrimage by faith, “Bear ye one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ.” In like manner it is said elsewhere, “Warn them that are unruly, comfort the feeble-minded, support the weak, be patient toward all men. See that none render evil for evil unto any man.” And in another place, “If a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted.” And elsewhere, “Let not the sun go down upon your wrath.” And in the Gospel, “If thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone.” So too of sins which may create scandal the apostle says, “Them that sin rebuke before all, that others also may fear.” For this purpose, and that we may keep that peace without which no man can see the Lord, many precepts are given which carefully inculcate mutual forgiveness; among which we may number that terrible word in which the servant is ordered to pay his formerly remitted debt of ten thousand talents, because he did not remit to his fellow-servant his debt of two hundred pence. To which parable the Lord Jesus added the words, “So likewise shall my heavenly Father do also unto you, if ye from your he

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XIV, Chapter 2. Of Carnal Life, Which is to Be Understood Not Only of Living in Bodily Indulgence, But Also of Living in the Vices of the Inner Man · Book XIV

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (6 links) point into what was removed: 1 Cor 15:39, Rom 3:20, Gal 3:11, John 1:14 and 2 more. It has no other printed links.

    • quotationGal 3:11 quotes Hab 2:3–4 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Hab 2:3–4 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    First, we must see what it is to live after the flesh, and what to live after the spirit. For any one who either does not recollect, or does not sufficiently weigh, the language of sacred Scripture, may, on first hearing… Text of the position

    First, we must see what it is to live after the flesh, and what to live after the spirit. For any one who either does not recollect, or does not sufficiently weigh, the language of sacred Scripture, may, on first hearing what we have said, suppose that the Epicurean philosophers live after the flesh, because they place man’s highest good in bodily pleasure; and that those others do so who have been of opinion that in some form or other bodily good is man’s supreme good; and that the mass of men do so who, without dogmatizing or philosophizing on the subject, are so prone to lust that they cannot delight in any pleasure save such as they receive from bodily sensations: and he may suppose that the Stoics, who place the supreme good of men in the soul, live after the spirit; for what is man’s soul, if not spirit? But in the sense of the divine Scripture both are proved to live after the flesh. For by flesh it means not only the body of a terrestrial and mortal animal, as when it says, “All flesh is not the same flesh, but there is one kind of flesh of men, another flesh of beasts, another of fishes, another of birds,” but it uses this word in many other significations; and among these various usages, a frequent one is to use flesh for man himself, the nature of man taking the part for the whole, as in the words, “By the deeds of the law there shall no flesh be justified;” for what does he mean here by “no flesh” but “no man?” And this, indeed, he shortly after says more plainly:

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • All printed links of the position (3 links) point into what was removed: Matt 10:28, Matt 8:22, Rom 8:18. It has no other printed links.

    What great thing, therefore, is it for that eternal and celestial city to despise all the charms of this world, however pleasant, if for the sake of this terrestrial city Brutus could even put to death his son,—a sacrifi… Text of the position

    What great thing, therefore, is it for that eternal and celestial city to despise all the charms of this world, however pleasant, if for the sake of this terrestrial city Brutus could even put to death his son,—a sacrifice which the heavenly city compels no one to make? But certainly it is more difficult to put to death one’s sons, than to do what is required to be done for the heavenly country, even to distribute to the poor those things which were looked upon as things to be massed and laid up for one’s children, or to let them go, if there arise any temptation which compels us to do so, for the sake of faith and righteousness. For it is not earthly riches which make us or our sons happy; for they must either be lost by us in our lifetime, or be possessed when we are dead, by whom we know not, or perhaps by whom we would not. But it is God who makes us happy, who is the true riches of minds. But of Brutus, even the poet who celebrates his praises testifies that it was the occasion of unhappiness to him that he slew his son, for he says, “And call his own rebellious seed For menaced liberty to bleed. Unhappy father! howsoe’er The deed be judged by after days.” But in the following verse he consoles him in his unhappiness, saying, “His country’s love shall all o’erbear.” There are those two things, namely, liberty and the desire of human praise, which compelled the Romans to admirable deeds. If, therefore, for the liberty of dying men, and for the desire of human praise wh

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • All printed links of the position (3 links) point into what was removed: Matt 25:46, John 8:44, 1 John 3:8. It has no other printed links.

    From all this, it will readily occur to any one that the blessedness which an intelligent being desires as its legitimate object results from a combination of these two things, namely, that it uninterruptedly enjoy the u… Text of the position

    From all this, it will readily occur to any one that the blessedness which an intelligent being desires as its legitimate object results from a combination of these two things, namely, that it uninterruptedly enjoy the unchangeable good, which is God; and that it be delivered from all dubiety, and know certainly that it shall eternally abide in the same enjoyment. That it is so with the angels of light we piously believe; but that the fallen angels, who by their own default lost that light, did not enjoy this blessedness even before they sinned, reason bids us conclude. Yet if their life was of any duration before they fell, we must allow them a blessedness of some kind, though not that which is accompanied with foresight. Or, if it seems hard to believe that, when the angels were created, some were created in ignorance either of their perseverance or their fall, while others were most certainly assured of the eternity of their felicity,—if it is hard to believe that they were not all from the beginning on an equal footing, until these who are now evil did of their own will fall away from the light of goodness, certainly it is much harder to believe that the holy angels are now uncertain of their eternal blessedness, and do not know regarding themselves as much as we have been able to gather regarding them from the Holy Scriptures. For what catholic Christian does not know that no new devil will ever arise among the good angels, as he knows that this present devil will never

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XX, Chapter 8. Of the Binding and Loosing of the Devil · Book XX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (3 links) point into what was removed: Rev 20:9–10, 1 John 2:19, Matt 24:12. It has no other printed links.

    • allusionRev 20:9 alludes to 2 Kgs 1:10 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of 2 Kgs 1:10 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    “After that,” says John, “he must be loosed a little season.” If the binding and shutting up of the devil means his being made unable to seduce the Church, must his loosing be the recovery of this ability? By no means. F… Text of the position

    “After that,” says John, “he must be loosed a little season.” If the binding and shutting up of the devil means his being made unable to seduce the Church, must his loosing be the recovery of this ability? By no means. For the Church predestined and elected before the foundation of the world, the Church of which it is said, “The Lord knoweth them that are His,” shall never be seduced by him. And yet there shall be a Church in this world even when the devil shall be loosed, as there has been since the beginning, and shall be always, the places of the dying being filled by new believers. For a little after John says that the devil, being loosed, shall draw the nations whom he has seduced in the whole world to make war against the Church, and that the number of these enemies shall be as the sand of the sea. “And they went up on the breadth of the earth, and compassed the camp of the saints about, and the beloved city: and fire came down from God out of heaven and devoured them. And the devil who seduced them was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are, and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.” This relates to the last judgment, but I have thought fit to mention it now, lest any one might suppose that in that short time during which the devil shall be loose there shall be no Church upon earth, whether because the devil finds no Church, or destroys it by manifold persecutions. The devil, then, is not bound during the whole

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XXI, Chapter 23. Against Those Who are of Opinion that the Punishment Neither of the Devil Nor of Wicked Men Shall Be Eternal · Book XXI

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (3 links) point into what was removed: Matt 25:41, Rev 20:10, Matt 25:46. It has no other printed links.

    First of all, it behoves us to inquire and to recognize why the Church has not been able to tolerate the idea that promises cleansing or indulgence to the devil even after the most severe and protracted punishment. For s… Text of the position

    First of all, it behoves us to inquire and to recognize why the Church has not been able to tolerate the idea that promises cleansing or indulgence to the devil even after the most severe and protracted punishment. For so many holy men, imbued with the spirit of the Old and New Testament, did not grudge to angels of any rank or character that they should enjoy the blessedness of the heavenly kingdom after being cleansed by suffering, but rather they perceived that they could not invalidate nor evacuate the divine sentence which the Lord predicted that He would pronounce in the judgment, saying, “Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.” For here it is evident that the devil and his angels shall burn in everlasting fire. And there is also that declaration in the Apocalypse, “The devil their deceiver was cast into the lake of fire and brimstone, where also are the beast and the false prophet. And they shall be tormented day and night for ever.” In the former passage “everlasting” is used, in the latter “for ever;” and by these words Scripture is wont to mean nothing else than endless duration. And therefore no other reason, no reason more obvious and just, can be found for holding it as the fixed and immovable belief of the truest piety, that the devil and his angels shall never return to the justice and life of the saints, than that Scripture, which deceives no man, says that God spared them not, and that they were condemned befo

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book X, Chapter 2. The Opinion of Plotinus the Platonist Regarding Enlightenment from Above · Book X

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: John 1:6–9, John 1:16. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    But with these more estimable philosophers we have no dispute in this matter. For they perceived, and in various forms abundantly expressed in their writings, that these spirits have the same source of happiness as ourse… Text of the position

    But with these more estimable philosophers we have no dispute in this matter. For they perceived, and in various forms abundantly expressed in their writings, that these spirits have the same source of happiness as ourselves,—a certain intelligible light, which is their God, and is different from themselves, and illumines them that they may be penetrated with light, and enjoy perfect happiness in the participation of God. Plotinus, commenting on Plato, repeatedly and strongly asserts that not even the soul which they believe to be the soul of the world, derives its blessedness from any other source than we do, viz., from that Light which is distinct from it and created it, and by whose intelligible illumination it enjoys light in things intelligible. He also compares those spiritual things to the vast and conspicuous heavenly bodies, as if God were the sun, and the soul the moon; for they suppose that the moon derives its light from the sun. That great Platonist, therefore, says that the rational soul, or rather the intellectual soul,—in which class he comprehends the souls of the blessed immortals who inhabit heaven,—has no nature superior to it save God, the Creator of the world and the soul itself, and that these heavenly spirits derive their blessed life, and the light of truth from their blessed life, and the light of truth, the source as ourselves, agreeing with the gospel where we read, “There was a man sent from God whose name was John; the same came for a witness to

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book X, Chapter 24. Of the One Only True Principle Which Alone Purifies and Renews Human Nature · Book X

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: John 1:14, John 6:60–64. It has no other printed links.

    Accordingly, when we speak of God, we do not affirm two or three principles, no more than we are at liberty to affirm two or three gods; although, speaking of each, of the Father, or of the Son, or of the Holy Ghost, we … Text of the position

    Accordingly, when we speak of God, we do not affirm two or three principles, no more than we are at liberty to affirm two or three gods; although, speaking of each, of the Father, or of the Son, or of the Holy Ghost, we confess that each is God: and yet we do not say, as the Sabellian heretics say, that the Father is the same as the Son, and the Holy Spirit the same as the Father and the Son; but we say that the Father is the Father of the Son, and the Son the Son of the Father, and that the Holy Spirit of the Father and the Son is neither the Father nor the Son. It was therefore truly said that man is cleansed only by a Principle, although the Platonists erred in speaking in the plural of principles. But Porphyry, being under the dominion of these envious powers, whose influence he was at once ashamed of and afraid to throw off, refused to recognize that Christ is the Principle by whose incarnation we are purified. Indeed he despised Him, because of the flesh itself which He assumed, that He might offer a sacrifice for our purification,—a great mystery, unintelligible to Porphyry’s pride, which that true and benignant Redeemer brought low by His humility, manifesting Himself to mortals by the mortality which He assumed, and which the malignant and deceitful mediators are proud of wanting, promising, as the boon of immortals, a deceptive assistance to wretched men. Thus the good and true Mediator showed that it is sin which is evil, and not the substance or nature of flesh; f

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book X, Chapter 29. Of the Incarnation of Our Lord Jesus Christ, Which the Platonists in Their Impiety Blush to Acknowledge · Book X

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: John 1:1–5, John 1:14. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    You proclaim the Father and His Son, whom you call the Father’s intellect or mind, and between these a third, by whom we suppose you mean the Holy Spirit, and in your own fashion you call these three Gods. In this, thoug… Text of the position

    You proclaim the Father and His Son, whom you call the Father’s intellect or mind, and between these a third, by whom we suppose you mean the Holy Spirit, and in your own fashion you call these three Gods. In this, though your expressions are inaccurate, you do in some sort, and as through a veil, see what we should strive towards; but the incarnation of the unchangeable Son of God, whereby we are saved, and are enabled to reach the things we believe, or in part understand, this is what you refuse to recognize. You see in a fashion, although at a distance, although with filmy eye, the country in which we should abide; but the way to it you know not. Yet you believe in grace, for you say it is granted to few to reach God by virtue of intelligence. For you do not say, “Few have thought fit or have wished,” but, “It has been granted to few,”—distinctly acknowledging God’s grace, not man’s sufficiency. You also use this word more expressly, when, in accordance with the opinion of Plato, you make no doubt that in this life a man cannot by any means attain to perfect wisdom, but that whatever is lacking is in the future life made up to those who live intellectually, by God’s providence and grace. Oh, had you but recognized the grace of God in Jesus Christ our Lord, and that very incarnation of His, wherein He assumed a human soul and body, you might have seemed the brightest example of grace! But what am I doing? I know it is useless to speak to a dead man,—useless, at least, so fa

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XI, Chapter 7. Of the Nature of the First Days, Which are Said to Have Had Morning and Evening, Before There Was a Sun · Book XI

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Gal 4:26, 1 Thess 5:5. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    We see, indeed, that our ordinary days have no evening but by the setting, and no morning but by the rising, of the sun; but the first three days of all were passed without sun, since it is reported to have been made on … Text of the position

    We see, indeed, that our ordinary days have no evening but by the setting, and no morning but by the rising, of the sun; but the first three days of all were passed without sun, since it is reported to have been made on the fourth day. And first of all, indeed, light was made by the word of God, and God, we read, separated it from the darkness, and called the light Day, and the darkness Night; but what kind of light that was, and by what periodic movement it made evening and morning, is beyond the reach of our senses; neither can we understand how it was, and yet must unhesitatingly believe it. For either it was some material light, whether proceeding from the upper parts of the world, far removed from our sight, or from the spot where the sun was afterwards kindled; or under the name of light the holy city was signified, composed of holy angels and blessed spirits, the city of which the apostle says, “Jerusalem which is above is our eternal mother in heaven;” and in another place, “For ye are all the children of the light, and the children of the day; we are not of the night, nor of darkness.” Yet in some respects we may appropriately speak of a morning and evening of this day also. For the knowledge of the creature is, in comparison of the knowledge of the Creator, but a twilight; and so it dawns and breaks into morning when the creature is drawn to the praise and love of the Creator; and night never falls when the Creator is not forsaken through love of the creature. In fi

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XIII, Chapter 5. As the Wicked Make an Ill Use of the Law, Which is Good, So the Good Make a Good Use of Death, Which is an Ill · Book XIII

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: 1 Cor 15:56, Rom 7:12–13. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    The apostle, wishing to show how hurtful a thing sin is, when grace does not aid us, has not hesitated to say that the strength of sin is that very law by which sin is prohibited. “The sting of death is sin, and the stre… Text of the position

    The apostle, wishing to show how hurtful a thing sin is, when grace does not aid us, has not hesitated to say that the strength of sin is that very law by which sin is prohibited. “The sting of death is sin, and the strength of sin is the law.” Most certainly true; for prohibition increases the desire of illicit action, if righteousness is not so loved that the desire of sin is conquered by that love. But unless divine grace aid us, we cannot love nor delight in true righteousness. But lest the law should be thought to be an evil, since it is called the strength of sin, the apostle, when treating a similar question in another place, says, “The law indeed is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good. Was then that which is holy made death unto me? God forbid. But sin, that it might appear sin, working death in me by that which is good; that sin by the commandment might become exceeding sinful.” Exceeding, he says, because the transgression is more heinous when through the increasing lust of sin the law itself also is despised. Why have we thought it worth while to mention this? For this reason, because, as the law is not an evil when it increases the lust of those who sin, so neither is death a good thing when it increases the glory of those who suffer it, since either the former is abandoned wickedly, and makes transgressors, or the latter is embraced, for the truth’s sake, and makes martyrs. And thus the law is indeed good, because it is prohibition of sin, and deat

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XV, Chapter 2. Of the Children of the Flesh and the Children of the Promise · Book XV

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Gal 4:21–31, Rom 9:22–23. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    • quotationGal 4:27 quotes Isa 54:1 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Isa 54:1 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    • quotationGal 4:30 quotes Gen 21:10 (per C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament», 1884); the text of Gen 21:10 itself remains; this position does not cite it.
    There was indeed on earth, so long as it was needed, a symbol and foreshadowing image of this city, which served the purpose of reminding men that such a city was to be rather than of making it present; and this image wa… Text of the position

    There was indeed on earth, so long as it was needed, a symbol and foreshadowing image of this city, which served the purpose of reminding men that such a city was to be rather than of making it present; and this image was itself called the holy city, as a symbol of the future city, though not itself the reality. Of this city which served as an image, and of that free city it typified, Paul writes to the Galatians in these terms: “Tell me, ye that desire to be under the law, do ye not hear the law? For it is written, that Abraham had two sons, the one by a bond maid, the other by a free woman. But he who was of the bond woman was born after the flesh, but he of the free woman was by promise. Which things are an allegory: for these are the two covenants; the one from the mount Sinai, which gendereth to bondage, which is Agar. For this Agar is mount Sinai in Arabia, and answereth to Jerusalem which now is, and is in bondage with her children. But Jerusalem which is above is free, which is the mother of us all. For it is written, Rejoice, thou barren that bearest not; break forth and cry, thou that travailest not, for the desolate hath many more children than she which hath an husband. Now we, brethren, as Isaac was, are the children of promise. But as then he that was born after the flesh persecuted him that was born after the Spirit, even so it is now. Nevertheless, what saith the Scripture? Cast out the bond woman and her son: for the son of the bond woman shall not be heir wi

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XX, Chapter 1. That Although God is Always Judging, It is Nevertheless Reasonable to Confine Our Attention in This Book to His Last Judgment · Book XX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Rom 9:14, Rom 11:33. It has no other printed links.

    Intending to speak, in dependence on God’s grace, of the day of His final judgment, and to affirm it against the ungodly and incredulous, we must first of all lay, as it were, in the foundation of the edifice the divine … Text of the position

    Intending to speak, in dependence on God’s grace, of the day of His final judgment, and to affirm it against the ungodly and incredulous, we must first of all lay, as it were, in the foundation of the edifice the divine declarations. Those persons who do not believe such declarations do their best to oppose to them false and illusive sophisms of their own, either contending that what is adduced from Scripture has another meaning, or altogether denying that it is an utterance of God’s. For I suppose no man who understands what is written, and believes it to be communicated by the supreme and true God through holy men, refuses to yield and consent to these declarations, whether he orally confesses his consent, or is from some evil influence ashamed or afraid to do so; or even, with an opinionativeness closely resembling madness, makes strenuous efforts to defend what he knows and believes to be false against what he knows and believes to be true. That, therefore, which the whole Church of the true God holds and professes as its creed, that Christ shall come from heaven to judge quick and dead, this we call the last day, or last time, of the divine judgment. For we do not know how many days this judgment may occupy; but no one who reads the Scriptures, however negligently, need be told that in them “day” is customarily used for “time.” And when we speak of the day of God’s judgment, we add the word last or final for this reason, because even now God judges, and has judged from

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XX, Chapter 4. That Proofs of the Last Judgment Will Be Adduced, First from the New Testament, and Then from the Old · Book XX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Rom 3:20–22, Matt 13:52. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    The proofs, then, of this last judgment of God which I propose to adduce shall be drawn first from the New Testament, and then from the Old. For although the Old Testament is prior in point of time, the New has the prece… Text of the position

    The proofs, then, of this last judgment of God which I propose to adduce shall be drawn first from the New Testament, and then from the Old. For although the Old Testament is prior in point of time, the New has the precedence in intrinsic value; for the Old acts the part of herald to the New. We shall therefore first cite passages from the New Testament, and confirm them by quotations from the Old Testament. The Old contains the law and the prophets, the New the gospel and the apostolic epistles. Now the apostle says “By the law is the knowledge of sin. But now the righteousness of God without the law is manifested, being witnessed by the law and the prophets; now the righteousness of God is by faith of Jesus Christ upon all them that believe.” This righteousness of God belongs to the New Testament, and evidence for it exists in the old books, that is to say, in the law and the prophets. I shall first, then state the case, and then call the witnesses. This order Jesus Christ Himself directs us to observe, saying, “The scribe instructed in the kingdom of God is like a good householder, bringing out of his treasure things new and old.” He did not say “old and new,” which He certainly would have said had He not wished to follow the order of merit rather than that of time.

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XX, Chapter 19. What the Apostle Paul Wrote to the Thessalonians About the Manifestation of Antichrist Which Shall Precede the Day of the Lord · Book XX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: 2 Thess 2:1–11, 1 John 2:18–19. It has no other printed links.

    I see that I must omit many of the statements of the gospels and epistles about this last judgment, that this volume may not become unduly long; but I can on no account omit what the Apostle Paul says, in writing to the … Text of the position

    I see that I must omit many of the statements of the gospels and epistles about this last judgment, that this volume may not become unduly long; but I can on no account omit what the Apostle Paul says, in writing to the Thessalonians, “We beseech you, brethren, by the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ,” etc. No one can doubt that he wrote this of Antichrist and of the day of judgment, which he here calls the day of the Lord, nor that he declared that this day should not come unless he first came who is called the apostate —apostate, to wit, from the Lord God. And if this may justly be said of all the ungodly, how much more of him? But it is uncertain in what temple he shall sit, whether in that ruin of the temple which was built by Solomon, or in the Church; for the apostle would not call the temple of any idol or demon the temple of God. And on this account some think that in this passage Antichrist means not the prince himself alone, but his whole body, that is, the mass of men who adhere to him, along with him their prince; and they also think that we should render the Greek more exactly were we to read, not “in the temple of God,” but “for” or “as the temple of God,” as if he himself were the temple of God, the Church. Then as for the words, “And now ye know what withholdeth,” i.e., ye know what hindrance or cause of delay there is, “that he might be revealed in his own time;” they show that he was unwilling to make an explicit statement, because he said that they knew. An

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • All printed links of the position (2 links) point into what was removed: Matt 24:13, 1 Cor 3:11–15. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    There are some, too, who found upon the expression of Scripture, “He that endureth to the end shall be saved,” and who promise salvation only to those who continue in the Church catholic; and though such persons have liv… Text of the position

    There are some, too, who found upon the expression of Scripture, “He that endureth to the end shall be saved,” and who promise salvation only to those who continue in the Church catholic; and though such persons have lived badly, yet, say they, they shall be saved as by fire through virtue of the foundation of which the apostle says, “For other foundation hath no man laid than that which is laid, which is Christ Jesus. Now if any man build upon this foundation gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay, stubble; every man’s work shall be made manifest: for the day of the Lord shall declare it, for it shall be revealed by fire; and each man’s work shall be proved of what sort it is. If any man’s work shall endure which he hath built thereupon, he shall receive a reward. But if any man’s work shall be burned, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved; yet so as through fire.” They say, accordingly, that the catholic Christian, no matter what his life be, has Christ as his foundation, while this foundation is not possessed by any heresy which is separated from the unity of His body. And therefore, through virtue of this foundation, even though the catholic Christian by the inconsistency of his life has been as one building up wood, hay, stubble, upon it, they believe that he shall be saved by fire, in other words, that he shall be delivered after tasting the pain of that fire to which the wicked shall be condemned at the last judgment.

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book I, Chapter 26. That in Certain Peculiar Cases the Examples of the Saints are Not to Be Followed · Book I

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: 1 Cor 2:11. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    But, they say, in the time of persecution some holy women escaped those who menaced them with outrage, by casting themselves into rivers which they knew would drown them; and having died in this manner, they are venerate… Text of the position

    But, they say, in the time of persecution some holy women escaped those who menaced them with outrage, by casting themselves into rivers which they knew would drown them; and having died in this manner, they are venerated in the church catholic as martyrs. Of such persons I do not presume to speak rashly. I cannot tell whether there may not have been vouchsafed to the church some divine authority, proved by trustworthy evidences, for so honoring their memory: it may be that it is so. It may be they were not deceived by human judgment, but prompted by divine wisdom, to their act of self-destruction. We know that this was the case with Samson. And when God enjoins any act, and intimates by plain evidence that He has enjoined it, who will call obedience criminal? Who will accuse so religious a submission? But then every man is not justified in sacrificing his son to God, because Abraham was commendable in so doing. The soldier who has slain a man in obedience to the authority under which he is lawfully commissioned, is not accused of murder by any law of his state; nay, if he has not slain him, it is then he is accused of treason to the state, and of despising the law. But if he has been acting on his own authority, and at his own impulse, he has in this case incurred the crime of shedding human blood. And thus he is punished for doing without orders the very thing he is punished for neglecting to do when he has been ordered. If the commands of a general make so great a differen

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book IV, Chapter 3. Whether the Great Extent of the Empire, Which Has Been Acquired Only by Wars, is to Be Reckoned Among the Good Things Either of the Wise or the Happy · Book IV

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: 2 Pet 2:19. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    Now, therefore, let us see how it is that they dare to ascribe the very great extent and duration of the Roman empire to those gods whom they contend that they worship honorably, even by the obsequies of vile games and t… Text of the position

    Now, therefore, let us see how it is that they dare to ascribe the very great extent and duration of the Roman empire to those gods whom they contend that they worship honorably, even by the obsequies of vile games and the ministry of vile men: although I should like first to inquire for a little what reason, what prudence, there is in wishing to glory in the greatness and extent of the empire, when you cannot point out the happiness of men who are always rolling, with dark fear and cruel lust, in warlike slaughters and in blood, which, whether shed in civil or foreign war, is still human blood; so that their joy may be compared to glass in its fragile splendor, of which one is horribly afraid lest it should be suddenly broken in pieces. That this may be more easily discerned, let us not come to nought by being carried away with empty boasting, or blunt the edge of our attention by loud-sounding names of things, when we hear of peoples, kingdoms, provinces. But let us suppose a case of two men; for each individual man, like one letter in a language, is as it were the element of a city or kingdom, however far-spreading in its occupation of the earth. Of these two men let us suppose that one is poor, or rather of middling circumstances; the other very rich. But the rich man is anxious with fears, pining with discontent, burning with covetousness, never se cure, always uneasy, panting from the perpetual strife of his enemies, adding to his patrimony indeed by these miseries to a

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: 1 Tim 2:5. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    I am considerably surprised that such learned men, men who pronounce all material and sensible things to be altogether inferior to those that are spiritual and intelligible, should mention bodily contact in connection wi… Text of the position

    I am considerably surprised that such learned men, men who pronounce all material and sensible things to be altogether inferior to those that are spiritual and intelligible, should mention bodily contact in connection with the blessed life. Is that sentiment of Plotinus forgotten?—“We must fly to our beloved fatherland. There is the Father, there our all. What fleet or flight shall convey us thither? Our way is, to become like God.” If, then, one is nearer to God the liker he is to Him, there is no other distance from God than unlikeness to Him. And the soul of man is unlike that incorporeal and unchangeable and eternal essence, in proportion as it craves things temporal and mutable. And as the things beneath, which are mortal and impure, cannot hold intercourse with the immortal purity which is above, a mediator is indeed needed to remove this difficulty; but not a mediator who resembles the highest order of being by possessing an immortal body, and the lowest by having a diseased soul, which makes him rather grudge that we be healed than help our cure. We need a Mediator who, being united to us here below by the mortality of His body, should at the same time be able to afford us truly divine help in cleansing and liberating us by means of the immortal righteousness of His spirit, whereby He remained heavenly even while here upon earth. Far be it from the incontaminable God to fear pollution from the man He assumed, or from the men among whom He lived in the form of a man. F

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book IX, Chapter 21. To What Extent the Lord Was Pleased to Make Himself Known to the Demons · Book IX

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Mark 1:24. It has no other printed links.

    Left (0)

    nothing

    The devils themselves knew this manifestation of God so well, that they said to the Lord though clothed with the infirmity of flesh, “What have we to do with Thee, Jesus of Nazareth? Art Thou come to destroy us before th… Text of the position

    The devils themselves knew this manifestation of God so well, that they said to the Lord though clothed with the infirmity of flesh, “What have we to do with Thee, Jesus of Nazareth? Art Thou come to destroy us before the time?” From these words, it is clear that they had great knowledge, and no charity. They feared His power to punish, and did not love His righteousness. He made known to them so much as He pleased, and He was pleased to make known so much as was needful. But He made Himself known not as to the holy angels, who know Him as the Word of God, and rejoice in His eternity, which they partake, but as was requisite to strike with terror the beings from whose tyranny He was going to free those who were predestined to His kingdom and the glory of it, eternally true and truly eternal. He made Himself known, therefore, to the demons, not by that which is life eternal, and the unchangeable light which illumines the pious, whose souls are cleansed by the faith that is in Him, but by some temporal effects of His power, and evidences of His mysterious presence, which were more easily discerned by the angelic senses even of wicked spirits than by human infirmity. But when He judged it advisable gradually to suppress these signs, and to retire into deeper obscurity, the prince of the demons doubted whether He were the Christ, and endeavored to ascertain this by tempting Him, in so far as He permitted Himself to be tempted, that He might adapt the manhood He wore to be an exam

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Rom 1:21. It has no other printed links.

    It is the decided opinion of all who use their brains, that all men desire to be happy. But who are happy, or how they become so, these are questions about which the weakness of human understanding stirs endless and angr… Text of the position

    It is the decided opinion of all who use their brains, that all men desire to be happy. But who are happy, or how they become so, these are questions about which the weakness of human understanding stirs endless and angry controversies, in which philosophers have wasted their strength and expended their leisure. To adduce and discuss their various opinions would be tedious, and is unnecessary. The reader may remember what we said in the eighth book, while making a selection of the philosophers with whom we might discuss the question regarding the future life of happiness, whether we can reach it by paying divine honors to the one true God, the Creator of all gods, or by worshipping many gods, and he will not expect us to repeat here the same argument, especially as, even if he has forgotten it, he may refresh his memory by reperusal. For we made selection of the Platonists, justly esteemed the noblest of the philosophers, because they had the wit to perceive that the human soul, immortal and rational, or intellectual, as it is, cannot be happy except by partaking of the light of that God by whom both itself and the world were made; and also that the happy life which all men desire cannot be reached by any who does not cleave with a pure and holy love to that one supreme good, the unchangeable God. But as even these philosophers, whether accommodating to the folly and ignorance of the people, or, as the apostle says, “becoming vain in their imaginations,” supposed or allowed o

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XI, Chapter 21. Of God’s Eternal and Unchangeable Knowledge and Will, Whereby All He Has Made Pleased Him in the Eternal Design as Well as in the Actual Result · Book XI

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: Jas 1:17. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    For what else is to be understood by that invariable refrain, “And God saw that it was good,” than the approval of the work in its design, which is the wisdom of God? For certainly God did not in the actual achievement o… Text of the position

    For what else is to be understood by that invariable refrain, “And God saw that it was good,” than the approval of the work in its design, which is the wisdom of God? For certainly God did not in the actual achievement of the work first learn that it was good, but, on the contrary, nothing would have been made had it not been first known by Him. While, therefore, He sees that that is good which, had He not seen it before it was made, would never have been made, it is plain that He is not discovering, but teaching that it is good. Plato, indeed, was bold enough to say that, when the universe was completed, God was, as it were, elated with joy. And Plato was not so foolish as to mean by this that God was rendered more blessed by the novelty of His creation; but he wished thus to indicate that the work now completed met with its Maker’s approval, as it had while yet in design. It is not as if the knowledge of God were of various kinds, knowing in different ways things which as yet are not, things which are, and things which have been. For not in our fashion does He look forward to what is future, nor at what is present, nor back upon what is past; but in a manner quite different and far and profoundly remote from our way of thinking. For He does not pass from this to that by transition of thought, but beholds all things with absolute unchangeableness; so that of those things which emerge in time, the future, indeed, are not yet, and the present are now, and the past no longer ar

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2) · Book XIV, Chapter 26. That We are to Believe that in Paradise Our First Parents Begat Offspring Without Blushing · Book XIV

    loses all printed links

    All printed links of the position (1 link) point into what was removed: 1 Tim 1:5. It has no other printed links.

    Printed links (1)

    Left (0)

    nothing

    In Paradise, then, man lived as he desired so long as he desired what God had commanded. He lived in the enjoyment of God, and was good by God’s goodness; he lived without any want, and had it in his power so to live ete… Text of the position

    In Paradise, then, man lived as he desired so long as he desired what God had commanded. He lived in the enjoyment of God, and was good by God’s goodness; he lived without any want, and had it in his power so to live eternally. He had food that he might not hunger, drink that he might not thirst, the tree of life that old age might not waste him. There was in his body no corruption, nor seed of corruption, which could produce in him any unpleasant sensation. He feared no inward disease, no outward accident. Soundest health blessed his body, absolute tranquillity his soul. As in Paradise there was no excessive heat or cold, so its inhabitants were exempt from the vicissitudes of fear and desire. No sadness of any kind was there, nor any foolish joy; true gladness ceaselessly flowed from the presence of God, who was loved “out of a pure heart, and a good conscience, and faith unfeigned.” The honest love of husband and wife made a sure harmony between them. Body and spirit worked harmoniously together, and the commandment was kept without labor. No languor made their leisure wearisome; no sleepiness interrupted their desire to labor. In tanta facilitate rerum et felicitate hominum, absit ut suspicemur, non potuisse prolem seri sine libidinis morbo: sed eo voluntatis nutu moverentur illa membra qua cætera, et sine ardoris illecebroso stimulo cum tranquillitate animi et corporis nulla corruptione integritatis infunderetur gremio maritus uxoris. Neque enim quia experientia probari

    (text shortened — read it whole in «Read»)

1–25 of 113next →

Documented parallels

  • The "golden rule": negative and positive forms

    Tob 4:15 · BT Shabbat 31a · Matt 7:12 · Luke 6:31

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • Duty to the neighbour, the near and the distant neighbour, and the stranger

    Lev 19:18 · Lev 19:34 · Deut 10:19 · Luke 10:29 · Quran 4:36

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • 'Until he loves for his brother what he loves for himself': the hadith and other forms of the golden rule

    Bukhari 13 · Muslim 45 · ArbainNawawi 13 · BT Shabbat 31a · Tob 4:15 · Matt 7:12

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • 'An eye for an eye': the Torah's law, the Sermon on the Mount and Quran 5:45

    Exod 21:23–25 · Lev 24:19–20 · Deut 19:21 · Matt 5:38–39 · Quran 5:45

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • The camel and the eye of the needle (the Gospels and Quran 7:40)

    Matt 19:24 · Mark 10:25 · Luke 18:25 · Quran 7:40

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • 'The righteous shall inherit the land' (Ps 37, Matt 5:5, Quran 21:105)

    Ps 37:11 · Ps 37:29 · Matt 5:5 · Quran 21:105

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • Six days of creation and 'rest' (Gen 2, Exod 31:17, Heb 4:4, Quran 50:38)

    Gen 2:2–3 · Exod 31:17 · Heb 4:4 · Quran 50:38

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

  • 'Ye shall not add … neither shall ye diminish' (Deut 4:2; 12:32 and Rev 22:18–19)

    Deut 4:2 · Deut 12:32 · Rev 22:18–19

    Similarity does not prove borrowing: this is a recorded parallel, not a dependence.

How the links were obtained

Quotations inside Scripture: Quotations of one Scripture place in another (e.g. Rom 13:9 quotes Lev 19:18) are known for 491 pairs: 355 explicit quotations and 136 allusions — from C. H. Toy, «Quotations in the New Testament» (1884, public domain; the book's headings and discussions, checked by shared words) and the recorded parallels.json groups. An explicit quotation of a removed place is not an independent basis; an allusion is shown as a note only. Other links carry no note: that is missing data, not a missing quotation.

How the links were obtained
  • Philaret's Longer Catechism: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the answer (Longer Catechism, Blackmore's English, as printed by Schaff)) — 324; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the answer (Longer Catechism, Blackmore's English, as printed by Schaff); Psalm verse numbers may follow the Prayer-Book Psalter, mapping to KJV unverified) — 9; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 28references read in the text: 337; new links added: 28; reference-like strings not read: 7; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 1
  • Canons of Dort: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Canons of Dort, traditional English, via Reformed Standards)) — 100; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 91; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on Romans (tr. J. B. Morris & W. H. Simcox, rev. G. B. Stevens, NPNF I/11): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF reference printed in the text (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1106; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 345; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF reference printed in the text (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); no CCEL osisRef, printed 'Acts ii:41' resolved by Versemora (unreviewed)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 31; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 22
  • Christian Perfection: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 53references read in the text: 49; new links added: 53; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Second Helvetic Confession: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Second Helvetic Confession, 20th-century English, via Creeds.json)) — 295
  • Helvetic Consensus: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Helvetic Consensus, tr. Klauber 1990, via Creeds.json)) — 53
  • Barclay's Apology: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 684references read in the text: 562; new links added: 684; reference-like strings not read: 29; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Formula of Concord (English): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Formula of Concord, Epitome, English (Schaff), via Schaff, Creeds III)) — 117; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 97; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augsburg Confession (Latin): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Augsburg Confession, Latin text, via Schaff, Creeds III)) — 75; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 61; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, Ten Homilies on the First Epistle of John (tr. H. Browne, rev. J. H. Myers, NPNF I/7): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 10; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 408; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Prov.9.18); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Dan.3.50: Greek Daniel 3:24-90 = KJV Apocrypha 'Song of the Three Children' (PrAzar 1-68)) — 1
  • Council of Trent (English): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 184; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference given in the editor's footnote (Council of Trent, Waterworth's English, via Schaff, Creeds II); given for a quotation of the decree) — 0; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference given in the editor's footnote (Council of Trent, Waterworth's English, via Schaff, Creeds II); given for a quotation of the decree; Psalm numbering may differ from the KJV (Vulgate/Septuagint/Hebrew verse count), mapping unverified) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, On Christian Doctrine (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/2): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 270; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX Psalm numbering (Ps.10.5); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX Psalm numbering (Ps.16.2); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Isa.61.10); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 4
  • First Confession of Basel: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (First Confession of Basel, marginal references, via Creeds.json)) — 157
  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John (tr. J. Gibb & J. Innes, NPNF I/7): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 130; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1920; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.131.17-Ps.131.18: Ps 131:17 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 132 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.36.8-Ps.36.13: Ps 36:8 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 37 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 23
  • Dordrecht Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 178; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Dordrecht Confession 1632, Sohm's translation, via en.wikisource)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, Enchiridion on Faith, Hope and Love (tr. J. F. Shaw, NPNF I/3): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 237; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed passage heading (CCEL ThML scripCom/scripRef)) — 1
  • Vatican I (English): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 23; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference given in the editor's footnote (Vatican I, Manning's English, via Schaff, Creeds II); given for a quotation of the decree) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Council of Orange: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Council of Orange, English translation, via Creeds.json)) — 40
  • The Baptist Faith and Message (1925): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 302; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 3; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Mogila's Confession (English, OCR): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 332; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Orthodox Confession of Mogila, Lodvel's English, via archive.org OCR); reference read from OCR text and not checked) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 54references read in the text: 340; new links added: 54; reference-like strings not read: 57; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 7
  • Henry's Scripture Catechism: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Matthew Henry, Scripture Catechism 1703, via Creeds.json)) — 2729; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 20references read in the text: 2735; new links added: 20; reference-like strings not read: 7; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 5
  • Fisher's Catechism: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Fisher and Erskine, Shorter Catechism Explained, via Creeds.json)) — 4698; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 4references read in the text: 4506; new links added: 4; reference-like strings not read: 5; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 2
  • London Baptist Confession 1689: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 969; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Second London Confession 1677/1689, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Puritan Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 255; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Puritan Catechism, via Creeds.json)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Books I-V (tr. A. Roberts & W. H. Rambaut, ANF 1): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1571; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.15.8: Ps 15:8 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 16 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Ps.49.21: Ps 49:21 does not exist in KJV numbering; read as Greek/Latin (LXX) Psalm numbering = KJV Psalm 50 (chapter level)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (ANF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed Jonah.2.11: Hebrew Jonah 2:11 = KJV Jonah 2:10) — 1
  • The Great Controversy: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 55references read in the text: 51; new links added: 55; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Westminster Confession (1788): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1788; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Confession, American revision 1788, reconstructed from Schaff's apparatus)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Westminster Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1823; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Confession 1647, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Heidelberg Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1663; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Heidelberg Catechism, traditional English edition, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 3references read in the text: 5; new links added: 3; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, Confessions (tr. J. G. Pilkington, NPNF I/1): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 968; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); CCEL osisRef Ps.49 disagrees with the printed 'Ps. cxlix.'; re-read from the print) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in VUL Psalm numbering (Ps.26.12); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in VUL Psalm numbering (Ps.22.2); mapped to the KJV psalm (chapter level: superscription verse offsets are not mapped)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (other sources) — 25
  • Scots Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 150; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Scots Confession 1560, marginal references, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Larger Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 2544; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Larger Catechism 1648, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Shorter Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 447; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Westminster Shorter Catechism 1648, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Keach's Catechism: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 470; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Keach's Catechism, via Reformed Standards)) — 0; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the answer (Keach's Catechism, via Reformed Standards)) — 8; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 8; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Augustine, The City of God (tr. M. Dods, G. Wilson & J. J. Smith, NPNF I/2): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1200; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Job.40.14); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 2; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF reference printed in the text (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index)) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (NPNF printed footnote reference (CCEL ThML scripRef = CCEL Scripture Index); printed in LXX versification (Prov.10.5); numbers assumed identical in KJV) — 1
  • New Hampshire Confession: Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 483; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (New Hampshire Confession, as printed by Schaff)) — 0; References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 0references read in the text: 0; new links added: 0; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Belgic Confession (French): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 799; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Belgic Confession, French text of 1619, via Schaff, Creeds III, marginal references)) — 0; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (printed proof list (Belgic Confession, French text of 1619, via Schaff, Creeds III, marginal references); Psalm numbering may differ from the KJV (Vulgate/Septuagint/Hebrew verse count), mapping unverified) — 0
  • Tetrapolitan Confession: Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Tetrapolitan Confession, English translation, via Creeds.json)) — 11
  • Statute of the Russian Orthodox Church (2000): References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 1references read in the text: 1; new links added: 1; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Confession of Dositheus (Greek): Proof texts printed with the position (the unit's proof list) — 1; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in the text (Confession of Dositheus, Greek text, via Schaff, Creeds II)) — 0
  • What is Christianity?: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 1references read in the text: 1; new links added: 1; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Methodist Articles: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 1references read in the text: 1; new links added: 1; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Declaration of Utrecht: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 4references read in the text: 3; new links added: 4; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Provincial Letters: References printed in the text, read by the library's reference parser — 3references read in the text: 2; new links added: 3; reference-like strings not read: 0; references to a verse that does not exist (not used): 0
  • Bavli (Vilna): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 30204; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:Mishnah label) — 4401; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 14786; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 14432; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 809
  • Mishneh Torah: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 3425; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 10723; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Ein Mishpat Ner Mitzvah) — 28381; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (commentator:Mekorei HaRambam LeRashash) — 108; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 14491
  • Rashi on the Torah: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:structure) — 7816; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 4659
  • Jalalayn (Arabic): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the edition's own sura/ayah heading) — 6230
  • Onkelos: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:structure) — 5846
  • Shulchan Arukh (OC, YD): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 62; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 5324; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Ein Mishpat Ner Mitzvah) — 15784; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed source note) — 1190; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 2
  • Riyad al-Salihin: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (OpenITI @QB@..@QE@ quotation tag; ayah found by matching the quoted words with the Tanzil text) — 71; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the text itself: source formula naming Sahih al-Bukhari) — 931; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the text itself: source formula naming Sahih Muslim) — 1227; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the source formula names this collection; the hadith itself was found in it by matn shingle containment) — 1358; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (other sources) — 995
  • Ibn Kathir (Arabic): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the edition's own sura/ayah heading) — 6171; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the unit text quotes the ayah; the edition has no heading for it) — 55
  • Mekhilta R. Yishmael: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 2554; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 168; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 381
  • Sifrei Devarim: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 871; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 950; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 4466
  • Sifra: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 759; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 2952; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 2421; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 736
  • Bukhari: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the text itself: the edition prints the quotation with its «sura: ayah» reference) — 1043; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (the quoted words run over this ayah too (match against the Tanzil text)) — 60
  • Tosefta: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 232; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 956; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 786; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 1249
  • Mishnah (Vilna): Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 7089; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 3563; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 422; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 102
  • Sifrei Bamidbar: Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:printed citation) — 308; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (text:quotation) — 564; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (printed:Mesorat HaShas) — 253; Source links recorded by the corpus (links.jsonl.gz) (dataset:Sefaria links) — 723
  • Philo, Allegorical Interpretation I-III (Greek): Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek) — 227; Links recorded by the corpus (citations.jsonl.gz): printed lists and references in the text (reference printed in parentheses in the Cohn-Wendland text (Philonis Alexandrini opera, Berlin 1896-1915), as encoded by First1KGreek; 'ibid.' resolved to the preceding reference) — 18

Reproducibility: input hash 4d04921ef676572c · corpus release 628002c692f87c7c